❌

Reading view

What Britain and the EU still don’t understand about each other

LONDON — They spent years locked in talks over Brexit — but Britain and the EU still sometimes manage to talk past each other.

British Prime Minister Andy Burnham heads to Brussels for a much-hyped summit this Friday after promising a “new approach” to dealing with the European Union. “Not adversarial. No longer burning bridges. But being constructive and positive,” Burnham told an audience in the City of London Monday night.

He’s already talked up a major revival of ties with the bloc — and even opened the door to British return to the EU, a decade after the U.K. public voted to leave.

Yet there remain a host of things the two political bubbles still get fundamentally wrong about each other. POLITICO spoke to officials and experts on both sides to gauge the dynamic shaping Fridays’ “reset” summit — and beyond.

Brussels isn’t thinking about the UK all the time

Seven or eight years ago, Brexit was front-page news on both sides of the Channel. Now? Not so much.

Policymakers in Brussels are grappling with the same thorny challenges that keep their counterparts in London up at night. Whether that’s Donald Trump, AI, climate change, or Chinese industrial capacity depends on what day of the week it is.

“Less than 1 percent of my work is about the U.K.,” said an EU diplomat, granted anonymity like others in this article to discuss the relationship frankly. “A lot less, actually!”

It’s important not to overstate this. EU officials point out that when called upon to engage with London, they have done so happily.

There are entire teams of people in Brussels whose job it is to negotiate with the U.K. But there are also entire teams of people whose job it is to negotiate with the Philippines.

Britain is still an important ally of the EU — hence Friday’s dedicated summit to hash out the finer points of the post-Brexit relationship.

The door’s always open for more, but the bloc isn’t sitting by the phone waiting for a U.K. call.

London’s budget is pretty tight

As an EU member country, the U.K. was a big net contributor to the bloc’s budget. But it doesn’t exactly have cash to burn these days.

“We need more money” was Czech Prime Minister Andrej Babiš’ pithy response last month when asked whether Britain could rejoin the bloc.

Since the global financial crisis, the U.K. public finances have been in a perpetually strained state. And the fraught politics of spending in Britain are not always understood abroad.

As a result, EU negotiators have repeatedly misjudged their U.K. counterparts’ willingness to write checks for things.

This led to a major failure of negotiations last year when talks on Britain joining the EU’s SAFE rearmament scheme unexpectedly collapsed over the question of money.

“A lot of people think that was a huge screw-up,” a second EU diplomat said. Both sides had very different expectations about what a British financial contribution might look like.

It’s also made things tricky in the run-up to this week’s summit. London has resisted a request to cut tuition fees for EU citizens studying in the U.K. on the basis that it would have to make up its universities’ budgets elsewhere.

The European Commission isn’t all-powerful

In 1988, Margaret Thatcher famously railed against a “European super-state exercising a new dominance from Brussels.” For some Brits decades later, leaving the EU was a rebellion against a controlling Brussels bureaucracy.

But sometimes, seeing the European Commission as the EU’s central antagonist can make it difficult to understand where the power really lies. “The Commission calls the shots with third countries — until it doesn’t,” said David Henig, U.K. director at think tank the European Centre for International Political Economy.

Henig said member countries tend to take charge “at the start and end of the negotiating process” — when they’re writing the Commission’s mandate, and then approving the final agreement. “We’re now at that latter point, when the dynamics change,” he said of the current EU-U.K. reset talks.

The European Commission has a lot of responsibility and often has freedom of action. But if EU member countries want something, they tend to get it.

Last week saw an obvious case in point: a compromise position on tuition fees was thrashed out by pragmatic EU officials, only for this to be toughened-up by member state ambassadors.

It’s a dynamic that may have left some British observers scratching their heads — but it’s worth London getting used to it. Member countries will also be the ultimate arbiter should the U.K. eventually apply to rejoin the EU — even if the Commission would directly handle negotiations.

Young people aren’t such a priority in Westminster

When the EU first proposed a post-Brexit youth experience scheme — allowing young people to move between the U.K. and EU for limited time periods — back in 2024, both Labour and the Conservative dismissed the idea out of hand.

Asked to choose between opportunities for young people and potentially angering euro-skeptic voters concerned about migration, for many in Westminster the answer was just common sense.

When it became clear that setting up the scheme was a red line for Brussels, the reaction turned to one of puzzlement. Off-the-record, some British politicians and aides seemed genuinely perplexed: why would they care so much about this issue?

“The U.K. only saw a youth mobility scheme as an EU ask because nobody was listening to young people,” Maurizio Cuttin, a board member at Youth Council UK, argued. “I remember officials telling me we didn’t need Erasmus+ or a youth mobility scheme.”

For the EU, opening up opportunities for young people was a worthy objective in itself — but also had concrete advantages. It would maintain what officials euphemistically call “people-to-people contact” with post-Brexit Britain.

The people staffing the EU institutions have themselves usually worked or studied abroad and see it as a force for soft power. That’s an argument less commonly heard in Westminster.

Both sides remain traumatized by Brexit

Here’s one point of agreement at least — both sides have scars on their back from the fraught Brexit process.

“There’s a lot of traumatized people from Brexit here in the European Union,” EU foreign affairs chief Kaja Kallas said earlier this month.

She’s not the first to say it: Brexit as trauma has very much become a meme in Brussels. Partly it was a sheer political shock. But partly it was about having one topic dominate the political conversation for several years — to the exclusion of others.

EU responses to any British overtures for a closer relationship should be read with Kallas’ summation in mind.

Yet while Brits might not frame it quite the same way, it’s something both capitals have in common.

For years, British politicians have stooped to avoid reopening the fundamental issue of Europe — even in the face of evidence it might be economically advantageous to do so.

That’s something Burnham — Britain’s seventh prime minister since the Brexit vote — has set out to change.

Pulling the U.K. out of its post-Brexit crouch will require convincing a bruised Brussels to trust again — and a weary electorate that reopening old wounds is worth the discomfort.

  •  
❌