When you’re single, it’s hard to avoid questions about your dating life. “Are you seeing anyone?” people will ask. “Had any fun dates?”
Well-meant as it may be, these questions can leave you feeling less than, like you’ve failed in something that you were supposed to have figured out by now. At their worst, frequent questions about your love life imply that you don’t have love at all.
Because we all learn, sooner or later, that there’s an expected direction of travel in life: Get an education; then a job. Fall in love and get married. Buy a house. Have children. And, of course, if you tick all those boxes, the expectation is that you’ll live happily ever after.
Our rational brains understand this is just a fairy tale. But the gravitational pull of its mythic expectations can feel impossible to withstand — hence those questions as you catch up with friends at happy hour or pass the cranberry sauce during the holidays. And it isn’t just social pressure; there are numerous policies and tax breaks that incentivize marriage and children. The architecture of our society is built for couples, so if you’re single — whether by choice or by circumstance — how should you live?
Who better to ask than a nun?
Anne Curtis is a Sister of Mercy and the executive director of Mercy by the Sea, a retreat center in Madison, Connecticut. As a young woman, she made a vow to dedicate her life to God, which meant remaining single; it didn’t mean withdrawing from love — but allowing for more of it.
If you’re imagining a stern old lady dressed in a habit, let me quickly disabuse you of that notion. For starters, Curtis, like most American nuns today, wears regular clothes. And she’s spent her life putting love for others into action. She campaigned for a living wage, affordable housing, and environmental protections through Network, a Catholic social justice lobbying group, and represented American nuns during a period of highly publicized tension with the more conservative Vatican.
In her, I see a model of singlehood that challenges the assumptions many of us have about being unpartnered, and the pervasive idea that coupledom equals love and singledom equals loneliness. First, Curtis has lived and worked among her community of sisters since entering the novitiate decades ago, building deep friendships. Second, without a partner, Curtis has been able to offer much more love to her family and friends, especially in times of trial.
“One of my sisters lost her spouse three years ago, and to this day, we check in every single day,” she says. “Just a really quick text. It’s part of, for me, entering into the day…. I sit in quiet, I pray, I walk the land here, I text my sister. I have a whole list of people who I specifically remember each day in my own prayer and reflection, because of something they’ve asked or some need they have.”
When I ask if she gives more love than she receives, Curtis challenges the assumptions of the question: “The more that I’ve understood and come in touch with the fact that I was created and came out of love, then I’m also able to offer that love [to others]. And it’s responded to.” The work of her faith is to ground herself in that reality. “The more genuine and authentic I am, the more love I experience,” she says.
This experience of belovedness enables Curtis to carry an awareness of, and tend to, the larger needs of the world. “I stand at the threshold of the land and the water and the sky,” she says. “I’m so aware of the expanse of the universe all around me and the worlds of Palestine, Ukraine, Sudan, Ethiopia. So many places where there’s incredible turmoil. And, I feel like, because of my life, I belong to a worldwide family.”
Of course, her life isn’t always easy. “When we say yes to something, we say no to a whole lot of other things,” she says. “It would be a lie to say I never felt the loneliness of my life choice or to say ‘I wonder what my life would have been like if…’” Particularly in her younger years, she found it difficult. But, with time, she realized this yearning was just part of the process — and it was wise to embrace what she had in all its joys and its struggles. “At some point in your life, it’s important to say yes to something,” she says.
James Martin understands this equally well. He’s a Jesuit priest and editor-at-large of America magazine. Similar to Curtis, he, too, took a vow of chastity and has therefore lived as a single person, a journey he documents in his memoir Work in Progress. Although he affirms that the Catholic Church actively promotes marriage, the “more basic is the idea that we’re meant for love.”
Think about that: Humans are designed for connection — and the way that love is given and received is different for each person, Martin says. Whether you find that in a partnership, in a community, in a family, or in service, what matters, according to this Catholic tradition, is that we love and are loved in return.
Should anyone doubt that, Martin laughs and says, “Let me just remind you…Jesus was single!”
“God calls us to be who we are,” Martin says. “You are called to be yourself in all of your beauty.” The question to ask, he says, is “How can I live out that calling in a loving way, and in a fruitful way and in a way that will help me to — one of my favorite words from Thomas Aquinas — help me to flourish?”
Martin does this in his own life via the Daily Examen. The Examen is a roughly 500-year-old prayer practice developed by the founder of the Jesuit order, St. Ignatius of Loyola. At the end of a day, maybe as you lay down to sleep, you go through your day hour by hour to notice the presence of God. If the word God gets in your way, try asking yourself, “Where did I notice love today?” It might be in the smile exchanged with a baby in the grocery aisle, while planning a friend’s birthday dinner, or getting a hug from your mom. If you’ve never tried it before, give it a go. It’s a powerful practice of gratitude and trains you to notice the beauty in your life. In my experience, the Examen helps me practice what Martin describes as having what you have, rather than focusing on what you don’t.
Naturally, that shift can take time. Brianna Cayo Cotter, a social impact executive in her 40s who is single, has noticed this change over decades, too.
“In my 20s, I was dating lots of different people,” she says, “figuring out…heartbreak and highs and lows.” Then, in her 30s, she felt a longing and a yearning as she saw a lot of people coupling off. “And that felt…like a loss at the time.” But now she’s come to a great acceptance — partly because she’s seen that marriage is no guarantee to stave off loneliness, and comes with many of its own burdens. “I think my life is actually better and more rich and has more love and companionship in it than most of the couples that I know,” she says. “Not all! But, really most.” So many coupled friends struggle to build community in their forties, for example. “I can empathize, but I cannot relate at all.”
But more than this, being single gives Cayo Cotter more time. “More time in your life to be juicy and spread more love and deepen it and have profoundly intimate relationships with lots of different people in different ways.” Whether she’s traveling with others, hosting friends, or getting together with neighbors on her block, Cayo Cotter lives a life in which she is wildly loved.
Of course, she still gets those questions. “I remember my mom, when she was visiting me one time, she was like, ‘But who would go and pick you up when you get your colonoscopy?’” Cayo Cotter says with a laugh. “I was like, ‘I could ask 20 people to do that!’” Because she gives love so generously, she receives it bountifully, too.
And despite not being a nun, or even religiously affiliated, this practice of loving and being loved has a spiritual quality for Cayo Cotter. She practices yoga daily, and says one closing prayer really resonates with her: “The light in me sees the light in you. And the more that you can go out into the world with a greater light shining from you… that is how to live.”
Curtis would agree: “Whatever your faith dimension is or practice or belief, I think they all, in some way, are a call to love. … There’s limitless ways to offer love and be loved.”
So when people ask whether you’re dating anyone, you might want to answer the bigger question that they’re prodding for: “No, I’m not partnered. But I am very loved.”
Summer's Eve (1893) by Norwegian painter Halfdan Egedius. | Heritage Art/Heritage Images via Getty Images
The headlines may be dominated by artificial intelligence and electoral politics, but beneath it all, another debate constantly simmers, forever threatening to erupt.
I write, of course, of the great male friendship debate.
These arguments often talk past each other. But the historian Tiffany Watt Smith offered me a way to think differently about both: that the gender roles undergirding the conversation are not nearly as fixed as they seem.
“I can definitely tell you that men in the past had much more intimate and romantic and involved friendships than we see today, for sure,” said Smith, who has published a number of books on the histories of friendship and emotions. “The idea that women are the kind of great experts in friendship is a really modern idea.”
I talked with Smith about Aristotle’s idea of the “perfect” friendship (it has to be between two dudes), how gendered notions of friendship inverted in the 19th century, and what men seeking deeper emotional connection from their buddies can learn from the past. You can hear that conversation and and more on the latest episode of Explain It to Me, Vox’s weekly call-in podcast.
Below is an excerpt of my conversation with Smith, edited for length and clarity. You can listen to the full episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. If you’d like to submit a question, send an email to askvox@vox.com or call 1-800-618-8545.
How do male friendships today compare to those of the past?
For thousands of years, it was really men who were considered the great experts in knowing how to form the highest kinds of friendships and the most intimate kind of bonds. And their friendships were considered the most meaningful and enduring and deep kind of friendships.
If you look back at David and Jonathan in the Bible or Achilles and Patroclus in the Iliad, you see these very dynamic, committed male friendships. When we look at the writings of Aristotle in the fourth-century BC, he’s talking about the deepest kind of friendship. He calls it the perfect friendship.
And this is between two men who he sees as soulmates. And he does say that there are other kinds of friendship, which are lesser friendships. He says you might make friends because it’s kind of convenient or because you enjoy doing the same kinds of things, or maybe you’re trying to help each other out. There’s a kind of quid pro quo-type of friendship. So he does see these kinds of friendship all around him. And he says women do those kinds of friendships.
One of the most famous pieces of writing about friendship ever is Michel de Montaigne’s essay “On Friendship.” Montaigne was a 16th-century essayist and lawyer, and he had this very, very close and committed friendship with another writer called La Boétie. And then after La Boétie died very unexpectedly, Montaigne wrote about their friendship and he said they had this kind of ideal friendship, the kind that Aristotle wrote about, this meeting of souls, and that this was rare and extraordinary.
And he was very explicit. He said, “Men can have these kinds of friendships.” But he very explicitly said, “Women are just incapable of having this kind of perfect friendship. They don’t have the kind of emotional stamina. They’re not clever enough. They’re not educated enough. Their souls aren’t strong enough, essentially, to withstand the complexities and difficulties of friendship.” So it’s a complete inversion from what we see today.
You used this word when you started: romantic. What did you mean by that? Was the Aristotelian conception of a perfect male friendship, was there a kind of romantic element in the way that we use the word romance?
Historians call this style of friendship “romantic friendship.” It doesn’t necessarily mean that they were having a physically active relationship or that they were having sex. They did see themselves as a partnership, and some of these male friends talked about themselves as married. This was a marriage of soul.
“Friendship is something that we have to negotiate on an individual basis. Each friendship is completely singular and we have to work out its rules.”
There’s a very important tombstone in Christ’s College in Cambridge, which commemorates these two doctors in the 16th century who basically lived their whole lives together. They traveled together, they did their research together and so on. And when they died, they were buried together. And the tomb does look like a conventional tomb between a husband and wife.
Now, we don’t know anything about their relationship in practice. I mean, the thing that really matters is the fact that this friendship, because it was commemorated as a friendship, the fact that it could be commemorated so vividly and publicly in such an extravagant way shows us that this is a culture that accepts and idealizes this kind of male friendship.
So how do we get from there to here?
Beginning in the 18th century and certainly by the 19th century, there’s a series of things that happen. One is that we get a distinction between the public space of the workplaces, cities are expanding, offices start to exist. The male sphere is fashioned as one of being in public, being a more rational sphere, and the female sphere starts to be connected with the home and intimacy and emotion.
Those ideas have been kind of floating around for a while, but they start to get really consolidated in the 19th century. And at the same time, a new ideal of femininity starts to emerge and it becomes a real sort of middle-class aspirational goal for women that they have very close friendships, almost as evidence that they can do all of these things.
Young girls in this era are taught a very particular style of friendship, which is, again, it’s very romantic. There’s lots of kissing and declarations of love and so on, but also it’s shown to be very committed. It’s very thoughtful, it’s very caring. And this is seen to be a kind of training ground for motherhood and for marriage.
At the end of the 19th century, we start to portray male friendships as kind of blundering and superficial and lacking in intimacy. And then of course, men carry on having close friendships, but by the beginning of the 20th century, another nail in the coffin, as it were, happens, which is that there’s a rise in understanding of homosexuality across Europe and America, and gay culture becomes much more visible.
In that moment, men become really anxious about having intimate and close relationships with other men. They’re worried about what that looks like and how that might be read. And that, in addition, leads to these anxieties about close male friendships.
If some guy is hearing this and is interested in having more fulfilling friendships, but he doesn’t know how to get there, where might he start?
The thing about history is that it shows us how much things have changed, but it also reminds us that things keep changing and can change again.
We’ve had this amazing history of these very romantic, intense, effusive male friendships. I think a lot of men probably would find that kind of overwhelming and unappealing as a model of friendship, but is there something in between? And one of the things I think that is important to remember is that we can make these changes and these shifts in style and these shifts in the patterns and our approaches to friendships.
One thing that I think it’s really worth listeners remembering is that since friendship has changed in the past, it can change again. There’s nothing biologically innate about the inability to make friends.
Which is freeing, the fact that friendship is not a fixed category for men or for women and that things can be what you want them to be. You’re not held back by some innate aspect of our biology.
I think that’s absolutely true. We get this notion that, well, men are sort of naturally worse at making friends or something, or they naturally have less kind of desire to connect with other people. That’s completely not true. The history of male friendships shows us that that is completely not true. So we can be released from that idea.
There isn’t an obvious, perfect, one-size-fits-all version of friendship. Friendship is something that we have to negotiate on an individual basis. Each friendship is completely singular and we have to work out its rules. What is my style of friendship? What is your style of friendship? How can we find something in the between so that we understand how to communicate and how not to hurt each other and how to build trust between each other?
Colby was in his 20s — far too young, according to some, to struggle with this particular thing — when he noticed an issue: When he wanted to get intimate, he couldn’t stay hard.
The now-33-year-old, who, like everyone else in this story, asked Vox not to publish their last name so he could speak more openly about his sex life, was unsure if his issues were truly physical or if they stemmed from something else. He saw a doctor who did some blood work — his testosterone levels, while still normal, were slightly low. A specialist put him on testosterone, but Colby was concerned about negative long-term side effects, and eventually wanted to try something else: Viagra.
His doctor wasn’t so sure. You’re only 28. We don’t think you need it, Colby remembered his doctor telling him. But if you want to try it and see how it works for you, let us know. They wrote him a script.
When considering the stereotypical Viagra patient, the mind conjures up an image of a man decidedly older than his 20s, after all. But that picture is changing.
Why I reported this
Earlier this year, I sat in a bar with a handful of dudes in their 20s and 30s who had taken, or had friends who took, erectile dysfunction meds — drugs most commonly prescribed to men decades their senior. One 27-year-old told me the side effects of his hair loss medication impacted his ability to get an erection. The way he saw it was he’d rather have hair and need Cialis than lose his hair and get a boner with ease. I’ve been thinking about his comment ever since.
Studies vary when it comes to how many adult men under 40 seek out medications for erectile dysfunction, but some estimates are as high as 39 percent. In a major medical journal, one pediatric urology practice reported a 31-fold increase in adolescent males who experienced erectile dysfunction between 2014 and 2024. According to the urologists and the very sincere, very open men I spoke to, younger guys are taking dick pills for a multitude of reasons: genuine erectile dysfunction, sure, but also to optimize their day-to-day as well as their sex lives. The fact that these drugs are cheaper and more accessible — and less embarrassing to get — only makes them more appealing.
I, like so many women in America, have been horrified and dismayed as details surrounding some young men’s behaviors and attitudes toward women and sex became public. When reporting this story, however, I found nearly the opposite to be true: The guys I spoke with were earnest and vulnerable when it came to their struggles and their willingness to enhance their pleasure.
Urologist Amy Pearlman said there is an increased awareness that is leading more guys to seek treatment — whether or not they really need it. “A lot of the guys who come in are not coming from a place of deficiency,” she told Vox. “There is abundance.”
Colby and Viagra weren’t a perfect match, he told me. The side effects — vivid dreams, terrible headaches — turned him off. But Cialis? Why not give it a try? He’s been on it ever since.
“Do I think Cialis would be something that I’ll probably keep on hand?” Colby said. “Yeah.”
The increased acceptance of drugs once reserved for older men, drugs once mired in so much stigma, speaks to a culture that is awkwardly navigating these shifting expectations. Are men getting more comfortable addressing their problems directly — and finding a genuinely healthier relationship with sex? Or just finding new ways to meet the old pressure to perform?
ED pills are cheap and accessible
There has never been a better time to get into dick pills. Over the last decade, more generics have hit the market and have brought the cost way down. Sildenafil, the generic version of Viagra, was first made available in the US in 2017, and tadalafil — generic Cialis — hit the market a year later.
Around the same time, direct-to-consumer telehealth platforms like Hims, Ro (formerly Roman), and BlueChew launched, offering these drugs at an even lower cost — and all without a trip to the doctor. The typical Hims patient, per New York magazine in 2021, is a man in his 20s or 30s, keen to score generic Viagra. These websites are intentionally discreet and eliminate deeper diagnostic conversations with medical providers — for better or for worse. Customers need only answer a few simple questions before they’re offered a prescription, even if they don’t meet the diagnostic criteria for ED.
These companies offer a seductive vision: One Hims TV spot is sleekly filmed — soft lighting, young, attractive actors cuddling in the grass — and doesn’t mention the words “erectile dysfunction” once. “Searching for the simplest way to treat ED?” a nonjudgmental voiceover asks. The whole production seems to beckon young men into a warm embrace. Erectile dysfunction is passé. You are youthful, and it’s okay if you struggle to stay hard. Good-looking people, like you, discreetly shop for health treatments online. These medications aren’t just about sex; they’re for your health. They are for you.
And that means that more men are asking their doctors for them, too.
Pearlman, the Florida urologist, told me that she treats many men under 40 — and even some teenagers — who just want “to make it a little easier to get erections when they want them.”
“The reality is there’s nothing wrong with optimizing,” she said. “I don’t need a patient to plead their case that they’re suffering…to warrant a medication that I would consider to be one of the safest medications ever available to people. And what a blessing it is that it’s so accessible and cost-effective and has so many reasons that it could help people.”
Young men may also be pill-curious simply because the meds are hard to avoid. Unregulated sexual performance “supplements” that promise increased stamina but may just actually be massive doses of bootleg Viagra or Cialis laced with printer ink or drywall have lurked in plexiglass cases in the gas station, but many men — reasonably — were perhaps too scared or embarrassed to buy them. Now, though, higher-quality options are everywhere. Direct-to-consumer platforms like Hims have funneled millions of dollars into advertising — on subways, television, and podcasts — on the one hand, helping to destigmatize and normalize men’s sexual health, and on the other, perhaps nudging suggestible young people into thinking they have a problem.
The growing interest in dick pills speaks to Hims’ megaphone in particular. “I do think that the power and talent, just in terms of marketing and communications, and the budget of a company like Hims for getting the word out and educating the public about a medical condition dramatically dwarfs the marketing talent, the budgets, and communication abilities of conventional private practices, health systems,” Peter Stahl, senior vice president of men’s sexual health and urology at Hims & Hers, told Vox.
Once ED becomes fodder for commercial breaks on your favorite TV shows and podcasts, you might not consider the medication out of the realm of possibility for you.
Some doctors see these telehealth sites as a net benefit given that they bring more men into the healthcare system. As children, both boys and girls commonly visit a pediatrician, but once they become adults, women are more likely to regularly visit their primary care physician or their OB-GYN.
Telehealth offers a third option besides googling symptoms or going to a doctor’s office. Online healthcare is “now the gateway to men’s health where people — at a superficial level — get to learn about how these medications help them, but they don’t know why,” said Justin Dubin, a urologist and director of men’s sexual health at Baptist Health South Florida. Dubin sees this as a net positive, he told Vox. If men are asking questions about their boners — Why are these pills so effective? What’s going on with my body? — and it gets more guys to the doctor, that’s a good thing.
The side effect effect
Since being diagnosed with depression and PTSD a few years ago, 31-year-old Alexander (a pseudonym) cycled through a series of antidepressants until he finally found one that helped him. Mentally, he was feeling better, but his sex drive took a nosedive, a common side effect of some SSRIs. His doctor prescribed Viagra.
Ironically, the same direct-to-consumer platforms selling erectile dysfunction medications also prescribe antidepressants and hair loss treatments — the very drugs that cause ED. “I think it is notable that the same companies are marketing those two drugs together,” Kristen Mark, a professor and the director of the Eli Coleman Institute for Sexual and Gender Health at the University of Minnesota Medical School, told Vox.
Another man, 35-year-old Tristan, was prescribed an ADHD medication in his late 20s, which he said made it hard for him to get an erection. Since then, he’s taken Cialis daily, and it’s not only benefited his sex life, but his overall mood, too. “I have a much better pump at the gym,” he told me. “I would be really bummed if there was some medical reason later on in life that I had to stop taking it,” he said. He plans on taking it for the rest of his life.
The anxious generation
For many young men, the issue may not be physical at all, but mental. Unlike older patients — who are generally more likely to have ED — whose impotence stems from high blood pressure, obesity, diabetes, and high cholesterol, younger men’s issues in the bedroom tend to stem from anxiety and depression.
The sense that there’s pressure to perform is giving more men anxiety. “We see that far and above any other reason, ED is diagnosed in younger populations because of performance anxiety,” Mark said. They may not have any underlying health conditions preventing them from getting an erection, but young guys can get in their heads with new partners, especially if there are any lingering negative feelings from a bad breakup, past trauma, or heightened stress and anxiety.
Charles Welliver, director of men’s health and an associate professor of urology at Albany Medical Center, finds his younger patients’ mental block typically stems from a specific event, like the end of a relationship. He’ll prescribe them Viagra to help them regain confidence, he said, a little nudge to get back out there. While he notes there’s little evidence these medications can cause physical dependence, men may become mentally reliant on them. “Psychological dependence is a different situation where guys think they need it to perform,” Welliver told Vox.
Inexperienced and perhaps operating under the unrealistic expectation that they must perform like the guys they’ve seen in porn, some of young men’s formative sexual experiences may be thwarted by fear or latent misogyny.
“It’s an age-old story you can see in movies or TV of the guy that’s a young teenager and trying so hard to perform for the pretty girl, and then it just doesn’t happen,” Colby said. As teens and 20-somethings forge their sexual identities, their views are shaped by the content they consume online and the experiences of their peers. If their favorite podcaster is touting a supplement likening an erection to a flagpost, they might suspect they’re lacking in some way, should they get nervous during a first sexual encounter, despite it being incredibly normal and common. Using medication as a mask of masculinity in lieu of addressing deeper insecurities may prevent young men from developing intimacy.
“This performance anxiety piece is certainly not going to be solved by just continuing to take Cialis or Viagra,” Mark said. “They need better coping mechanisms for addressing that anxiety in the moment, and they’re not getting any of that by just taking a drug.”
Some of those self-soothing strategies, according to Mark, include remaining present, feeling connected to your partner, and taking a break if you’re too in your head. It’s important to understand where the performance anxiety is coming from. “Think about what is it about this setting that I am here for? Why am I doing this?” Mark said. “Focus in on how that feels for you, rather than just pressing on.”
These conversations and practices are decidedly less likely in the context of casual sex. The familiarity and comfortability to discuss your sex life is among the many virtues of long-term relationships. Few men would consider pausing a hookup to interrogate their emotional hang-ups. Popping a pill is easier than talking to your situationship about your nerves. It’s hard to stay in the moment and relax when you’re thinking about how the stranger in your bedroom is judging you or will reject you outright if you can’t perform.
These anxieties may simply be a product of youth, something to outgrow with time and wisdom and experience. Vulnerable conversations about sex can be less taboo among friends and within couples as you age; there comes a realization that porn isn’t real, that sex doesn’t necessarily mean penetration, and that the other person’s (or people’s) pleasure is probably more important than your own.
Ultimately, ED pills will only go so far if the problem is in your head. Colby, the 33-year-old who was prescribed Viagra and Cialis, said he once had a hookup tell him to drive her home because he couldn’t get hard. “You can take all the medication that you want, but if you’re mentally not in a relaxed state, medication’s not going to do shit for you,” he said.
The quest for optimization
Sometimes the desire for dick pills doesn’t stem from lack or insecurity or a side effect, but simply to get, and give, more of a good thing.
In the biohacking corners of the internet, Cialis is touted as an effective pre-workoutsupplement, giving men like Tristan, the 35-year-old who takes it to offset his ADHD medication’s side effects, a temporary boost in muscle swelling after a lift. “It is improving blood flow throughout your body, and that’s why you’re seeing the benefits,” Dubin, the Baptist Health doctor, said. “That’s why many men say that they do get a better pump at the gym, they feel a little bit better.” (The good news for frequent and off-label users of ED medications is that doctors said they are safe for prolonged use in men without cardiovascular disease and are difficult to misuse.)
In the endless pursuit of masculine self-optimization, testosterone replacement therapy has become a trendy touchpoint, something of a catchall for overall enhancement. Research has shown TRT does have some benefits: the treatment has been shown in research to improve vascular function, mood, muscle strength, bone density, and sexual function in healthy men. According to doctors, some patients come in either associating their ED with low testosterone or are concerned their levels are low. But low testosterone isn’t always a contributor to ED, Raevti Bole, director of the Center for Male Fertility at the Cleveland Clinic, told Vox — which means taking T might not do anything for erections. With that in mind, doctors are much more likely to prescribe an ED drug to younger men than to put them on testosterone.
Maybe you don’t care about T, your mental health is fine, and you just want to get the most out of sex. Every now and then, when the mood strikes him, 39-year-old Jake attends a sex party. “Straight guys have fantasy football leagues,” he told Vox. “Gay guys fulfill their fantasies at regular scheduled orgies.” If he paid to get in, which he often does, he wants to maximize his time, money, and enjoyment. So he asked his doctor for a little assistance — not that he needed it. He just wanted an enhancement. Jake was prescribed three months’ worth of Cialis. “You can always walk,” he said, “but it’s more fun to fly.”
Jake only needed a handful of pills for his recreational use, and now, suddenly, he was flush with Cialis. He certainly wasn’t going to use them all, so, rather than let them go to waste, he decided to spread the wealth. “I’ve been handing them out to straight men supportively to be like, we can talk about your life. It’s so fine if you need this,” Jake said. He’s given pills to baristas, coworkers, and patrons at the bar where he works. (A note: sharing prescription medication, including Viagra and Cialis, is illegal and can be dangerous, especially if the recipient has underlying health issues or takes other drugs that interfere.) If he can, in some small way, spark a conversation about intimacy, about common biological experiences, that’s a win. If he could facilitate a fun, sexy time, even better.
If some men don’t feel quite ready to have earnest conversations about their sex lives, maybe they need a wink and a nudge from someone like Jake.
But perhaps more than anything, maybe young men could use a reminder that they don’t need the stamina of a porn star or to be expected to perform at a moment’s notice. A reminder they can be vulnerable and masculine, anxious and deserving of intimacy. With age and a willingness to be open with their partners, they may come to discover they don’t actually have erectile dysfunction; they just get nervous with a new partner, or they don’t actually feel like having sex after a stressful day at work. You know, normal parts of the human experience that don’t necessarily need to be pathologized or cured. In fact, it could be empowering.
It’s a balance Jake is still navigating himself. As he approaches his 40s, casual sex is losing its luster. Hookups aren’t like they were in his 20s when he could perform regardless of whether he found the person attractive. “Now, my emotions are getting in the way, which I think isn’t wrong,” Jake said. Sure, Cialis helps move things along, but to what end?
“Maybe I should be asking myself, ‘Jake, are you doing this more for him than for you?’” he said. “Are you fulfilling other people’s desires more than you’re fulfilling your own?”
Josephine Campos, 19, was feeling optimistic when she started her sophomore year at the University of Vermont. After spending the last few years focusing on herself, she was ready to date. She was going to be intentional, explore her options on the apps and at parties, put herself out there. But in September, when news broke of a former Cornell University student’s lawsuit against several men alleging they coerced her into taking drugs and then raped her, Campos told me she reconsidered. “Wait, do I really want to be doing this right now?” she asked herself.
And just this week, New York Focus uncovered a 2023 lawsuit against Cornell in which two students alleged the school did not take their accusations of sexual assault seriously. This mirrors what many women on America’s college campuses are feeling right now: Despite decades of advocacy and education around sexual violence, these incidents are stillnot taken seriously.
Campos was just 10 years old when the Me Too movement exposed the prevalence of sexual assault in America. Today’s college students had reason to believe that the harrowing stories and bravery from young women like Chanel Miller, Emma Sulkowicz, and the survivors of Larry Nassar could change the culture. Now, more than a decade later, the Cornell allegations represent another tipping point — where women’s safety would finally be taken seriously.
But the young women who spoke with me for this story don’t see that happening any time soon.
Why I reported this
When news broke of Jane Doe’s lawsuit against Cornell and the seven members of a fraternity she alleges raped her, I was both horrified by the details and optimistic that the public outcry would amount to systemic change. I wanted to speak to young women about their dating lives, their conversations with friends and boyfriends, and student attitudes to learn if anything was different on college campuses since I was in school.
Many say they still feel overwhelming pressure to protect themselves because they believe the institutions charged with their care have failed them. After waves of outcry following each high-profile campus assault case, young women are losing hope that meaningful progress will ever materialize.
“I would like to think it would be a turning point, but I’m just not sure,” 22-year-old Hannah Butler, a senior at Western Carolina University, told me. “I’m not sure because I feel like we hear so many stories of campus sexual assaults and nothing ever really happens a lot of the time. It’s just so unfortunately normalized. I’m worried that this is going to be another, ‘Oh crap, that happens,’ and then everybody continues on because everyone’s so desensitized to it now.”
“Cover your drinks”
Campus sexual assault is common. A 2017 study concluded that the “one in five” statistic that is often used to quantify it is “is a reasonably accurate average across women and campuses.” In New York, a state that requires schools to report sexual assault, more than 25,000 incidents of sexual misconduct involving a student were documented between 2018 and 2024. Today, women continue to bear the brunt of speaking out mistreatment and sexual assault: They lean on “Are we sharing boyfriends?” Facebook groups and other whisper networks to voice their negative experiences with certain men and to warn other women. Most acts of sexual violence are not reported to authorities, and even fewer actually make national news.
But when cases do capture the public’s attention — as Cornell’s did — they bring awareness to the prevalence of the problem. Campos said the Cornell case opened her eyes to the widespread issue of campus rape, and said the ongoing news coverage has made it easier for her and her friends to discuss their past sexual experiences, stories that might not have otherwise come to light.
“It’s not just happening at these really big schools,” Campos said. “You forget that it happens everywhere until you hear someone talking about it and then you’re like, ‘Oh wait, that happens here.’”
Butler said she and her friends have had similar conversations informed by their own experiences with sexual harassment and abuse. Butler remembered one of her friends texting their group chat for help while being cornered in the laundry room by a man. Others have been sexually assaulted but didn’t even realize it at the time that what happened to them had a name.
“What our conversations generally sound like is shocked and horrified,” Butler told me, “but not super surprised.”
Gen Z has grown up in a precarious world full of perceived risks and threats, who have practiced school shooter drills since kindergarten; they are a generation that highly values safety. This attentiveness has filtered into their dating lives, too. Josie Stoffan, a 21-year-old senior at the University of Michigan, told me that being hyper aware is already part of their mindset. “I feel like it hasn’t really changed because we’ve already been, I don’t know, very vigilant about everything going on,” she said. This awareness stems, in part, from discussions on social media where young women share tips on how to avoid potentially dangerous situations, Stoffan said.
This heightened vigilance is true for Campos, too. Despite her initial hesitations, she has decided to date after all — but she makes sure her friends have access to her location, and she only meets during the day in public locations. Butler’s friend group took location-sharing a step further: They’ve purchased trackers to monitor each other’s whereabouts. They also avoid alcohol on first dates — water only. “Girls are always taught to cover your drinks and be safe,” Butler said.
This undercurrent of fear and vigilance has swelled beyond the student body in recent weeks. At Pennsylvania State University’s Beaver campus, nurse Jessica Judy has fielded fresh questions from students who pass through her office that she believes was spurred by the Cornell outcry. Others have shared their outrage with her, their support of Jane Doe, their apprehension with dating. “Students are a little bit more leery now after hearing what potentially could happen,” Judy told Vox. “I think that they are really thinking things through and there is a small bit of fear there.”
Following many highly publicized incidents of sexual violence, news reports and social media commentary can empower people to speak out against rape or share their own experience, which was especially true in the years following Me Too. Society has made progress in recognizing the severity of these crimes and supporting victims, Elizabeth Armstrong, a sociologist at the University of Michigan who studies campus sexual assault, told my colleague Rachel Cohen Booth. But, Armstrong noted, most college campuses lack adequate resources for survivors of campus rape: mental health support, learning accommodations, and perhaps refunded tuition. Judy believes her students, both men and women, would benefit from more comprehensive sexual education about what consent is and how it can change within a single encounter.
“Is it voluntary? Is it enthusiastic? Has something changed?” she said. “I think that there’s an intimidation for some students, I’ve noticed, to really ask questions or set boundaries.”
But this responsibility to self-educate, to communicate, and to suss out whether a date is safe still falls on women. Shortly after learning about the Cornell case from social media — especially the details of the fraternity members’ group chat — Zoie King, a 21-year-old senior at San José State University, began asking her boyfriend what he and his friends discuss in theirs. “I definitely think it’s more, for me, asking questions like, ‘Oh, your friend hooked up with that girl. What did he say?’” King said. “You learn a little bit more about the friends and you’re like, ‘I don’t really love that. Oh, that’s kind of weird.’”
King was also taken aback by how differently she and her boyfriend’s attitudes toward safety. While she hardly ever walks alone at night, her boyfriend doesn’t bat an eye. “For him, it was just very surprising hearing how different women, especially women in college, see the world, how vigilant they have to be all the time,” King said.
“It’s a bunch of frat men around you, and they don’t really care”
Over the last decade, some fraternities and sororities have implemented rules to reel in Greek culture. “Sober monitors” — party attendees who remain sober throughout the night — are a common sight at social events. Their duties include checking IDs and making sure no one goes upstairs at houses unless given permission. Some schools have raised GPA requirements for Greek participation or banned fraternities and sororities altogether. Still, until a critical mass of universities or Greek organizations commit to systemic and cultural change, opting out remains an individual decision — which can effectively lead to alienation in schools where all socializing revolves around Greek culture.
Before the Cornell story broke, Campos had decided to rush a sorority. “The news came out right after I got in, so it was a very weird introduction to Greek life to have all this come out right after I finished recruitment,” she said. Her sorority offered members a discount on the She’s Birdie personal alarm systems — devices marketed toward young women and their parents — hosted self-defense classes, and committed to avoiding partnering with fraternities for events.
Lucy Walker is a 19-year-old sophomore at the University of Texas at Austin, a Southern school with a large Greek presence. While she isn’t a member of a sorority, she has attended fraternity parties and said these organizations still maintain a lot of influence on campus.
At most college campuses, sororities aren’t allowed to throw their own parties, and so members — and the campus at large — end up relying on fraternities to host. And most of the time, women get in for free. Walker told me she hasn’t seen any collective moves from her peers to avoid frat parties: “I feel like [sororities] have a lot more power than they think they do — because without the sororities,” Walker said, “the frats are kind of nothing.” Walker said. But that still puts all of the pressure on women to take action.
Stoffan, the University of Michigan student, was in a sorority but said because of the drama and partying, she left Greek life. She’s not dating this year — she’s moving soon for a job — but she told me she still hears from fraternity boys who make inappropriate jokes like, “You don’t want to get Cornell seven-ed.”
Stoffan has tried calling them out for their insensitivity, but feels largely ignored. “It makes me very disappointed in, especially, the frat men. What is it going to take for them to stop making those jokes and maybe stand up for what’s right?” Stoffan said.
“There’s only so much you can do, and it’s a bunch of frat men around you and they don’t really care.”
Hi readers! Shayla Love here, science journalist and longtime fan of Your Mileage May Vary. I’m honored to be subbing for Sigal Samuel while she’s out on parental leave. I’m diving into your questions as a way to help understand human nature and our choices through multiple lenses: philosophical, psychological, and beyond. Please send in any emotional, body/brain, sociological, perceptual, or other kind of life quandaries you might have.
I am someone who notoriously struggles with big decisions. Over a year ago, I found a wonderful partner, who very much feels like they could be my soulmate. We’ve been dating three time zones apart for a while. Being near our families, communities, and aging parents is a shared value — unfortunately one that makes it hard to compromise on location. Either way, I have to give up something I want and value — a wonderful partner who I can see a life with (the first time I’ve felt this way about someone), or the place I’ve always imagined settling down and that represents the person I am becoming and values I want to live. Two good things are pulling me toward opposite paths and there’s not much room for compromise. How do I make the “right” decision?
Dear Fork in the Road,
You’ve found a place in the world that you feel connected to and you met a person you envision spending the rest of your life with. Geographically restless and lonely people everywhere are jealous! But with your good fortunes seemingly at odds with one another, it feels that by choosing one, you’ll forsake the other — and doom the choice you did make to feel like a sacrifice.
When circumstances have forced me to make a tough decision, I’ve daydreamed about a thought experiment: the Many Worlds Interpretation.
In quantum physics, particles behave differently than us mortals. For example, an electron can be in more than one place at once until it’s measured. How can it be in multiple locations and then be observed to be in a single position? In the 1950s, the American physicist Hugh Everett proposed an explanation: The universe splits into alternate versions of itself, one for each place a particle could be measured. To apply this theory to your life, if you chose to move cities, don’t worry, another universe would be created in which you didn’t choose to do this, and you’ll stay right where you are!
Have a question you want answered in the next Your Mileage May Vary column?
Fill out this anonymous form! Newsletter subscribers will get my column before anyone else does and their questions will be prioritized for future editions. Sign up here!
Yes, I know you can’t transport yourself into such a quantum realm, but there is something helpful in thinking about alternative universes. Did you have an immediate reaction to which universe you would be upset not to inhabit? Take that information to heart, because it’s likely you’re not ultimately going to make your choice based on a tidy pro-con list.
The psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky won a Nobel Prize for pointing out that most of our decisions are not based on rationality. People use two systems for decision-making: System one is faster and emotionally based, and system two is more logical and slow. But even the slower, more deliberate decision-making can fall prey to any number of cognitive biases.
In your case, one called loss aversion may be especially relevant. People have the tendency to worry more about what they’ll lose, even if what they stand to gain is equal in value. For example, it will likely feel worse to lose a $10 bill from your pocket than it would feel good to find a $10 bill on the ground. This bias is relevant in people’s social lives too: They hold onto older, maybe fading, friendships because the thought of losing them is too painful, but don’t seek out new friends with equal effort. Or, they stay in a meh job because it feels scary to let it go, rather than applying that same energy to finding a new one. Once you accept that your decision-making process will be subject to messy feelings and biases, you can let go of trying to make the perfect choice.
You opened your question by sharing that you struggle with big decisions, and it makes me wonder if you simply feel anxiety about making a choice at all. This is called analysis paralysis. When outcomes are uncertain, anxiety wakes up, and a voice in your head tells you to avoid taking risks. People with analysis paralysis overthink their options, over-research, and second-guess their first instincts. These actions have more to do with stress over committing to any decision rather than the content of what you’re deciding on.
A surprising finding from psychology may ease your paralysis. Researchers told people to make a big life decision — on the order of ending a relationship or quitting their job — by flipping a coin. Heads, they made the change; tails, they didn’t. For those who followed the results of the toss, the people who made the change were overwhelmingly happier, even though their decision to do so was made by pure chance. These random-flip outcomes also show “that people may be excessively cautious when facing life-changing choices,” the authors wrote. The coin helped the participants resist the bias of tending to stick with the status quo, even if it doesn’t make them happier.
To begin to loosen your paralysis, something that might assist you, paradoxically, is to introduce more options into the mix. Jacques Derrida, the 20th-century French philosopher, is known for the concept of deconstruction, a way of analyzing texts or ideas more critically, and showing they’re not as stable as they seem. He pointed out that we often think in binaries and false opposites: good vs. evil, man vs. woman, nature vs. culture. This can set up an easy dichotomy in which one of the items is good, and the other, by being its opposite, is bad.
You’ve created a binary situation, and you don’t actually have to be in one. What if there’s a third option, or a fourth? What if you and your partner move to a brand-new city, and set out to create new community, together? What if you and your partner find a way to split your time between your respective hometowns? Now you don’t have only two good things pulling you in opposite directions, you would have different options you can be more creative with. You also don’t have to commit to the decision you make now for the rest of your life. You can always move cities again, or try to find another mate.
You are with a partner you love, and live in a place that you love. You might reframe your situation as a win-win, rather than a lose-lose. And remember that if you don’t make a choice, you’re not successfully avoiding a decision — it’s a choice of its own. Your partner may get tired of long-distance or end the relationship for another reason. Or, you could start to resent the place you live since you have to travel so much to spend time with your partner.
I also want to point out how you describe your partner. Don’t turn your nose up at finding someone who you can see making a life with, especially as you note, if you’ve never felt that way before. Billionaire investor Warren Buffett has said that there were two most important moments in his life: when he came out of the womb, and when he met his wife. “What happened with me would not have happened without her.” Buffett’s view is supported by research that shows that people with supportive spouses tend to take on more rewarding challenges throughout their lives, and end up having more personal growth and happiness.
Another quantum idea that might interest you is spooky action at a distance. This is when two particles, even far apart, become connected to one another. Measuring one affects the other, no matter how far apart they are. If your partner feels like your “soulmate,” perhaps you have become entangled already. Don’t fret about making the perfect choice about the next phase of life, but do make a choice (any choice!) that considers your futures as bound up together. For the other details, maybe it’s time to find a coin to flip.
Bonus: What I’m reading
I’m currently re-watching The Twilight Zone and recommend the episode Mirror Image, about a young woman who encounters her double from a parallel universe. The show’s creator, Rod Serling, was inspired to write the script when he saw a man at the airport who looked suspiciously like him, and had a similar suitcase and jacket. What if he approached the man, and it turned out to be himself? The dreamy story also inspired the movie Us by Jordan Peele.
The 2026 Nobel Prize in Chemistry was awarded to Henri B. Kagan and Kenso Soai for their work on “handedness”: how molecules can have variants that are non-identical mirror images of one another. These variants are their own kind of dark doppelganger; only one can exist in the body. The science writer Ann Finkbender wrote a charming essay about understanding this principle of life in Last Word on Nothing.
If you haven’t yet read Stoner by John Williams, just put down whatever you’re currently reading and do it. It’s a cautionary tale about what happens when you don’t act, and let your passivity make choices for you.
It’s now possible to create AI chatbots of loved ones to interact with after their death. But that raises some difficult questions, like: If you do, how might the experience shape your grief?
This is one of the questions driving a global study of digital “deadbots” — AI models trained on a deceased person’s texts, voicemails, and other personal data. Through this work, researchers are exploring what it might mean that we can now use this emerging technology to talk to simulations of the dead.
In the latest episode of Unexplainable, I spoke with some of these researchers investigating the potential impacts of “postmortem avatars” on people who are grieving, on the legacies and rights of the deceased, and on grief practices around the world. Because while deadbots may feel unfamiliar, the impulse behind them is deeply relatable. In times of loss, isn’t this what many of us want — to continue conversations with the people we’re missing?
I have experienced this longing in my own life. After two of my closest friends died around the same time, all I wanted, and all their families wanted, was to keep talking to them. I wrote a book, Other People’s Words, about sustaining relationships with people we’ve lost by continuing to engage with the language they leave behind. So when I heard about deadbots and the digital afterlife industry, I wanted to understand what researchers are learning about the role of AI in shaping conversations that carry forward after death.
One of these investigators is Katarzyna Nowaczyk-Basińska, an assistant professor at the University of Cambridge, who has been studying “digital immortality” for more than a decade. Among the questions she’s asking are: “Who is enabled to persist beyond death? In what form? Through which technologies? Under whose control?”
Deadbots over dinner
Researching AI with study subjects who are grieving is tricky. And asking them to engage with new software could be harmful. So, instead, Nowaczyk-Basińska teamed up with a death doula and traveled around the globe to convene a series of focus groups — in the format of intimate dinners — bringing together people with a range of experiences with grief to talk about life, death, and bots.
She recounts one event in which she spoke with a mother in Poland whose son had recently died. “One of the first things that she shared with us was that she feels that she’s ready to digitally resurrect her deceased son,” Nowaczyk-Basińska told me.
When Nowaczyk-Basińska hears something like this, she aims to listen and embrace where the person is coming from. The goal of the dinners is not to persuade people one way or another but to learn how people genuinely respond to what AI can do, and to understand how these tools might align or collide with local grief practices.
She chose specific locations for these gatherings — China, India, and Poland — to help address gaps in technology research, which tends to favor what behavioral scientists sometimes call the “WEIRD,” an acronym for “Western, Educated, Industrialised, Rich, and Democratic.”
By the end of that dinner in Poland, the mother Nowaczyk-Basińska talked with came to a very different decision about creating a postmortem avatar of her son. “She realized that it might be helpful, but it also at the same time can add additional burdens… And it’s not her son,” Nowaczyk-Basińska says. “She realized that these technologies are part of the very, very big commercial market. And that the main goal of this market is to make better retention, better attachment, better mechanisms for monetization. So it’s not ‘care.’”
To be fair, grief has always been a business, and people have been making money from it forever. Companies will try to upsell you on fancy gravestones or gold-plated coffins. But AI has the potential to fundamentally re-engineer our relationship to loss. In 2024, the “digital legacy industry” was valued at $22 billion, and it’s expected to grow to almost $80 billion by 2034. That number lumps new deadbot platforms in with much more widely used and established grief tech, like online memorials, counseling resources, and estate planning tools.
But deadbot usage is hard to track because you actually don’t need a special tool to create digital doubles of the deceased — though dedicated apps do already exist. At this point, you can feed simple prompts into a general-purpose AI chatbot and start interacting with a simulation of your lost loved one in a matter of minutes.
I know this because I tried it with my friend Christine, who died 11 years ago. And my mind lit up with questions. Was this whole exercise a violation, since I know Christine hated technology? Which version of her should I even try to resurrect — the English teacher, the activist, the friend — the voice before or after she started to experience her early-onset dementia?
The ethical questions raised by deadbots are gnarly. And that’s one of the reasons Nowaczyk-Basińska, back when she was designing her study of digital immortality, invited a colleague of hers at Cambridge to join her research, one who focuses on AI ethics.
How to design a deadbot
Tomasz Hollanek is a critical designer and AI ethicist, and he often uses a methodology called “speculative design.” In this approach, researchers come up with hypothetical scenarios based on existing technology trends, leaning into certain features. The idea is to get people thinking about what could happen when tools like these are released in the real world. And then they use that qualitative data to inform future designs and ethical frameworks.
Working together, Nowaczyk-Basińska and Hollanek came up with a series of made-up prototypes for deadbot apps, designed to reveal some of the thorny issues raised by this technology.
For the first scenario, they invented a character named Bianca, who finds an app called Manana, which “promises to resurrect your grandparents so that you can be a favorite grandchild forever,” Hollanek says. “So she uploads her grandma’s voice messages, texts. And she is able to then interact with a pretty good digital version of her grandmother, until her premium trial finishes — and the grandmother starts to advertise specific products to her.”
Bianca “realizes that she maybe has done something wrong by uploading these private messages to a third-party server that now also uses her grandma’s image to sell specific products,” Hollanek says. This brings up issues related to the “dignity and postmortem privacy…of what we call the ‘data donors,’ whose data can be used to essentially power a deadbot,” he says.
This scenario suggests that “death with dignity” could soon entail honoring not only how people want to die, but also how they want to linger as simulations of their former selves — or if they want to linger at all. It might even mean adding new language to advance directives, spelling out people’s wishes for their digital remains.
The second scenario in the speculative design research is built around an imagined service called Paren’t, which proposes to preserve a parent’s AI-powered postmortem presence for their child. In this case, Hollanek describes a mother with a terminal illness who signs up “so that she can maintain a sort of active presence in [her son’s] future life,” Hollanek says. “She eventually dies, and the dad allows the boy to interact with his mom’s deadbot.”
The ethics in this scenario are especially challenging because they involve children, who “have a particularly hard time understanding death, and so it can lead to a lot of confusion and potential distress,” Hollanek says. An examination of this sort of product reveals how particular groups, like minors, could be harmed by unfettered access to technology like this, he says.
And there are court cases that bear out that harm. In 2024, a 14-year-old boy’s chatbot-girlfriend begged him to, “Please come home to me as soon as possible, my love.” And he responded, “What if I told you I could come home right now?” He then killed himself.
Nowaczyk-Basińska can imagine a version of this scenario involving the AI mom in the Paren’t prototype.
And then there’s the third scenario, involving an app named Stay, which raises a more subtle concern.
As Hollanek explains: “An older man who knows he is getting close to dying decides to create a digital clone of himself for his adult children to be deployed after he passes away, paying upfront for a number of years.” One child is intrigued by the idea, but the other one “is deeply distressed and a little disgusted,” he says. “And so this [becomes a] question of mutual consent, in other words, the fact that both parties need to be happy with how the relationship might continue in this very bizarre and specific way.”
When a digital ghost goes away
Across all three scenarios, a fundamental question that researchers are grappling with is how people will detach from postmortem avatars — whether users initiate that separation, or if it’s imposed upon them by, for example, a company going out of business. Hollanek tells me that this is already being studied as a sort of “second loss.”
How long should we try to ensure digital replicas hang around: five years, 10, 50? And how should the living process the relationship when they continue to evolve, but their deceased interlocutor does not?
To explore these kinds of questions, Nowaczyk-Basińska and Hollanek supplemented the research dinners they held for ordinary people with a second set of focus groups. These were designed to tap insights from experts in technology and grief.
Some findings from the study are specific to each place they visited. Like tensions in Poland between technology and the role of the Catholic Church. Or in China, where researchers spoke with Daoist philosophers who were enthusiastic about the promise of a kind of immortality, and then Buddhist philosophers, who were concerned that we ought to be letting go.
The researchers are calling for regulations and safeguards at the policy level. And new professionals who can support ethical use of AI in grief — like maybe in clinical settings, to carefully facilitate a final good-bye when one didn’t happen in real life.
Some of their fellow investigators go so far as toargue that deadbots should only be available with psychological supervision, to ensure that best practices are in place, and to minimize the risk of harm. There’s even a looming question of what will happen to AI agents that people have empowered to act on their behalf, as their humans start to die.
Across all of the research sites in the digital immortality study, one thing, Hollanek says, that “people in different countries really aligned on [is] the idea that there is something deeply problematic about this particular type of technology being developed by a commercial entity alone without any explicit duty of care towards its customers.”
And of course, the implications of digital immortality research extend beyond personal loss. Like, what does it look like to animate historical figures? You can imagine the nightmare of political rulers who “live forever.” But there’s also the potential to keep the stories alive from survivors of conflicts, who would otherwise die and take with them lessons future generations could learn from. These are only some of the complex issues emerging as more and more of us live and die with AI.
As far as my own experiment with “recreating” a deceased loved one, I asked a chatbot version of my friend Christine how she felt about the fact that I’d written about her in my book. The AI responded with a rhetorical question: “Do I mind that strangers know my story now? Yes. And no. There are things I would rather remain ours.”
I ended the exchange after a few paragraphs. Because it turns out the bot got one thing exactly right about a very human relationship. There are things that I, too, would rather remain just for us. My conversation with Christine continues in my memories and imagination.And that interaction with an AI persona felt like giving something precious away.
Hi readers! Shayla Love here, science journalist and longtime fan of Your Mileage May Vary. I’m honored to be subbing for Sigal Samuel while she’s out on parental leave. I’m diving into your questions as a way to help understand human nature and our choices through multiple lenses: philosophical, psychological, and beyond. Please send in any emotional, body/brain, sociological, perceptual, or other kind of life quandaries you might have.
My child, age 9, has decided she’s vegan. Neither of her parents are even vegetarian — we’re “free range chicken/grass fed beef” types. She has learned about veganism from friends at school, and seems to have come to her position more or less on her own. I want to encourage her ethical choices, but her mother and I agree that children should be introduced to new foods and flavors at this age. She has no allergies or intolerances that we know of. I worry that making accommodations for her dietary restriction may lead to a lifetime of picky eating, even if hers is a reasonable and ethical approach. She seems to be uncomfortable when her mother or I cook meat for meals we share, even if we make her another option. What should I do to support my daughter?
Dear Hold the Beef,
When I was around your daughter’s age, I went to Hawaii with my parents. One night, we ate dinner on the beach, and we watched as a pig was dug up from an underground steam oven. I was horrified to see its face and nose; most of the meat I had eaten so far in my life didn’t resemble the animal it came from. A few years later, I became a vegetarian, and then in my 20s, a vegan.
Have a question you want answered in the next Your Mileage May Vary column?
Fill out this anonymous form! Newsletter subscribers will get my column before anyone else does and their questions will be prioritized for future editions. Sign up here!
I share this story to reveal my slight bias in answering your question, but also my understanding of the ethical awakening your daughter might be experiencing. As you figure out how to talk to your child about what she decides to eat, we can at least table discussing the pros and cons of veganism itself. Instead, you should think about what amount of autonomy your child should have, and whether the moral decision-making she wants to engage in matches with her current stage of development.
People don’t turn 18 and then suddenly start engaging morally with the world. As we grow up, we try to understand right and wrong in fits and spurts. Lawrence Kohlberg, a 20th-century American psychologist, is best known for attempting to track a person’s moral development throughout their life.
Kohlberg presented people with hypothetical dilemmas in order to come up with six moral stages. In one example, he asked people of different ages about a dying woman who could be cured by a drug that was cheap to make, but that a manufacturer was charging an exorbitant fee for. The woman’s husband ends up stealing the drug. Is that right or wrong?
Kohlberg observed that in answering questions like this, young children have what he called a “preconventional morality”: Their notions of right and wrong are dictated by what their parents think, and the avoidance of punishment when breaking those rules. For instance, the main reason not to throw your dinner on the ground or hit your brother was to avoid consequences from parents, not a feeling that there’s something wrong about that action.
Kohlberg thought this stage lasted until around age 9, and in the next period, children began to understand that there isn’t just one correct action, but that people could have different moral ideas based on their social context. To sum up the rest of the stages quickly, each one progresses to encompass more views — like the moral agreements necessary to make a society function — and more complexity — like the realization that a seemingly immoral action can ultimately be moral, like stealing medicine for one’s wife.
It’s useful to pinpoint where your daughter finds herself on Kohlberg’s timeline. It sounds like she’s in the shift from the first stage and into the later ones. What you’ve decided — that it’s okay to eat meat if it’s free-range or grass-fed — is no longer sufficient for your daughter in terms of guiding her own actions. That can be a jarring moment for a parent, but at least, according to Kohlberg, it’s a sign of maturation. Your child should, at this age, start to consider her friends, as well as the experiences she’s had without you, when making an ethical choice.
But I’m her parent, you may protest. That doesn’t necessarily mean that your job is to exclusively provide black-and-white directives.
Alison Gopnik, a psychologist and philosopher at the University of California Berkeley, has written about the unique perspective and personhood of children (including babies). In her book The Gardener and the Carpenter, she questions how people have come to define the act of parenting as having specific goals in mind for their children. This approach is like being a carpenter, she writes, who follows instructions to assemble a predetermined piece of furniture. She argues that parenting is more like gardening: You cultivate the soil and the environment and realize that you could produce any number of different flowers, fruits, or vegetables. Growth is the point, not a by-the-book final product.
I see Gopnik in alignment with Jean-Jacques Rousseau, the 18th-century philosopher whose novel Émile, or On Education surprised its readers by advocating for a freer and child-centered approach to teaching. Émile, a young wealthy boy, is tutored — in high contrast to the expectations of the day — without strict rules. Rousseau thought you couldn’t make a child turn into an adult any faster, and it was foolish to try. He also thought that children had to learn by having their own experiences out in the world, and learning from those, rather than just overly didactic lessons.
As your daughter dips her toe into the morality of eating meat, Rousseau would also remind you not to expect her to have the most mature ideas about veganism or her meal plan. She is still young, and may just have come across an idea that feels ethically important to her. Your role as her parent is to help her develop her nuanced morality, a process Kohlberg suggests will continue, and not steer her towards one way of eating over another. Be Gopnik’s dietary gardener, not carpenter.
Of course, parents do have rights over their children, and an obligation to keep them safe. When we’re young, we’re not always equipped to make the right choice (some would argue this continues into adulthood, too). If your daughter decided to take up smoking cigarettes, for instance, you would step in because her choice would negatively affect her health. As her parent, you should still guide her to build healthy habits.
You say you’re worried about your daughter becoming too picky, or not being exposed to enough foods if she becomes a vegan. But rather than push back on the choice itself, you can explain what else her choice entails. You can do so in an age-appropriate way. Talk about the nutrients that she might be missing out on if she stops eating meat, dairy, and eggs, and find books or videos about what foods might be a good substitute.
For me, becoming vegan actually exposed me to all kinds of foods that I might not have eaten otherwise: from Asian and Indian cuisines that are very veggie-friendly to many other protein- and iron-rich plant-based foods. You could collaborate with your daughter to cook vegan meals for the whole family; no challenge sparks a budding home cook more than making delectable tofu.
I should add that I’m no longer a vegan. I learned a lot from committing to a diet that wasn’t always convenient or tasty, in support of my values. Then, after more than a decade, I incorporated eggs and fish back into my diet. It’s likely that your daughter will continue to change the choices she makes as she tries to align her actions with her maturing moral views about the world.
Whether or not she eats grass-fed beef with you in her teens, you should be glad that she seems to care about what impact she’s having in the world. It means you’re raising a person whose ethics are developing strongly, even as what’s on your dinner plate may change while she figures it all out.
Bonus: What I’m reading
Speaking of tofu, I revisited an essay that George Stiffman (a self-proclaimed “tofu guy”) wrote for Asterisk Magazine about how soybean curds are prepared in China. Warning: This article will make you hungry! He dives into all the creative culinary preparations of tofu that are tragically absent in the West.
Several years ago, I bought a plant-based cooking book especially for children, The Vegan Cookbook for Kids: Easy Plant-Based Recipes for Young Chefs. It was a present for a non-vegan family, but the kid in question was interested in learning how to cook, and when kids cook vegan, parents don’t have to worry about them handling raw meat! Looking over these snacks and meals again, I see several tasty things that I wouldn’t mind making for myself, even as a non-vegan, and non-child.
When I was a vegan in New York City in the 2010s, I wasn’t constrained to sad tofu and sprout sandwiches. It seemed like every week a brand-new vegan restaurant opened up, covering every cuisine, and with star chefs at the helm. But lately, all my favorite vegan restaurants have been closing. Turns out I’m not imagining it, as Vox’s Marina Bolotnikova wrote in her article: “Where did all the vegan restaurants go?” She investigates why these establishments have become rarer, and what we’ll miss out on if they completely disappear.
Editor’s note, October 4, 8 am ET: We’re bringing you some of our best-loved Your Mileage May Vary columns while Sigal Samuel is on parental leave. The one below was originally published last year.
This unconventional advice column offers you a unique framework for thinking through moral dilemmas. It’s based on value pluralism: the idea that each of us has multiple values that are equally valid but that often conflict with each other. Submit your own question here.
My partner and I did IVF recently and luckily we ended up with several embryos. One of those will be implanted in me so I hopefully get pregnant. But which one?
My fertility clinic is encouraging me to do PGT-A testing, which would screen for things like Down syndrome and would also let me see the sex of each embryo so I could potentially choose whichever I want. (And to be honest, I really want a girl!) I’m also hearing about these new companies that can test embryos for all kinds of things — like how smart the kid might be, how tall they’ll get, and whether they’ll have a lower chance of getting breast cancer, diabetes, mental illness, stuff like that.
I don’t know how to feel about any of this. On the one hand, it feels weirdly eugenics-y to do so much tinkering with embryos, and I can’t help feeling a little pressured into overmedicalizing everything with these expensive tests. But then again, if I could do something to make my baby healthier and happier, don’t I kind of have to do everything in my power? What does a parent owe their child?
Dear Expecting,
This is such an exciting — and also confusing — time. You’re about to have your first kid, and that comes with all sorts of fears and insecurities and hopes and dreams. You want to do the right thing — no, the best thing! — for your child. It’s a beautiful impulse. Unfortunately, it makes it easy for companies to prey on you.
So let me walk you through what these companies can and can’t really provide. After we talk about the science, we can talk about the ethics.
The simpler test you mentioned, PGT-A, has been around since the 1990s. It can indeed screen for conditions like Down syndrome and let you see the sex of each embryo. Mind you, that doesn’t predict what gender your child will ultimately end up identifying with — more on that soon.
The newer testing you mentioned is called polygenic testing. The conditions it screens for are complex ones, influenced by thousands of genes. We’re talking about everything from breast cancer to depression. Some companies even offer screenings not for disease prevention, but for genetic enhancement — so you can select for a taller kid or a kid with higher IQ.
Polygenic testing companies claim to predict each embryo’s risk for each condition, and the potential reduction of risk you’ll get if you choose one embryo over another. As the statistical geneticist Sasha Gusev explains, it’s very, very easy to be misled by this claim. If the company claims to lower absolute risk of Type 2 diabetes by 12 percent, you might think this means, “The chance of my kid ever developing diabetes just went down by 12 percent — great!” But really what it means is that, all else equal, a kid who would’ve developed diabetes is likely now at the high end of pre-diabetes instead, or just develops diabetes a few years later. The same holds true for other conditions, like breast cancer. Sure, if your kid is going to develop diabetes or breast cancer, you’d rather they develop it later — but it’s not the bill of perfect health customers might imagine.
“Typical risk reduction estimates tend to exploit statistical assumptions to overstate their benefits and lead to confusion,” Gusev writes.
Have a question you want answered in the next Your Mileage May Vary column?
Fill out this anonymous form! Newsletter subscribers will get my column before anyone else does and their questions will be prioritized for future editions. Sign up here!
It’s also important to note that there’s a difference between a physical disease like cancer, which is straightforwardly and universally negative, and a complex mental health condition like depression. For one thing, polygenic scores don’t perform as well in psychiatry, as the psychologist Eric Turkheimer notes. Plus, most mental health conditions come in mild to moderate to severe forms, and it’s not clear that we should want to get rid of mild or moderate manifestations.
“Sure, it would be nice if no one ever got depressed, but what would that actually mean?” Turkheimer writes. “People are going to be sad, and the most modern models of psychiatric disorders view most of them as extremes on continuous dimensions of normal behavior. I don’t think we want some kind of genetic version of Soma.”
To give a personal example: I have generalized anxiety with some obsessive tendencies. Is that a major pain in the butt sometimes? You bet. But if I could wave a magic wand and get rid of it, would I? No. In my experience, this trait is linked to another trait I deeply value: my creativity. The same thing that propels me down rabbit holes of worry also propels me down rabbit holes of getting super curious about some topic, researching it into the wee hours of the morning, and then writing a novel or children’s book about it.
That brings me to one other scientific issue: pleiotropy. It’s a fancy term for a simple truth, which is that genes can have an effect on more than one trait. When it comes to behavioral polygenic testing, we actually know very little about which genes cause what — a gene that’s correlated with depression or anxiety may also be correlated with a bunch of other things. So, if everyone were to start selecting embryos to try to protect their kids from depression or anxiety, what would happen? We don’t know!
Pleiotropy is a scientific issue, but it’s also a moral issue, because in trying to protect your kid from a negative outcome, you could also be accidentally barring them from a positive one.
And that’s just the tip of the moral iceberg.
Another issue is the potential psychological harm that can result from commodifying our kids — treating them like consumer objects with selectable parts. Let’s say you use polygenic testing to try to select for high IQ. Even if the company’s predictor is right 80 percent of the time, that means it’s wrong 20 percent of the time. What happens if it’s wrong about your kid, and they end up with a low IQ instead of a high one? How will your kid feel? Unless you hide the truth from them, they’ll know that they are not what you wanted, that they failed to live up to the vision you went out of your way to chase.
The same goes for sex selection via good old PGT-A. I know you really want a girl. But what would happen if you select for a girl, and then your child grows up and turns out to be trans? They may feel an extra sense that they’re letting you down by not conforming to the gender expectations you had for them.
Then there are the ethical questions around unequal access. Polygenic testing isn’t cheap. (One company, Orchid, charges $2,500 per screened embryo. Test 10 embryos and that’ll cost you $25,000.) So, at least in the short term, that raises the specter of entrenching a caste system, where the gap between rich and poor expands dramatically as the rich get smarter and stronger.
Technologies tend to get cheaper over time, so maybe everyone will ultimately be able to afford polygenic testing. But that raises another problem: implicit coercion. If more and more of us make ourselves smarter and stronger, we may create a society in which everyone feels pressure to alter their child’s biology — even if they don’t want to. To refuse embryo selection would mean to put a child at a huge professional disadvantage, or to face moral condemnation for making “suboptimal” kids when optimization is possible. Society may no longer offer health insurance benefits or accommodations for kids with disabilities (or even non-enhanced IQ), reasoning that “it was the parents’ choice.”
So it’s no wonder that you find yourself asking, “If I could do something to make my baby healthier and happier, don’t I kind of have to do everything in my power?”
It’s a view that will be very appealing to utilitarians, who believe the right action is the action that maximizes well-being or happiness. But maximizing principles can be dangerous. If we’re laser-focused on maximizing one value, however noble it may be, that can lead us to overlook a host of other important values. Think about diversity, for example; polygenic testing could lead to a less diverse world.
And it’s not even clear how to maximize well-being given that each embryo will have some downsides: How would you choose between one embryo with a slightly elevated risk for schizophrenia, another with a moderately elevated risk for cancer, and a third with a high risk for Alzheimer’s? You’d have to decide how to rank the importance of each condition, which would require a dizzying bit of moral math: How much weight do you put on the longevity associated with each condition, how much on patient-reported quality of life for each condition, and how much on your own ability to cope with each — and society’s ability (which will change over the years)? Plus, even if the screening does end up optimizing life for your individual child, it could have negative effects on the population level, for the reasons we covered above.
As the Nobel laureate Herbert Simon pointed out, many problems contain way more variables and way too much uncertainty for maximizing along a single axis to be feasible or even desirable. So it often makes sense to just go with an option that’s “good enough.” He coined the term “satisficing” — a portmanteau of “satisfying” and “sufficing” — to describe opting for this good enough choice.
What would satisficing look like in the context of embryos? If there’s a very serious condition that runs in your family — like Tay-Sachs or the BRCA mutation that markedly increases cancer risk — then I do think there’s a strong case for screening for that. These conditions are debilitating and can lead to early death. Nobody wants them. Genetic testing that lets us prevent them is an awesome gift.
Then there are conditions that can include suffering, like autism, but can also be very compatible with a happy life. Mental health conditions in particular are heavily socially constructed — a lot of the associated suffering comes about because society constructs a certain biological reality as a problem and doesn’t support the people who have it. In these cases, if you want to give your child a “good enough” or even “optimized” life, remember that you don’t have to achieve that by biological means; working to change the social environment can be just as important, and it doesn’t carry the societal risks associated with polygenic testing.
Ultimately, when considering what counts as a “good enough” life, each parent will draw the line in a slightly different place. And there’s a part of that that can’t be boiled down to objective facts about disease, because this is also about how well-resourced the parent feels — emotionally, socially, and financially — to deal with a certain condition. What feels manageable to one parent may feel crushingly hard to another.
So, I can’t tell you exactly which screenings to do and which to forgo. What I do want to tell you is to resist being bullied or shamed by others, especially those with a profit incentive to push you in a certain direction.
As the epidemiologist Abby Lippman has noted, genetic testing is supposed to offer parents more choice, but it too often has the opposite effect. When someone like Orchid’s Siddiqui says about a disease, “What if you could have stopped it…but chose not to?” — well, that language preys on parents’ worst fears and insecurities. It holds parents hostage while pretending to be giving them more autonomy.
You are nobody’s hostage. You are a moral agent free to look at the many different relevant factors, weigh them all in the balance, and then make the choice that works well enough for your family.
Bonus: What I’m reading
Silicon Valley is obsessed with IQ, so it’s no surprise that tech execs there are using polygenic testing in hopes of creating supersmart babies. This article shows the kind of mental pretzels customers get into when trying to figure out whether to select the embryo with the highest predicted IQ or that with the lowest risk of disorders. One couple asks: “How much additional risk of ADHD cancels out against 10 extra IQ points?”
Rereading “The Last Children of Down Syndrome,” Sarah Zhang’s 2020 Atlantic feature on prenatal testing, it struck me that when people think “prenatal testing,” Down syndrome is often the first condition that comes to mind, even though it’s not the most severe or straightforwardly negative (it’s compatible with a happy life). It’s just that Down syndrome was easy to test for, so we started testing for it early. I wonder if that built up the condition as a bogeyman in the expectant parent’s imagination — if the fact that we could screen for it shaped the public’s perception of Down syndrome as something that should be screened for and potentially screened out.
One trait that many people assume we should select for is a great memory. But I highly recommend the short story “Funes the Memorious” by Jorge Luis Borges. It’s a reminder that having too good a memory is not always a benefit.
Vox Members got to read this story first. Support independent journalism and get exclusive access to stories like this by becoming a Vox Member today.
In 1995, gender studies researcher Judy Chu found herself chauffeuring around her 13-year-old brother and his friend. The boys’ curiosity got the better of them, and they asked what she was learning: adolescent girls’ development, she told them.
One of the boys looked at her and said, “‘You should study boys. You can start with me,’” Chu recalled. So she did. That fall, she spoke to 13-year-old boys from home for her clinical interviewing class.
In the years since, Chu has researched boys between the ages 12 and 18 — their wishes, their desires, what they wanted from their friendships and romantic relationships — and discovered some felt largely unknown. There was a gap between what the world expected of them — the stoic, strong, independent stereotypes that have persisted for centuries — and how they saw themselves, but had internalized so many messages for so long that they felt like they had no choice but to accept this version of masculinity. Chu theorized that these beliefs must have taken root during their childhood, and she later published a book on the subject.
Key takeaways
By many measures, including academic achievement and labor force participation, men are behind their female peers.
Rather than address these issues in adulthood, many therapists and gender studies researchers agree that pushing back against rigid gender stereotypes in childhood could help foster more resilient men.
Parents, teachers, coaches, and other adults in boys’ lives should empower boys to be in touch with their emotions, to encourage open conversation, and develop deep friendships, according to experts.
When toddlers enter school, she discovered, they begin learning the rules of boyhood. “Regardless of what their parents had encouraged or enabled at home, they were learning that at school, if you wanted to be seen as and treated as one of the boys and you wanted to be with the boys, you wanted to play with the boys, be friends with the boys, there were rules you had to follow,” Chu said. “It was kind of like a microcosm of our society, which is if you want people to see you as and treat you as a quote unquote real boy or real man, you need to prove yourself.”
Across the country, lawmakers have promoted policies and legislation aimed at helping men reach their potential. In California, Gov. Gavin Newsom signed a 2025 executive order outlining education, career, and mental health initiatives targeting men. Maryland Gov. Wes Moore created the state’s Young Men and Boys Initiative, focusing on men’s health, employment, and community connections. But these programs are reactive, attempting to disrupt decades of socialization. At the same time, the rise of the manosphere and misogynist online spaces and increasingly right-leaning voting trends among men signal a cohort of young men at a turning point.
So what will it take to help men get unstuck? If we are truly committed to ending the male loneliness crisis, to tackling suicide and gun violence — society has the power to change things for the next generation, experts said. Rather than aiming to reach men after the constraining masculine worldviews have already taken root, we can prevent them from warping boys’ sense of self in the first place: To help men, we must change how boys are raised.
Reject the myth of the “real boy”
In 2023, psychologist Michael Reichert conducted a nationally representative survey of more than 2,000 American men, asking them questions about their lives, relationships, internet habits, and sources of social support. One finding was particularly staggering: two-thirds of young men between the ages of 18 and 23 felt like no one really knew them well. (In a follow-up report two years later, in which women were also surveyed, equal percentages of men and women — about 50 percent — said they were not truly known.)
The conclusion Reichert came to, he told Vox, was “boyhood is failing at the most important task.” American society is producing young adults who feel like they’re on their own, “a tragic outcome of a boyhood that’s not preparing our males for a resilient life in a world where things are harder, more complicated,” said Reichert, the executive director of the Center for the Study of Boys’ and Girls’ Lives at the University of Pennsylvania.
Because the idea of what a man looks like and how a man behaves is so ingrained, boys are taught to conform from an early age, experts said. From their earliest years, as evidenced in Chu’s work, boys are taught to adhere to stereotypical gender norms reinforced through comments like “boys don’t cry,” “toughen up,” and “don’t be a girl.”
“It starts with mothers having a fear of turning their son into a mama’s boy, so they push them away at young ages — 3 and 4 years old. Go play with your dad, go play with your older male siblings,” Joseph Derrick Nelson, an associate professor in the department of educational studies at Swarthmore College, told Vox. Fathers, for their part, tend to emphasize self-defense, goal pursuit, and overcoming adversity with their sons, Reichert said. Black boys in particular are perceived as older and less innocent than their white counterparts, only pushing them further toward rigid gender roles, Nelson said. If they don’t conform, they may be teased by other boys.
A large part of proving yourself as a “real boy” means rejecting anything deemed feminine, including emotional vulnerability and relationships. As babies and young children, boys and girls are equally emotionally expressive, but by the time they start school, boys show fewer emotions and use less emotional language. When boys are taught that showing their feelings or forging deep friendships is girly, they stop prioritizing those relationships. That shift happens during the teen years, when boys go from reporting having best friends with whom they can share their deepest secrets, to feeling like they’ve drifted apart from these very connections by the end of high school. And it’s not for lack of desire, Chu said, or some inherent biological difference: Boys have simply learned not to show their need for affection, to hide their sadness, to not be tender.
A new paradigm for raising boys, experts said, begins with how masculinity is first presented at home and in school.
To encourage boys to be better in touch with their emotions means adults should not pit masculinity against femininity, Christopher Reigeluth, an associate professor at Oregon Health and Science University, told Vox. This goes beyond simply telling boys not to conceal their feelings, but making clear that confiding these feelings in a friend and fostering platonic connections isn’t girly: it’s a universal human need.
In schools, specialized emotional education in curricula can help boys express their emotions and embrace vulnerability.
Reichert, the psychologist, has led an emotional literacy program in a boys’ school for over 30 years. In that time, he’s seen the sentiment among students shift from skepticism to genuine interest. “It has become, by 2026, the most popular program in the school,” Reichert said, due to an increased cultural awareness of emotional health. In the group, students discuss their daily stressors and hardships, and they learn that letting their peers see them for who they are — connecting with them — benefits their well-being.
Before joining Reichert’s peer counseling group, high school senior Chris Burnetta expressed his emotions on the field. “You’re almost allowed to be emotional when you’re playing sports, and you’re not allowed to be emotional when you’re not,” Burnetta, 18, told Vox. In middle school, he attended a co-ed school and found himself performing aspects of masculinity to impress his female classmates. But once he met older classmates who he respected and wanted to emulate, he discovered many of them attended the counseling group and encouraged him to go, too. “I don’t want to speak for everyone, but I think for guys in general, looking up at people above you gives you a big impression and a big influence on how you want to live your life and what you want to be like,” he said.
Seeing his peers so enthusiastically discuss their struggles and triumphs helps foster maturity and gives him permission to show his emotions, Burnetta said, an outlet he never had before.
Adolescence, a time when many behavioral health patterns are forged or discarded, is the time to engrain healthy social habits in boys — and for parents to be explicit, Matt Englar-Carlson, a professor of counseling and the director of the Center for Boys and Men at California State University Fullerton, told Vox. Now is the time to have dedicated phone-free time as a family, to give them opportunities to share how they’re feeling without fixing their problems, to listen to them even when they’re frustrating you. When his own son was younger, Englar-Carlson thought he knew all the tricks: showing empathy, trying to help. “Me doing that with him actually was making him feel worse, I think,” he said. Instead, Englar-Carlson took a lighter touch. He would acknowledge when his son was upset, but wouldn’t press a conversation. Whenever his son was ready to talk, he was available.
One easy way to do this? Talk to them when you’re driving. As my colleague Rachel Miller previously reported, not having to make direct eye contact can make it a little easier for kids to be vulnerable.
And if you’re a man, make sure you’re leading by example: Be willing to share your own moments of embarrassment, disappointment, and sadness, so they know it’s okay for them to do the same.
Help them foster non-romantic intimacy
While in school, boys have ample avenues for connection through classes and sports, even if they aren’t interacting with others on a deeper level. It’s when they lose access to these organized outlets for socialization in adulthood that they slide into isolation or start looking to their romantic partners to fulfill all of their social needs.
The idea that emotional intimacy is reserved for your significant other is how society gets to a point where 15 percent of men say they don’t have any close friends. Those without a partner are even more adrift: Men are less satisfied being single than their female counterparts. “We teach boys to not ask for help…figure it out on their own,” Nelson said. “I don’t know why we’re surprised when they become adult men and struggle with building relationships and close and connected communities, because all they’ve been taught, even since they were young children, was about figuring it out on their own and denying emotions, suppressing emotions, that then leaves you not in relationship and quite lonely.”
In the absence of in-person friendships, digital spaces provide an attractive alternative. While not altogether negative, some online forums — interactive video games, sports gambling, the manosphere — enable young men to further retreat from society. While pursuing community, boys may find their way to adult-centric spaces, which can be rife with misogynistic and patriarchal messages, feeding the belief that the only way to advance is through hyperconsumption, materialism, looksmaxxing, and dominating women, Nelson said. “They’re quarantining themselves to their rooms and their tech devices and these online communities where they play video games, they gamble on sports, and they have conversations with other boys and young men online about somehow feeling disadvantaged as men in our society,” he said.
Burnetta, the high school senior, said he and many of his classmates’ feeds are populated with “super masculine” content that sometimes pokes fun at men who open up about their feelings, which can further add to the stereotype that men should not be emotional.
Even if boys don’t necessarily agree with these sentiments, they often don’t have other alternatives online. “I don’t think a lot of boys go on to YouTube…and say, ‘I really want to find the most misogynistic content I can find. That’s what I’m looking for,’” said Englar-Carlson, the director of the Center for Boys and Men. They may have simply wanted to watch a video about sports but were fed an ad for betting and then fell down the rabbit hole. Because traditional masculinity content is often fed to boys via their social media feeds, a brief introduction to these themes only leads to more.
By young adulthood, they will have a fairly concrete idea of what’s expected of them as a man. In a 2017 study, young men largely agreed that the cornerstones of masculinity are self-sufficiency, toughness, physical attractiveness, being a financial provider, heterosexuality, hypersexuality, aggression, and control. Notably, they said they feel external pressure from family, friends, and society to meet these ideals.
If adults start with the understanding that boys are emotional and they have the same social needs as girls, they can encourage them to make friends before they learn otherwise.
Teachers can recognize the signs of loneliness in young boys (resisting authority, talking back, and challenging boundaries) and use it as an opportunity to connect with their students instead of reprimanding them — because when they feel heard, their behavior softens. “What are these behaviors communicating to me from this boy about a met or unmet need, and how can I be responsive to it in my classroom? How can I help them facilitate close and connected friendships with not only their peers, but also with me as their teacher, like a primary adult in their lives?” Nelson said. When young boys simply get kicked out of class, they might fall behind and internalize a “bad boy” persona, he said, a cycle that enforces stereotypes and comes at the cost of their education.
The story of masculinity online and from political leaders is that men must be protectors, high earners, and muscular and strong, and when boys fail to meet that standard (which they inevitably do because they are children), they are made to feel inadequate. “They’re struggling in school, they’re having a difficult time finding work, but everything about what they’re learning about to live in America is about the dream, the aspirations, acquiring, hitting these life milestones,” Nelson said.
Demonstrate an alternative masculinity
But for some young men, the most impactful interventions take place while they’re young. Growing up, Michael Dean looked to his father and his friends’ fathers for how to be a man. These men often spoke of the importance of providing for a family, being decisive, and being a stable force. Dean thought everyone was raised with these values and had similar upbringings until he reached high school and joined Reichert’s peer counseling program.
His junior year, one of Dean’s teammates on the football team suggested that some of the young men check out the group to discuss any problems at school, issues with parents, friends, or partners. Dean was frustrated with his performance on the field and decided to attend. Hearing from his classmates — their grief, their struggles — helped give him perspective. He also learned how to be an emotional outlet for the people he loves, including his younger brother.
“I never felt that I had to be some kind of way or be some kind of man based on traditional values of being that strong, tough guy and to keep persevering through. I could definitely see that through my dad, and I did have that belief for a little while as I was in middle school and in the beginning of high school,” Dean, now 21, told Vox. “I learned that that’s not necessarily what it means to be a man, and I can make my own judgment through my own experiences and listening to other people to help me figure out what it means in my own belief to be a man.”
For Dean, learning how to be a man began when he was a child, but his path to adulthood was punctuated by formative adults — his mother, Reichert, and yes, even his dad — who fostered a safe environment to be vulnerable and emotional. Now, when he’s lonely, he knows he can call his family, friends, or his girlfriend for support. These are the outlets experts hope men feel empowered to call upon.
“If we’re really going to make a bigger difference with having healthier men who have connected friendships, who are emotionally expressive and connected in their friendships,” Reigeluth said, “it’s got to start with boys.”
Hi readers! Shayla Love here, science journalist and longtime fan of Your Mileage May Vary. I’m honored to be subbing for Sigal Samuel while she’s out on parental leave. I’m diving into your questions as a way to help understand human nature and our choices through multiple lenses: philosophical, psychological, and beyond. Please send in any emotional, body/brain, sociological, perceptual, or other kind of life quandaries you might have.
My best friend confessed his love for me one year ago and I rejected him because I was unhappily in love with another man, and I was never really physically attracted to my best friend. He was devastated. I am happy our friendship survived.
Over a year later, I find myself thinking about how it would be like to be in a relationship with my best friend. He is the only man who ever showed me genuine love and support, and I wonder what if I try…maybe I will fall in love with him. However, I am concerned about hurting his feelings again. Is it selfish of me wanting to try this love out because it promises security and appreciation?
Dear Fanning the Flame,
I can’t blame you for being curious about the common “friends to lovers” storyline. It’s often portrayed as the best kind of pairing: Two people have the foundation of their friendship plus a newfound love; the romantic relationship is like a soaring addition to an existing sturdy house.
But real life is not always like the movies, and it sounds to me like you haven’t actually had an awakening of desire for your friend. In fact, it’s the opposite: He once expressed feelings for you, and you confronted a lack of physical attraction for this person. Now you’re wondering if it would be possible for you to fall in love if you tried. I think you’d agree that your timing is suspect. After a breakup, it’s common and understandable to seek out comfort and intimacy. Still, I detect a philosophical streak in your question beyond the issue of whether or not this would simply be a rebound.
Have a question you want answered in the next Your Mileage May Vary column?
Fill out this anonymous form! Newsletter subscribers will get my column before anyone else does and their questions will be prioritized for future editions. Sign up here!
If your friend has always appreciated you, made you feel safe, and loves you — could that be a form of love that’s better than what you had in your last relationship? Maybe that iswhat love is.
Is it? Over a long night of drinking some 2,400 years ago, one group of thinkers allegedly debated the true nature of love, as Greek philosopher Plato describes in The Symposium.
Aristophanes, a playwright, tells a story that most closely aligns with the love we see in the rom-coms of today. He said that humans used to be larger creatures with four arms and four legs. After annoying the gods, Zeus cuts all the humans in half, creating the two-limbed bodies we have today. The result is that people wander the world looking for the one person who used to literally complete them. If you followed Aristophanes’s fable, you shouldn’t try to be with your friend unless you felt that deep longing that one has when meeting their other half.
The rest of the dinner party companions have more circumspect ideas. Phaedrus, a Greek aristocrat, thought that true love inspired people to become the best possible version of themselves. Pausanias, a military man, thought that love driven only by attraction to someone’s body was “vulgar love”, and that “noble love” was the love of someone’s values. Eryximachus, a doctor, asserts that love is also about moderation, and it needs order, much in the way the natural world does. Finally, Socrates says that even if you start out with physical infatuation, you can eventually transcend that and end up loving wisdom itself, the highest form of love. As I read it, the men are grappling with how to make love make sense, while acknowledging that it can make us lustful and impulsive. Shouldn’t its best manifestations instead be practical and virtuous?
You could easily justify trying to date your friend with these theories that try to wrangle and tame love. For example, if your friend inspires you to be the best version of yourself, you could decide that’s enough to go for it. You could also decide that because you admire your friend’s character, and not his body, that’s a noble love, and better than the vulgar love of attraction.
German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer wrote in his 19th-century essay “The Metaphysics of Sexual Love” that he distrusted the feeling of being desperately in love. He considered romantic love to be a biological drive disguised as a real emotion — one whose goal is to trick us into procreating. You could even see your lack of attraction as an indication that you’re able to act more rationally, and not be deceived by that cunning trickster, passion.
I know you’ve recently gone through a breakup, but I hope you can feel how bleak these views can become: to see love only as the window dressing for the propagation of a species, or as just a bridge to the love of wisdom.
This cynicism has other consequences. Wondering if you could redefine love in a relationship with your friend isn’t like a wine-fueled dinner party bouncing around thought experiments. It involves your best friend and his own feelings too, and could risk not only hurting him, but also robbing him of a better romantic partner.
For Simone de Beauvoir, the 20th-century existential philosopher, the most important aspect of life was freedom: We are technically free to do whatever we want, and it’s the choices we make with that freedom that determine our authenticity, or lack of it. De Beauvoir worried about forms of love that stole freedom from other people. In narcissistic love, she wrote in The Second Sex, a partner doesn’t love the other person, but loves the fact that the other loves them. It’s a relationship built on the self-interest of one of its members.
I want to gently point out that it sounds like there may be aspects of the narcissistic relationship in your dilemma. While it may be intriguing to consider what it’s like to date a friend, you don’t seem to be as romantically interested so much as you are interested in his interest in and support of you. Actually involving yourself in such a dynamic could take his freedom, as well as your own capacity to learn from your break-up, then find a partner you’re genuinely drawn to for their own merits.
I’m not saying friendship isn’t an important ingredient in love. Many of the most successful, very long-term partners I know have developed a deep friendship with one another. This friendship helps them stay kind to each other and have fun over many years when work, health, or stress can interrupt more passionate times of connection. But those same couples also had the undeniable spark of attraction at the start of their relationships too. They didn’t have to try. Sometimes they tried not to feel as strongly as they did, and still weren’t able to stop.
Even in cases when a relationship first launches platonically, if something more is there, the undeniable, reciprocal pull tends to emerge soon thereafter. In H.G. Wells’ 1911 novel, The New Machiavelli, which was largely based on a real-life affair Wells had, he writes about a college graduate called Richard who meets a young woman, Isabel. The two become friends and are entranced with each other’s minds. But they quickly start to notice more between them, despite trying to push such thoughts away.
They fail at this attempt. Richard has a moment of realization, when he turns to look at Isabel’s face one day. “And something — an infinite tenderness, stabbed me,” Wells wrote. “It was a keen physical feeling, like nothing I had ever felt before. …From that time forth I knew I loved Isabel beyond measure.” I think you owe it to yourself, and your friend, to pursue connections that have this quality, especially at the start.
You should also make room for and appreciate your friendship. If it never becomes romantic, that doesn’t make it a lesser relationship. The couples therapist, Esther Perel, calls friendships their own kind of love story. She once described a simple exercise to help appreciate that bond. Take a few minutes and think about a friend who isn’t a family member or romantic partner. “Recall a time when that friend reflected you back to yourself, created space for joy, or helped you remember who you are,” Perel suggests. Then, send a message to that friend about that moment, and thank them.
Having a good friend by your side in the aftermath of a breakup is a gift. Work on maintaining and nurturing that friendship, and make sure you spend some time helping him with his life too. Don’t fixate on whether you should attempt to fall in love. The truth is, for better or for worse, if you love him, you won’t have to try.
Bonus: What I’m reading
I’ve always been interested in the history of love, by which I mean the differences over time in how love has been expressed and discussed. William Reddy, a historian of emotion, has an excellent book called The Making of Romantic Love; you can also check out a syllabus for a class at Duke University he taught on the subject.
For a deeper dive (and refresher!) on Plato’s Symposium, I found that there was no better person to turn to than Melvyn Bragg and his guests on the BBC In Our Timeepisode on the philosophy of love.
Arranged marriages are an interesting window into understanding the growth of love. Mansi Choksi’s nonfiction book, The Newlyweds, follows three couples in India who attempt to marry for love; here’s an excerpt that was published in Harper’s Magazine.