We give developers powerful APIs to build incredible capabilities
into their apps for Apple products, backed by a set of controls
designed to protect users’ private data. Full Disk Access largely
sidesteps these controls in order to allow backup apps to function
properly on the Mac. Some developers are using Full Disk Access in
ways that could put users at risk, exposing everything on their
systems — including files, mail, messages, and even browsing
history — without users’ full knowledge and understanding. For
communication apps, this can also compromise the privacy of the
people users are communicating with.
Going forward, we will introduce additional controls to ensure
that users who genuinely wish to grant an app this extraordinary
level of access can only do so with very explicit user action.
Addressing this is critical. As AI agents become increasingly
capable and autonomous, the risks associated with this level of
access will grow substantially. We are committed to ensuring users
clearly understand these risks before granting such access, so
they can make informed decisions about their own data and privacy.
They don’t name names, but clearly this is in response to Meta Muse (cf. Jason Aten’s misadventure with Muse accessing Aten’s iMessages), Grok Bot, Claude, Dots, and the rest. This is why we can’t have nice things.
I really worry about just how much Apple is going to lock Full Disk Access down. I use it with several apps that couldn’t function properly without it, and would be severely hampered if I needed to authorize it manually every time they do something.
But before we Mac power users riot in Cupertino, we should note that we have no idea how many unsophisticated Mac users are calling Apple and queuing up at the retail store Genius Bars to complain about Muse and these other agents having run amok on their Macs, against their desires, after convincing these users to grant them access. It is a legitimate frustration for the highest-functioning users among us that the Mac has, for years, already seemed “too locked down”. But there are now around 150 million Mac users worldwide. Most of them are unsophisticated technically — a majority of them, profoundly so. Many of them have technical needs that cannot be met by the baby computer OS that is iPadOS. For a lot of them it might just be the ability to run the real version of Google’s Chrome web browser — or even the desktop version of Safari. So there are tens of millions of people who need to use a Mac to do things that cannot be done on an iPad, but who have zero understanding of what it means, say, to grant Muse permission for Full Disk Access. And then they think it is Apple’s fault that Muse is suddenly able to read their private iMessage conversations.
(Anyone out there who, say, works at an Apple retail store and can confirm whether this is an escalating support issue — one way or the other — I’d love to hear from you, confidentially.)
On iOS (and its tablet variant, iPadOS), you can say OK to every single thing an app like Muse asks for and Muse still won’t be able to read your email or end-to-end encrypted messages from iMessage or WhatsApp. There is no level of permission that grants third-party apps permission for such things. (The EU wants to force Apple to allow that under the DMA.) MacOS isn’t like that. You still need to grant apps permission for such things, but if you say OK to everything an app like Muse asks for on the Mac, you’re granting that app access to, effectively, almost everything on your startup drive. There are still some things it can’t see, but not many. A lot of non-technical Mac users do not understand this and cannot be expected to understand this. They just think, wrongly, that Apple protects them from allowing anything truly dangerous, because that’s how their iPhone (and/or iPad) works. So they just click OK to every access request from Muse and presume they’re still largely protected.
Hopefully Apple has in mind a solution to this situation that will still enable knowledgeable power users to confirm agreement to a sufficiently scary warning and put their Macs in a state similar to what we have today. I worry. What alleviates my worst fears is the knowledge that every technical user at Apple itself needs to use their Mac as the powerful Unix workstation OS that it is. Some of us need dangerously powerful tools. Most Mac users, however, do not — and don’t realize they’re using a dangerously powerful Unix workstation with a very friendly (literal) face.
This week’s Draper-D story is a parody of “Eleanor Rigby,” (which was Sisqo’s inspiration for “The Thong Song,” in case you hadn’t noticed) but it could have easily been a song by The Heartbreakers and their leader Tom, because everyone is being so petty.
Betty is trying to turn Sally against Megan because she’s a sad, fat, divorced woman who just squirts whipped cream in her mouth and thinks about her ex-husband. Those are Vince’s words, but to be fair, that is how the show depicts her. Don’t be mad at Vince because Matthew Weiner made her this way.
Don realizes Ginsberg has better ideas for the Sno Ball account so he attempts to bury his new rival’s pitch in favor of his own. Then we get the famous scene where Don says he doesn’t think about Ginsberg at all, and if your understanding of that scene were entirely based on memes, you might think he meant it. Lucky for you, you have this podcast to explain the art to you between parody songs that recap the episode in terms that rhyme with "poopoo."
Tell us what you're thankful for this Thanksgiving in a five-star review on Apple Podcasts.
Support the Pod: become a patron atpatreon.com/Frotcast and get more bonus content than you could ever want. Sign up for the Pod Yourself a Shoutout tier to hear Vince give you a shout out on the show, like this week's shoutouts for El Conquistador & V Squared.
LAcon V, the 84th World Science Fiction Convention, was held August 27-31, 2026 at the Anaheim Convention Center and Hilton Anaheim & Anaheim Marriott Hotels in Anaheim, California. Guests of honor were novelist Barbara Hambly, cartoonist Colleen Doran, illustrator Tim Kirk, graphic novelist Stan Sakai, screenwriter Ronald D. Moore, fanzine editor Geri Sullivan, and engineer Anita Sengupta; special guests were NASA engineer Tracy Drain and authors Terese Mason Pierre and Tracey Baptiste. Registration reported 4,597 in-person warm bodies from 59 different countries, at least 847 of which were Worldcon first-timers; 8,225 memberships were purchased, 990 of which were virtual. They saw 1,843 memberships sold for WSFS (supporting memberships). Though there were fewer warm bodies than Seattle at 7,177 and Glasgow at 7,300, Anaheim’s total memberships rival last year’s 8,667 in Seattle. In comparison, Glasgow reported over 10,000 total members, and Chengdu 2023 saw a record in-person attendance of 18,895 with over 20,000 total members.
Hugo base designed by Scoft Lefton
The con hotels were about a five-minute walk from the ACC North where the dealers room and art show were housed, as well as much programming, which ran in the ACC North and the fourth floor of the Hilton. Events used the center arena as well as two ballrooms in the Hilton, all offering enough space that none of the events were ticketed. At night, the Lanai Deck of the Hilton on the fifth floor, which opened up onto the large, well-lit outdoor green, became a central hub for room parties.
This year’s theme was ‘‘Adventure Awaits.’’ Worldcon chair Joyce Lloyd wrote, ‘‘In line with our theme, the directive given to everyone was to provide an adventure around every corner.’’ Exhibits were placed beyond the traditional exhibit area and into the Hilton function space, with photography exhibits, themed backdrops for photo ops, a LEGO play area, and more.
Anaheim Convention Center.
PROGRAMMING
Programming began early on Thursday with several panels, readings, and workshops. The Opening Ceremonies ran that evening with host T. Kingfisher and, after a land acknowledgment and a performance by Toveema, a Tongva song and dance ensemble, saw speeches by Lloyd and the guests of honor and special guests. H. Emiko Ogasawara detailed the Lodestar Trophy design in a recorded video, and Scott Lefton introduced the Hugo Base design in person. Then, the First Fandom Awards were presented by David Ritter. The Big Heart Award went to Ian Stockdale; Hall of Fame to Mike Glyer, Craig Miller, and Bjo Trimble; Hall of Fame, Posthumous to Fredric Brown and Myrtle R. Douglas; and Sam Moskowitz Archive Award to Andrew Porter and David Ritter. Also making an appearance was Fuzzy the Channel Island Fox, LAcon V’s mascot.
Opening Ceremonies: Guests of Honor & Special Guests: Tracy Drain, Tim Kirk, Colleen Doran, Barbara Hambly, Ronald D. Moore, Dr. Anita Sengupta, Geri Sullivan, Stan Sakai, Tracey Baptiste, Terese Mason Pierre, Toastmaster Ursula Vernon AKA T. Kingfisher
Programming was prolific this year, featuring a wide variety of panels, interviews, meetups, workshops, screenings, performances, tours, and much more. There was no pocket program, to the consternation of many. The well-used online program guide (loaded a reported 2.7 million times) featured tags including AI, astronomy and space, contracts, fandom history, gameshow, music, non-Western literature, roleplaying, sustainability, and many genre categories. There were 1,737 scheduled items, with 243 fully virtual, and over 500 recorded for replay to members; participants totaled 1,063, with 168 virtual. There were 356 table talks; 166 readings. For comparison, Seattle reported 1,425 program items and 936 participants; Glasgow reported 789 program items and 976 participants; and Chengdu offered 235 in-person items with a reported 1,200 panelists and guests. Programming worked to platform ‘‘a very strong indigenous languages track with workshops and panels on Navajo, Tongva, and Chumash.’’
Virtual programming was particularly robust. Of the scheduled items, 243 were fully virtual, and over 500 were recorded for replay to members. Included in these numbers was the convention’s joint program stream with the African Science Fiction Society, which hosted ASFS members on several panels and workshops, as well as the Nommo Awards nominees announcement on Thursday morning. Besides the virtual content itself, the convention held a Discord server that accrued approximately 1,600 members, discussing program items at length before and after the items ran.
Con Chair Joyce Lloyd, mascot Fuzzy, Toastmaster Ursula Vernon AKA T. Kingfisher; Harry Turtledove presents Sidewise Award to Ronald D. Moore
There was plenty of hands-on content to be found as well. Among the highlights was ‘‘what we believe is the first fully dedicated Makerspace at the convention,’’ according to Lloyd – four rooms were devoted to Makers presentations and demos. There were also gaming spaces throughout the convention, with libraries and equipment courtesy of such organizations as Strategicon and Anime Los Angeles. The Freebies Book Lounge held books, galleys, bookmarks, and more, ‘‘replacing the bookbags given away at some smaller conventions.’’ For those interested in more physical activity, the convention saw the customary morning Stroll with the Stars, tai chi, Muay Thai, dance workshops, full-body improv workshops, and multiple combat sessions presented by the Society for Creative Anachronism (SCA) Kingdom of Caid. Even before the convention formally started, Anaheim Poet Laureate Camille Hernandez hosted a preconvention poetry event at the city’s public library, and later she moderated a poetry workshop as well.
LAcon V had 78 items listed as ‘‘Kid Friendly.’’ Comparatively, 27 items at Seattle Worldcon were listed as ‘‘Youth’’ and 16 as ‘‘Teen,’’ Glasgow listed 26 as ‘‘Children’s Programme,’’ and Chicon listed 34 tagged with ‘‘children’s program.’’
The Masquerade was Friday night, directed by Richard Man and Karisu Wen. The Award for Best in Show Presentation went to Lance Ikegawa for ‘‘Single Parent’’ and Best in Show Workmanship went to Ed and Jenn for ‘‘Nuada and Nualla from Hellboy 2.’’
Con Chair Joyce Lloyd, mascot Fuzzy, Toastmaster Ursula Vernon AKA T. Kingfisher; Harry Turtledove presents Sidewise Award to Ronald D. Moore
DEALERS’ ROOM
Located in the spacious Exhibits Hall, the dealers’ room was a huge hall where dealers were interspersed with exhibits, hangout spaces, signing tables, GOH booths, bid tables, and many empty booths and tables that never filled, wrapped around the art show, which was draped or paneled off from view. The overall effect was that the rather daunting space was sparsely occupied and it never felt the hum of business. There were 120 total dealers offering ‘‘books, jewelry, artwork, collectables, and more.’’ Dealers included Bad Habit Publishing, Tachyon, PM Press, Locus, the Scribe Tribe, and many other indie publishers; Clarkesworld Magazine; Indigenous Tongva people; jewelers, artisans, author tables, and more. Many vendors colonized the empty spaces and we heard from many that the layout was uncomfortably disjointed. Randee Dawn of Armchair News said, ‘‘I sold better here than I’ve ever done before, so I have no complaints about that. But I was all the way in the back of the room, near tables that never were filled up, and it felt a little empty and abandoned,’’ a sentiment others echoed. ‘‘My only real issue was the cold in the room. I brought some nice frocks to wear and had to have a quilted flannel over them! But seriously, it was cold.’’
Patrick Swenson of Fairwood Press said, ‘‘I was very much spoiled by the Seattle Worldcon last year, but this year was not terrible. Considerably less sales, though…. Last year in Seattle the traffic was steady all the time. This year, there were pockets of quiet time, and then some steady times and some rushes. Having the art show in the middle of all the dealers was not the best decision made for the exhibits area. Trying to navigate paying for Wi-Fi (or electricity) and actually getting it was difficult. I never got mine, and I hope to see a refund for what I paid.’’
Shahid Mahmud said, ‘‘We had four tables for Arc Manor/Caezik. We found the room too large and strangely laid out (no segregated sections for dealers and other items like art shows etc., so kind of dispersed all over the place). I think the expansive space with wide empty spaces also made it seem like there was a lot less foot traffic than in Seattle. We had multiple inquiries of people getting frustrated trying to find particular booths since there did not seem to be a comprehensive map and the overall layout made it difficult to locate specific vendors.’’
Fairwood Press: Patrick Swenson; Theodora Goss, Jacob Weisman, Kate Elliott, T.A. Chan; Rick Sternbach, Wil Wheaton
ART SHOW
The exhibit hall of the ACC North saw the participation of 141 artists, 2,398 pieces on display, and 1,933 prints for sale. This was the first Worldcon to display the work of backdrop/scene painters. Organizers reported sales numbers reaching $140,000 in total buyer payments. There were two internal special displays for Frank Kelly Freas and Vincent Villafranca. Best in Show went to K.L. Wollons for ‘‘Dhiala Waning’’, Best Color 2D went to Barbara Hambly for ‘‘The War Doctor’’, Best Monochrome 2D went to Vincent Di Fate for ‘‘Who Goes There?’’, best 3D went to Vincent Villafranca for ‘‘The Monster Tree’’, Best Fabric Art went to Kestrel Michaud, Best Mixed Media went to Snail Scott for ‘‘Guardian’’, Judges’ Choice went to Daniel Gonzalez for ‘‘Canción Nocterna’’, and the Judges’ Choice for Body of Work went to Brittany Otto. The judges were Elizabeth Klein-Lebbink, Meghan Lancaster, Edie Stern, Joe Siclari, and David Stein.
The 20 Minute Masterpiece Competition!: Scott Lefton, Daniel Gonzalez, Stan Sakai, Catherine Koon, GoH Tim Kirk
PARTIES/CON SUITE
The Con Suite was well attended, located at the Hilton in room 5505 from 10:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. every day except Monday and offering snacks and beverages for all attendees. The room parties were ‘‘a hit,’’ per Lloyd. There were parties for the Edmonton and Brisbane Worldcon bids and for the Montréal Worldcon, as well as an Asian Fantasy Book Party, a party run by the cast of the Writing Excuses podcast, parties titled ‘‘90 Years of Cons’’ and ‘‘We Interrupt This Party’’, Brotherhood Without Banners, Space Bar, and more. All room parties set on the Lanai deck opened onto a shared central courtyard. Geri Sullivan’s suite, ‘‘Toad Woods West’’, was a popular destination, not least because she hosted and lent the suite to multiple parties throughout the convention. Other publisher and agent mixers were held off-site and in the hotels, as well as a combined Locus & Saga party in the presidential suite.
Star Trek is 60! David Gerrold, Bjo Trimble, Eugene “Rod” Roddenberry, Sarah Gulde
CON PUBLICATIONS
The souvenir book was the main guide to the convention, a hefty 160-page full-size perfect bound publication, with a cover boasting Big Foot by GOH Tim Kirk. A letter from the chair Joyce Lloyd was followed by introductions to the guests of honor, special guests, and toastmaster Ursula Vernon; essays on Worldcons past; sections on the awards, including a full list of Hugo finalists and the membership list, and a section about WSFS.
The Fuzzy Pink Papers, the convention newsletter published online and in print at the convention, offered regular status updates, featuring programming updates, useful information, announcements, award results, and more.
50 Years of Voyager panel: Sun Kang Matsumoto, Kelly L. Perry, Todd J. Barber, Linda Spilker, Kareem Badaruddin
HUGO AWARDS
The Hugo Awards Ceremony capped off the night of Sunday, August 30, 2026 at the ACC Arena, running from about 8:00 to 11:00 p.m. The event was livestreamed through the convention member portal as well as on YouTube. There was an autocaptioner, though it tended to lag behind, and multiple interpreters. Organizers estimate the in-person audience at 2,500 viewers, and as of September 9, the YouTube livestream had over 10,000 views. The toastmaster this year was T. Kingfisher, whose cheerful energy, hats, and abundant supply of animal facts kept viewers well entertained for the extended show. Although the ceremony experienced some technical issues, notably a corrupted slide deck, all content was shown. Finalist names were read in a prepared audio recording by Frank Todaro, and musical accompaniment was provided by the South Side Symphony.
Hilton Anaheim lobby gathering; Stroll with the Stars
After Kingfisher’s lively extended opening, as she stalled for time for the A/V team, Hugo administrator Tammy Coxen shared that the awards received 1,488 nominations and ballots from 2,492 members across all 21 categories. Kingfisher then returned to the stage to lead the In Memoriam for the many contributors to the SF scene who died in the past year, although technical issues delayed the playing of the video until later.
Emily Hockaday presented the Astounding Award for Best New Writer to Antonia Hodgson. Hodgson said, ‘‘My first novel, which was unpublished for good reason, was a Gothic vampire saga. My writing took a detour, but my heart has always remained fantastical. This award really does mean the world to me. No more detours. You’re stuck with me, I’m afraid.’’ She thanked the voters, fellow nominees, Hodderscape, Orbit US, her agent, and everyone at Worldcon.
Dublin 2029 Céilí: featuring Stepwise; SCA Demo
Tracey Baptiste presented the Lodestar Award for Best Young Adult Book to C.B. Lee for Coffeeshop in an Alternate Universe. Lee, attending Worldcon for the first time, said, ‘‘Thank you all so much! I didn’t write a speech because I didn’t think that a little queer cozy novel could even be nominated.… But a novel that celebrates joy is not little.’’ They thanked their five-year-old child, partners, agent, and ‘‘I don’t know, cheese and frogs and all the wonderful things in the world,’’ and all the nominees.
Terese Mason Pierre presented the award for Best Poem to Elis Montgomery for ‘‘Hex Supply Customer Support Log’’. Montgomery, also a first-time Worldcongoer, thanked Jennifer Hudak, LAcon, the readers and voters, the poets of the Speculative Poetry Initiative, and more, and encouraged everyone to vote to make the category a permanent installment of the Hugos.
Vincent Villafranca; Mia Araujo; Vincent Di Fate, John Picacio
Tim Kirk presented the award for Best Fan Artist to Yuumei, who said in a virtual acceptance speech, ‘‘I am so grateful to everyone who has supported my art over the years. Your support allowed me to dream and create to the fullest.’’
Mike Glyer presented the Best Fan Writer Award to Jason Sanford. Chris Barkley accepted and read Sanford’s speech, beginning, ‘‘Oh shit, I guess I should have attended Worldcon.’’ Sanford expressed ‘‘I’m honored that people see my journalism and essays as worthy of standing among the writings of these wonderful people.’’ He thanked his mother, his children, Lucienne Diver, Barkley, his readers, and more. He thanked SF/F as a genre for ‘‘help[ing] me realize there’s nothing wrong with me’’ as a neurodiverse child and said, ‘‘We will always be here, living, seeing, loving, dying. We are as normal as life itself.’’
Tracy Drain presented the Best Fancast Award to Hugo, Girl! Amy Salley, Kevin Anderson, and Lori Anderson accepted, expressing extensive thanks and acknowledging Haley Zapal, who could not attend. Lori addressed ‘‘anyone creating fan work: Thank you for sharing your art with the world. In a society where everything is increasingly profit-driven, making cool stuff just because you love to do it and then giving it away for free is an act of resistance. Keep it up.’’
Susan Hanfield, Gabrielle de Cuir, Stefan Rudnicki; Jacob Charlot, Marc Zicree, Alexandra Wahl
After the In Memoriam ran successfully, Geri Sullivan presented the award for Best Fanzine to nerds of a feather, flock together. G. Brown, Vance Kotrla and Paul Weimer accepted. Brown said, ‘‘The role of a fanzine like nerds of a feather, flock together, as I see it, is not only to celebrate the art that we all love, but to shine a light on these imagined worlds and how they contribute to our shared understanding of what it means to be human.’’ The cast thanked their team and families.
Neil Clarke presented the Best Semiprozine Award to Uncanny Magazine. Michael Damian Thomas accepted by video and thanked the magazine staff, Worldcon staff, the Space Unicorn Ranger Corps, and his family. Betsy Aoki also accepted in person, saying, ‘‘It’s been a bad year for speculative fiction magazines. We’ve seen too many good journals close. It’s really through the gracious community support that Uncanny Magazine has that we’ve been able to keep going another year and we’re grateful.’’
Colleen Doran presented the Best Professional Artist Award to John Picacio, who thanked Doran, Leigh Bardugo, New Leaf Literary, his editor, creative director, family, and more, and dedicated the award to his recently passed brother-in-law.
The award for Best Editor, Short Form was presented by Anita Sengupta to Neil Clarke, who said, ‘‘Twenty years ago this October, Clarkesworld published its first issue. It’s something I never thought would last that long, and my plus-one this evening thought he was here to help me with the table – and to be fair, I helped him with the table in the Dealers’ Room. But I wanted Sean Wallace here because he’s the person that talked me into taking this job. He’s worked by my side this entire time.… I never thought that I would find a career in this.’’ He also encouraged everyone to support the fundraiser for fellow finalist Sheila Williams and her health care.
A Skulk of Foxes: Chris Doyle, Bill Howard, Debbie Bretschneider, Ron Oakes, John Coxon, España Sheriff, Kevin Roche, Karisu, Fuzzy the Channel Island mascot, Alex Mui, Cindy Scott
The award for Best Editor, Long Form was presented by Patrick Nielsen Hayden to Diana M. Pho. Pho accepted, saying, ‘‘One word echoes in my head, said by so many this evening: despite. We are here, we’re alive, despite everything.… Let us keep our spirits, the spite, the fight, and the adventure, and for those who are against these values of love and acceptance, in the words of a great man, ‘Change your heart or die.’’’ She thanked the Worldcon community, family, friends, colleagues, and many others.
Tanya DePass presented the Best Game or Interactive Work Award to Clair Obscur: Expedition 33. Lead writer Jennifer Svedberg-Yen accepted, saying, ‘‘It is an honor to be here today to celebrate the artistic minds of folks who have inspired us, delighted us, and made us think and feel, and I hope we never lose sight of what makes us human and what humans can contribute to each other.’’
Ronald D. Moore presented the award for Best Dramatic Presentation, Short Form to Murderbot: ‘‘All Systems Red’’. Chris Weitz accepted with several others of the show staff, including Martha Wells and actor David Daltsmachian, saying, ‘‘It has been the privilege of a lifetime to be able to make this incredibly well-funded fan fiction.’’
Preston Grassmann, Donald Grassmann, Mari Kotani & Takayuki Tatsumi; Dalila Ali Rajah, Christian M. Ivey, Erin Brown
David Gerrold presented the award for Best Dramatic Presentation, Long Form to Sinners, although Ryan Coogler was not able to attend and did not share a speech.
Charlie Jane Anders presented the Best Related Work Award to ‘‘Inventing the Renaissance’’ by Ada Palmer. Palmer, unable to attend, accepted by video, though it was not able to be played immediately. She thanked her agent, advisors, fellow scholars, publishing teams, family, blog readers, and more. ‘‘Critics have called the book innovative, but Worldcon is where that innovation comes from, so it means the world to me to see my weird bridge book welcomed here.’’
Stan Sakai presented the award for Best Graphic Story or Comic to A Wizard of Earthsea: A Graphic Novel. Fred Fordham shared a video acceptance speech expressing many thanks.
The award for Best Series was presented by Barbara Hambly to the Old Man’s War series by John Scalzi, who accepted and said, ‘‘I and some other members of the Best Series crew made a pact that whoever won, the rest of us would flip them off. You don’t do that if you don’t love the people that you are in your field with.’’ He thanked editor Patrick Nielsen Hayden and his wife Kristine.
Ace Antonio Hall,Linda D. Addison; Lila Mizzi, Kemi Ashing-Giwa, Chloe Smith; Anand Gandhi, Arkady Martine
The award for Best Short Story, presented by Larry Niven, went to ‘‘In My Country’’ by Thomas Ha. Ha expressed thanks to the voters, Clarkesworld, finalists, winners, family, and more, and said, ‘‘I know it’s hard to find the motivation, at least it is for me and I know that it is for some others. It is endless and relentless the way the world’s upended every other day, but I hope other writers, especially newer writers who are just starting out… I hope you just keep going and follow the impulse and the compulsion. You can’t let anyone take that away from you.’’
Mary Robinette Kowal presented the award for Best Novelette to ‘‘Never Eaten Vegetables’’ by H.H. Pak, who accepted with surprise. ‘‘In the absence of words, I’m just filled with gratitude,’’ they said, and thanked Clarkesworld, their readers, their teachers and professors, and their mother.
Harry Turtledove presented the award for Best Novella to The River Has Roots by Amal El-Mohtar. She thanked her fellow finalists, voters, Worldcon volunteers, her agent and editorial team, family, and more. ‘‘The process of seeing The River Has Roots published was a process of being constantly humbled by how much extraordinary art and skill went into making it a beautiful object to hold and experience,’’ she said, recognizing Gem Carmella, Jeff Miller, Kathleen Neeley, and Steve Wagner for their work on the art and audiobook. ‘‘Free Palestine, trans rights are inviolable human rights, borders are bullshit, and we are bound together in this world to fight for the liberation of all people.’’
Kingfisher presented the award for Best Novel, in an envelope delivered by R2-D2, to The Everlasting by Alix E. Harrow. El-Mohtar read Harrow’s speech. ‘‘This is a moment when both love and stories are being systematically devalued, distorted, suppressed, stolen, banned. I don’t know how we’re going to get through it sometimes. Then I start listing people again, the people who keep fighting and yelling at their senators and giving to bail funds and loving each other and telling stories. I want to thank all of you for loving a love story in times like these. It is by far the luckiest, most unlikely thing in a life of unlikely and lucky things.’’
Gail Carriger, Kevin Botterbusch, Grant Saylor; Todd Dashoff & Joni Brill Dashoff, Alex Latzko
ACCESSIBILITY ISSUES
After some reports about accessibility concerns at the awards and around the hotel, as well as ableist language used with one of the finalists, LAcon V’s chair issued a statement.
‘‘LAcon V recognizes that there were failures in accessibility and communication surrounding our main stage during the convention. The rear backstage ramp did not meet ADA accessibility requirements, and as a result we failed to provide the level of access that we intended and that our community has every right to expect. While this originated with a third-party vendor issue, responsibility for ensuring an accessible experience remained ours. We also failed to communicate the problem, its impact, and potential solutions effectively to those affected.
We recognize that this created barriers for attendees using mobility devices and caused understandable frustration, disappointment, and exclusion. We are deeply sorry for that harm.’’
The 85th World SF Convention, Montréal Worldcon 2027, will be held at the Palais de Congrès de Montréal in Québec, Canada, September 2-6, 2027, featuring guests of honor Linda D. Addison, Cory Doctorow, Chris Barkley, Jeph Jacques, Yves Meynard, Jo Walton, and more to be announced.
The 86th World SF Convention, Aussiecon 5, is scheduled for July 27-31, 2028 at the Brisbane Convention & Exhibition Centre in Brisbane (Meanjin), Australia, featuring guests of honor Claire G. Coleman, David Gaider, Kathleen Jennings, Seanan McGuire, Perry Middlemiss, Jonathan Strahan, and more to be announced.
–Alice Strangman & Liza Groen Trombi
A selection of photos from the convention follows.
Cheryl Brigham Brin & David Brin; Storm Humbert, Brandon Case; S.B. Divya, Elan SamuelGay & Joe Haldeman, Lorena Haldeman; Shahid Mahmud, Yasser Bahjatt, Robert Silverberg, Alex ShvartsmanMichelle Pincus, Maria Jimenez, Larry Niven, Carole Philips; Tina Wong, Carolyn Clink, Shoshana Glick, Robert J. SawyerDongWon Song, Arley Sorg; Nicole Glover, Nia Davenport; Elijah Kinch Spector, Ai Jiang, Melissa A. WatkinsJ.T. Petty & Sarah Langan, Ellen Datlow, Kate Maruyama; Viengsamai Fetters, Allison Mick, Michelle Addo-ChajetBrent C. Lambert, Clay Harmon, Christopher Caldwell; Stina Leicht, Benjamin C. Kinney, Justin C. Key, Tamika ThompsonSisterhood Without Standards: Gina Tuboly Kluth, Andi Galusha, Jenn R. Johansson, Nichole Giles, Julia McCracken; Trevor Quachri, Kirsten Gong-Wong, Teddy BuchananChris Campbell, Colton Kekoa Neves, Shay Kauwe, Sophia Babai; Hannah Bowman, Carrie Vaughn, Sandra TaylerSomto Ihezue, Brandon O’Brien, Alex Brown, Akis Linardos; Avani Vaghela, Daryl Gregory, Steen ComerBrotherhood Without Banners party with Parris McBride & George R.R. MartinNovella: Amal El-Mohtar; Novelette: H.H. Pak; Series: John Scalzi; Short Story: Thomas HaAstounding: Antonia Hodgson; Game: Jennifer Svedberg-Yen; Editor, Short: Neil Clarke; Editor, Long: Diana M. PhoProfessional Artist: John Picacio; Fancast: Kevin Anderson, Lori Anderson, Amy Salley; Semiprozine: Betsy AokiPoem: Elis Montgomery; Fanzine: Vance Kotrla, Paul Weimer, G. Brown; Lodestar: C.B. LeeDramatic, Short: “All Systems Red” Keith Levine, David Dastmalchian, Martha Wells, Chris Weitz, Dan Balgoyen, Stan Pham, Britta Rowings, Andrew MianoKelcey Bauer, Randall Shepherd; Tammy Coxen, Hugo and Lodestar base designers Scott Lefton, H. Emiko OgasawaraToastmaster Ursula Vernon aka T. Kingfisher; GoH Barbara Hambly, Richard ManCameron McClure, Robert Jackson Bennett; Coye Lloyd, Maurice Broaddus; Scott Edelman, Rosemary Claire SmithMary Robinette Kowal, Lynne M. Thomas; Carl Engle-Laird, Teresa Nielsen Hayden, Patrick Nielsen Hayden; David Dastmalchian, Vanessa ApplegateKamilah Cole, Emily Forney; Terese Mason Pierre,Tracey Drain; Seanan McGuire, Sarah Rees BrennanGoH Colleen Duran, Val Terwilliger, Kristine Blauser & John Scalzi; Tia Tashiro, Claudia Liu, Udochi NwobodoDale W. Hanes, Tom Gregory, Gary K. Wolfe, front Mari Ness; Martha Wells, Holly Black, Leigh BardugoRJ Carey & Emily Hockaday; Ian Stockdale, Jeff Wildman, Kris Wildman, Meg MacDonald, Sarah GuldeLaura Woodney, Sara Felix; Valerie McElroy, Gideon Marcus; Fran Wilde, Troyce WilsonRandy Mills & Samantha Mills, Abhijeet Sathe; Joshua Jenkins, Catherynne M. Valente, Betsy Aoki, Elizabeth BearAmanda Wakaruk & Olav Rokne, Chris Barkley & Juli Marr; Max Gladstone & Simon Neely, Annalee Newitz & Charlie Jane AndersMasquerade Open Division WinnersNovice, Best in Class Workmanship: Claire Reimagined 18th Century Outlander Gown; Workmanship, Best Original Design: Fire and Ice; Presentation, Best in Show: Single ParentJourneyman, Best in Class Workmanship: From the Court of the Dragon Queen; Workmanship, Best in Show: Nuada and Nuala from Hellboy II: The Golden ArmyThe Japan Party, presented by the HAL-CON CommitteePartiers gather on the Lanai DeckDJ Scalzi DiscothequePast and Future Worldcon Chairs (l to r): front: Mike Glyer (1996), Kent Bloom (2008), Joyce Lloyd (2026), Bruce Farr (2027), Karen Meschke (1997), Joe Siclari (1992); middle: Vix Richardson (2028), Helen Montgomery (2022), Tom Veal (2000), Kevin Roche (2018), Kathy Bond (2025), Leslie Turek (1980), Mary Robinette Kowal (2021); back: Kayla Allen (2002), Tom Whitmore (2002), Todd Dashoff (2001), Randall Shepherd (2013), Michael J. Walsh (1983), Christian McGuire (2006)Handing off to Montréal 2027: LAcon V Chair Joyce Lloyd, Seattle 2025 Chair Kathy Bond, Montréal 2027 Chair Bruce Farr
2 October 10 p. m.—Last night I slept, but did not dream. I must have slept soundly, for I was not waked by Jonathan coming to bed; but the sleep has not refreshed me, for to-day I feel terribly weak and spiritless. I spent all yesterday trying to read, or lying down dozing. In the afternoon Mr. Renfield asked if he might see me. Poor man, he was very gentle, and when I came away he kissed my hand and bade God bless me. Some way it affected me much; I am crying when I think of him. This is a new weakness, of which I must be careful. Jonathan would be miserable if he knew I had been crying. He and the others were out till dinner-time, and they all came in tired. I did what I could to brighten them up, and I suppose that the effort did me good, for I forgot how tired I was. After dinner they sent me to bed, and all went off to smoke together, as they said, but I knew that they wanted to tell each other of what had occurred to each during the day; I could see from Jonathan's manner that he had something important to communicate. I was not so sleepy as I should have been; so before they went I asked Dr. Seward to give me a little opiate of some kind, as I had not slept well the night before. He very kindly made me up a sleeping draught, which he gave to me, telling me that it would do me no harm, as it was very mild.... I have taken it, and am waiting for sleep, which still keeps aloof. I hope I have not done wrong, for as sleep begins to flirt with me, a new fear comes: that I may have been foolish in thus depriving myself of the power of waking. I might want it. Here comes sleep. Good-night.
JONATHAN HARKER'S JOURNAL
2 October, evening.—A long and trying and exciting day. By the first post I got my directed envelope with a dirty scrap of paper enclosed, on which was written with a carpenter's pencil in a sprawling hand:—
Sam Bloxam, Korkrans, 4, Poters Cort, Bartel Street, Walworth. Arsk for the depite.
I got the letter in bed, and rose without waking Mina. She looked heavy and sleepy and pale, and far from well. I determined not to wake her, but that, when I should return from this new search, I would arrange for her going back to Exeter. I think she would be happier in our own home, with her daily tasks to interest her, than in being here amongst us and in ignorance. I only saw Dr. Seward for a moment, and told him where I was off to, promising to come back and tell the rest so soon as I should have found out anything. I drove to Walworth and found, with some difficulty, Potter's Court. Mr. Smollet's spelling misled me, as I asked for Poter's Court instead of Potter's Court. However, when I had found the court, I had no difficulty in discovering Corcoran's lodging-house. When I asked the man who came to the door for the "depite," he shook his head, and said: "I dunno 'im. There ain't no such a person 'ere; I never 'eard of 'im in all my bloomin' days. Don't believe there ain't nobody of that kind livin' ere or anywheres." I took out Smollet's letter, and as I read it it seemed to me that the lesson of the spelling of the name of the court might guide me. "What are you?" I asked.
"I'm the depity," he answered. I saw at once that I was on the right track; phonetic spelling had again misled me. A half-crown tip put the deputy's knowledge at my disposal, and I learned that Mr. Bloxam, who had slept off the remains of his beer on the previous night at Corcoran's, had left for his work at Poplar at five o'clock that morning. He could not tell me where the place of work was situated, but he had a vague idea that it was some kind of a "new-fangled ware'us"; and with this slender clue I had to start for Poplar. It was twelve o'clock before I got any satisfactory hint of such a building, and this I got at a coffee-shop, where some workmen were having their dinner. One of these suggested that there was being erected at Cross Angel Street a new "cold storage" building; and as this suited the condition of a "new-fangled ware'us," I at once drove to it. An interview with a surly gatekeeper and a surlier foreman, both of whom were appeased with the coin of the realm, put me on the track of Bloxam; he was sent for on my suggesting that I was willing to pay his day's wages to his foreman for the privilege of asking him a few questions on a private matter. He was a smart enough fellow, though rough of speech and bearing. When I had promised to pay for his information and given him an earnest, he told me that he had made two journeys between Carfax and a house in Piccadilly, and had taken from this house to the latter nine great boxes—"main heavy ones"—with a horse and cart hired by him for this purpose. I asked him if he could tell me the number of the house in Piccadilly, to which he replied:—
"Well, guv'nor, I forgits the number, but it was only a few doors from a big white church or somethink of the kind, not long built. It was a dusty old 'ouse, too, though nothin' to the dustiness of the 'ouse we tooked the bloomin' boxes from."
"How did you get into the houses if they were both empty?"
"There was the old party what engaged me a-waitin' in the 'ouse at Purfleet. He 'elped me to lift the boxes and put them in the dray. Curse me, but he was the strongest chap I ever struck, an' him a old feller, with a white moustache, one that thin you would think he couldn't throw a shadder."
How this phrase thrilled through me!
"Why, 'e took up 'is end o' the boxes like they was pounds of tea, and me a-puffin' an' a-blowin' afore I could up-end mine anyhow—an' I'm no chicken, neither."
"How did you get into the house in Piccadilly?" I asked.
"He was there too. He must 'a' started off and got there afore me, for when I rung of the bell he kem an' opened the door 'isself an' 'elped me to carry the boxes into the 'all."
"The whole nine?" I asked.
"Yus; there was five in the first load an' four in the second. It was main dry work, an' I don't so well remember 'ow I got 'ome." I interrupted him:—
"Were the boxes left in the hall?"
"Yus; it was a big 'all, an' there was nothin' else in it." I made one more attempt to further matters:—
"You didn't have any key?"
"Never used no key nor nothink. The old gent, he opened the door 'isself an' shut it again when I druv off. I don't remember the last time—but that was the beer."
"And you can't remember the number of the house?"
"No, sir. But ye needn't have no difficulty about that. It's a 'igh 'un with a stone front with a bow on it, an' 'igh steps up to the door. I know them steps, 'avin' 'ad to carry the boxes up with three loafers what come round to earn a copper. The old gent give them shillin's, an' they seein' they got so much, they wanted more; but 'e took one of them by the shoulder and was like to throw 'im down the steps, till the lot of them went away cussin'." I thought that with this description I could find the house, so, having paid my friend for his information, I started off for Piccadilly. I had gained a new painful experience; the Count could, it was evident, handle the earth-boxes himself. If so, time was precious; for, now that he had achieved a certain amount of distribution, he could, by choosing his own time, complete the task unobserved. At Piccadilly Circus I discharged my cab, and walked westward; beyond the Junior Constitutional I came across the house described, and was satisfied that this was the next of the lairs arranged by Dracula. The house looked as though it had been long untenanted. The windows were encrusted with dust, and the shutters were up. All the framework was black with time, and from the iron the paint had mostly scaled away. It was evident that up to lately there had been a large notice-board in front of the balcony; it had, however, been roughly torn away, the uprights which had supported it still remaining. Behind the rails of the balcony I saw there were some loose boards, whose raw edges looked white. I would have given a good deal to have been able to see the notice-board intact, as it would, perhaps, have given some clue to the ownership of the house. I remembered my experience of the investigation and purchase of Carfax, and I could not but feel that if I could find the former owner there might be some means discovered of gaining access to the house.
There was at present nothing to be learned from the Piccadilly side, and nothing could be done; so I went round to the back to see if anything could be gathered from this quarter. The mews were active, the Piccadilly houses being mostly in occupation. I asked one or two of the grooms and helpers whom I saw around if they could tell me anything about the empty house. One of them said that he heard it had lately been taken, but he couldn't say from whom. He told me, however, that up to very lately there had been a notice-board of "For Sale" up, and that perhaps Mitchell, Sons, & Candy, the house agents, could tell me something, as he thought he remembered seeing the name of that firm on the board. I did not wish to seem too eager, or to let my informant know or guess too much, so, thanking him in the usual manner, I strolled away. It was now growing dusk, and the autumn night was closing in, so I did not lose any time. Having learned the address of Mitchell, Sons, & Candy from a directory at the Berkeley, I was soon at their office in Sackville Street.
The gentleman who saw me was particularly suave in manner, but uncommunicative in equal proportion. Having once told me that the Piccadilly house—which throughout our interview he called a "mansion"—was sold, he considered my business as concluded. When I asked who had purchased it, he opened his eyes a thought wider, and paused a few seconds before replying:—
"It is sold, sir."
"Pardon me," I said, with equal politeness, "but I have a special reason for wishing to know who purchased it."
Again he paused longer, and raised his eyebrows still more. "It is sold, sir," was again his laconic reply.
"Surely," I said, "you do not mind letting me know so much."
"But I do mind," he answered. "The affairs of their clients are absolutely safe in the hands of Mitchell, Sons, & Candy." This was manifestly a prig of the first water, and there was no use arguing with him. I thought I had best meet him on his own ground, so I said:—
"Your clients, sir, are happy in having so resolute a guardian of their confidence. I am myself a professional man." Here I handed him my card. "In this instance I am not prompted by curiosity; I act on the part of Lord Godalming, who wishes to know something of the property which was, he understood, lately for sale." These words put a different complexion on affairs. He said:—
"I would like to oblige you if I could, Mr. Harker, and especially would I like to oblige his lordship. We once carried out a small matter of renting some chambers for him when he was the Honourable Arthur Holmwood. If you will let me have his lordship's address I will consult the House on the subject, and will, in any case, communicate with his lordship by to-night's post. It will be a pleasure if we can so far deviate from our rules as to give the required information to his lordship."
I wanted to secure a friend, and not to make an enemy, so I thanked him, gave the address at Dr. Seward's and came away. It was now dark, and I was tired and hungry. I got a cup of tea at the Aërated Bread Company and came down to Purfleet by the next train.
I found all the others at home. Mina was looking tired and pale, but she made a gallant effort to be bright and cheerful, it wrung my heart to think that I had had to keep anything from her and so caused her inquietude. Thank God, this will be the last night of her looking on at our conferences, and feeling the sting of our not showing our confidence. It took all my courage to hold to the wise resolution of keeping her out of our grim task. She seems somehow more reconciled; or else the very subject seems to have become repugnant to her, for when any accidental allusion is made she actually shudders. I am glad we made our resolution in time, as with such a feeling as this, our growing knowledge would be torture to her.
I could not tell the others of the day's discovery till we were alone; so after dinner—followed by a little music to save appearances even amongst ourselves—I took Mina to her room and left her to go to bed. The dear girl was more affectionate with me than ever, and clung to me as though she would detain me; but there was much to be talked of and I came away. Thank God, the ceasing of telling things has made no difference between us.
When I came down again I found the others all gathered round the fire in the study. In the train I had written my diary so far, and simply read it off to them as the best means of letting them get abreast of my own information; when I had finished Van Helsing said:—
"This has been a great day's work, friend Jonathan. Doubtless we are on the track of the missing boxes. If we find them all in that house, then our work is near the end. But if there be some missing, we must search until we find them. Then shall we make our final _coup_, and hunt the wretch to his real death." We all sat silent awhile and all at once Mr. Morris spoke:—
"Say! how are we going to get into that house?"
"We got into the other," answered Lord Godalming quickly.
"But, Art, this is different. We broke house at Carfax, but we had night and a walled park to protect us. It will be a mighty different thing to commit burglary in Piccadilly, either by day or night. I confess I don't see how we are going to get in unless that agency duck can find us a key of some sort; perhaps we shall know when you get his letter in the morning." Lord Godalming's brows contracted, and he stood up and walked about the room. By-and-by he stopped and said, turning from one to another of us:—
"Quincey's head is level. This burglary business is getting serious; we got off once all right; but we have now a rare job on hand—unless we can find the Count's key basket."
As nothing could well be done before morning, and as it would be at least advisable to wait till Lord Godalming should hear from Mitchell's, we decided not to take any active step before breakfast time. For a good while we sat and smoked, discussing the matter in its various lights and bearings; I took the opportunity of bringing this diary right up to the moment. I am very sleepy and shall go to bed....
Just a line. Mina sleeps soundly and her breathing is regular. Her forehead is puckered up into little wrinkles, as though she thinks even in her sleep. She is still too pale, but does not look so haggard as she did this morning. To-morrow will, I hope, mend all this; she will be herself at home in Exeter. Oh, but I am sleepy!
Dr. Seward's Diary.
2 October.—I placed a man in the corridor last night, and told him to make an accurate note of any sound he might hear from Renfield's room, and gave him instructions that if there should be anything strange he was to call me. After dinner, when we had all gathered round the fire in the study—Mrs. Harker having gone to bed—we discussed the attempts and discoveries of the day. Harker was the only one who had any result, and we are in great hopes that his clue may be an important one.
Before going to bed I went round to the patient's room and looked in through the observation trap. He was sleeping soundly, and his heart rose and fell with regular respiration.
This morning the man on duty reported to me that a little after midnight he was restless and kept saying his prayers somewhat loudly. I asked him if that was all; he replied that it was all he heard. There was something about his manner so suspicious that I asked him point blank if he had been asleep. He denied sleep, but admitted to having "dozed" for a while. It is too bad that men cannot be trusted unless they are watched.
To-day Harker is out following up his clue, and Art and Quincey are looking after horses. Godalming thinks that it will be well to have horses always in readiness, for when we get the information which we seek there will be no time to lose. We must sterilise all the imported earth between sunrise and sunset; we shall thus catch the Count at his weakest, and without a refuge to fly to. Van Helsing is off to the British Museum looking up some authorities on ancient medicine. The old physicians took account of things which their followers do not accept, and the Professor is searching for witch and demon cures which may be useful to us later.
I sometimes think we must be all mad and that we shall wake to sanity in strait-waistcoats.
Later.—We have met again. We seem at last to be on the track, and our work of to-morrow may be the beginning of the end. I wonder if Renfield's quiet has anything to do with this. His moods have so followed the doings of the Count, that the coming destruction of the monster may be carried to him in some subtle way. If we could only get some hint as to what passed in his mind, between the time of my argument with him to-day and his resumption of fly-catching, it might afford us a valuable clue. He is now seemingly quiet for a spell.... Is he?—— That wild yell seemed to come from his room....
The attendant came bursting into my room and told me that Renfield had somehow met with some accident. He had heard him yell; and when he went to him found him lying on his face on the floor, all covered with blood. I must go at once....
There’s a lot to be anxious about as AI agents and bots get more integrated into every aspect of our lives. Meta, which recently agreed to pay over $17 billion to settle a lawsuit related to harming kids, now wants you to hand over all your online accounts to an inexplicably cute “agent” named Muse that might give a stranger your home address. OpenAI just introduced little blobs called Dots that can supposedly automate routine tasks, like planning dinner and ordering it from your favorite neighborhood spot. AI companies don’t just want you to talk to their chatbots; they want their agents to be an indispensable part of your daily routine.
As a parent, however, I think that perhaps the worst thing AI could do is be my kid’s friend.
AI companions have been around longer than ChatGPT, and they’re growing in popularity with young users. More than half of teens have interacted with AI companions at least a few times a month, and one in three decided to talk about a serious issue with AI companions instead of real people, according to a Common Sense Media survey conducted last year. In certain groups and situations, a chatbot could offer some benefit — a lifeline for, say, LGBTQ youth who don’t have any in-person support networks, one study found. But even so, there are important caveats and risks.
If you have kids, these are horrifying stories to hear. It’s reasonable to wonder how widespread the issues are, and who they are affecting most. As of right now, the majority of younger kids aren’t using AI for companionship (phew!). But for those who are, where do the issues arise? And how do they go from using ChatGPT for help with their homework to opening up to it about their problems to preferring it to their human friends?
Some answers are starting to emerge from research.
Why I wrote this
My first daughter was born not long after ChatGPT hit the scene, and as someone who’s covered tech for years, I knew the technology’s effects would be profound, especially for young people. So when I came across Anne Maheux’s study on middle schools and AI companions, I had to know more about how things are going.
For even young adolescents, there’s a direct link between AI companion use and mental health issues, according to a new study by researchers at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Their paper, which is still under review, is the first longitudinal study in the US that has looked at the bidirectional association between AI companionship in adolescents and mental health issues, according to one of the researchers. It charted AI use among 2,300 middle schoolers and found that about one in five used AI for emotional companionship. Those who used AI more reported higher levels of loneliness.
“It’s not just that the lonely kids are using AI, and they’re otherwise unharmed,” said Anne Maheux, an assistant professor of psychology and neuroscience at UNC Chapel Hill and the lead author on the study. “It is that using AI comes first, and middle school students are increasing their sense of loneliness following the use of AI.”
I recently spoke to Maheux about her research and the role of technology in young people’s lives. We discussed how much parents and teachers know about what is going on, what kids get out of human relationships that AI can’t provide, and whether she’d let a child under her care use an AI chatbot. While she said there is a lot to be scared of right now, there is some evidence that, when designed with the intention of promoting child learning and development and under the supervision of a caring adult, AI can offer some benefits, and, ultimately, she’s optimistic that we can design a better future for kids.
The conversation below has been lightly edited for length and clarity.
How do so many kids end up with an AI companion? Do kids start using AI for homework help and end up in an emotional relationship with the technology?
At a high level, AI companions — in our darkest vision of what that might look like — would be a kid calling an AI chatbot their best friend. That phenomenon is still quite rare. There are certainly plenty of kids who are experiencing that, but it’s not to say that it’s all kids or even most kids. I think that’s good news.
But it’s also true that the line between opening up AI to ask a question about your homework and a full-blown AI companionship relationship involves a lot of gray areas. There’s evidence, mostly preliminary and anecdotal evidence, to suggest that very few people open up to AI with the primary initial goal of developing an intimate friendship or relationship.
Most people open it out of a curiosity, sense of novelty, or seeking an answer to a question that’s very pragmatic. Then that can potentially evolve into something more akin to seeking personal advice or help making a decision or help making sense of one’s recent experiences with other humans. And that can potentially evolve to something that’s a bit more emotional.
What did your latest study on adolescents, AI companions, and mental health reveal?
Some kids seek out AI for certain purposes in different ways than other kids. For some kids, AI companionship is particularly attractive, especially the kids who maybe don’t have close friends or social networks in their offline life and who are already lonely.
It’s a chicken-and-egg problem. Is it that these kids are seeking out AI companions or is it that having an AI companion is exacerbating those potential vulnerabilities or exacerbating risk for mental health problems? What we found is that interacting with an AI companion in a way that’s akin to emotional intimacy among middle school students is longitudinally associated with increases over time in loneliness. So the kids who are seeking out these companions, who are presumably already lonely, are also experiencing an increase in loneliness over time.
There is this potential directionality question that we’re starting to answer here: It’s not just that the lonely kids are using AI, and they’re otherwise unharmed. It is that using AI comes first, and middle school students are increasing their sense of loneliness following the use of AI. In other words, middle school students using AI for emotional intimacy and companionship developed greater loneliness over time.
Do you have a sense of how often these kids are using the chatbots?
In our sample — so again, these are US middle school kids — about 15 to 20 percent say that they’re using it at least a few times a week for any purpose. We don’t have specific rates of use for companionship because the questions that we asked were just not framed in a frequency measure, but more in how emotionally intimate they felt with the chatbot.
What else could have been causing that loneliness? There are almost definitely many causes, and I think that our data suggests that AI companionship may be one cause. It certainly isn’t definitive. Obviously, I have to say that. I’m a scientist and trying to be hesitant about these things, but the reality is that whether or not AI use causes loneliness in this particular case, there are definitely other things that are also causing loneliness.
That could be a myriad of things about the kid, maybe they have a lot of social anxiety, maybe they struggle with social skills, maybe the kid has had struggles in their family life and doesn’t have a strong sense of connection and belonging at home. It could be structural things. The kid just doesn’t have enough access to appropriate resources. So certainly there’s other things that are at play here, and typically technology use is one of many factors that can influence a kid’s mental health.
And how much do you think that parents and teachers know about what’s going on, and how well-equipped do you think they are to intervene or to just be more involved in how these kids are using this technology?
It’s a very slippery technology. The way kids are using it has changed rapidly in just the last year or two years. I would expect that parents, teachers, people who care about kids are probably struggling with the rapidity of change. But it’s also true that all the things that we have known for a long time about supporting kids and helping them thrive, those things are still true and they’ll be true with whatever technology comes after AI that kids are exploring.
Those things include being curious, asking kids questions about their lived experiences online and offline, having conversations with kids so that they can understand the implications of different technology use. They can understand how, for example, AI is embedded within a broader system of social and political and economic factors, including the fact that many companies are trying to exploit kids’ attention in order to make money, which many kids are quite interested to hear about.
Supporting kids also means providing a warm and supportive space for them to learn, to make mistakes, to be kids in the offline world, to have the frictionful, challenging, awkward conversations and first dates and all of the things that parents are sometimes trying to protect kids from by providing a safe container for them to explore those things. All of that can also provide avenues for kids to learn what they need to learn and develop — all the resources for a long life of thriving, even in the context of AI or other new technologies.
What do kids learn from having these kinds of conversations with other humans that they can’t get from AI?
Kids need to engage with other people, period. That’s true for all of us. We’re an incredibly social species. Simply being around other people and talking to strangers, let alone having strong social bonds, is really good for us. And all those things are uniquely important during adolescence, when kids have this neurobiological sensitivity to social information and reward. That’s when kids learn how to engage in conversation, they learn how to maintain eye contact, how to read body language, how to read emotions and perceive the world from the lens of someone else, to take their perspective. That’s not to mention other things, like being a member of one’s culture, what is valued, and what is expected. All of that is learned in the context of other human social relationships or relationships with broader social groups that a kid might be a member of.
AI obviously can’t and never will be able to offer some of those things. It can’t actually experience empathy or care. It can’t engage in a true mutual human relationship. It may be able to simulate some of those things, and there’s some evidence that it can serve as a source of social practice. It can help kids work through the potential for difficult conversations and then serve as a bridge to engaging with other people. But there are aspects of AI that just simply can never replace the core sacred aspects of humans.
Can you be more specific? What is it about human relationships that can’t AI simulate?
The way that AI systems are currently designed, which is not an inherent feature, but is a design choice, is to be sycophantic, highly agreeable, anthropomorphized, and all of those things can lead to kids developing expectations or understandings of interactive relationships that are actually fundamentally at odds with a normal human relationship. Some of the most consistent things that I’ve seen in the educated hypotheses on this topic and also in the emerging empirical research is that people need the friction that comes with human relationships.
Human relationships are just hard and messy, and they’re also really beautiful. They’re what make so much of human life valuable and worth living. And with AI that’s always agreeable, that’s always available, that has no needs of its own, that can’t care or be cared for, it just doesn’t serve the same context to help kids learn things like conflict resolution or negotiation, being pro-social or caring for someone else who has needs. So many of those aspects that can feel uncomfortable in the moment, dealing with another person or a person who’s not responding right away, those things are actually important in the building blocks of developing the skills and capacities to be a functioning and thriving person in the social adult world.
This is a problem with AI in general, isn’t it? It makes things effortless, but if you choose this path of least resistance, you’ll avoid the friction that causes you to learn and develop and build skills you need to exist in the world.
Absolutely. And I think that all these things are connected too. AI offers this effortless, frictionless solution to our day-to-day problems, whether they’re social problems, whether they’re problems doing our homework, and those immediate solutions feel really good in the moment, so they’re quite tempting to keep coming back to. But there’s this real possibility that in the long term, that erodes our capacity for not only social relationships or cognitive skills, but just a general ability to withstand the momentary day-to-day distress of being a person living a normal life. And so I think every domain of human psychology comes together at that point, whether it’s social, emotional, mental health, or cognitive.
Do you think that there are interventions that legislators could make or even that tech companies could make that would improve outcomes for kids, maybe make them a little less lonely?
There are a million specific design changes that I would recommend. I think at a very minimum, AI systems can afford a pretty phenomenal amount of access to information, but there’s been no benefits that I’ve seen of them acting as friends. Kids need other human friends, full stop. Designing systems that are intended to exploit kids’ vulnerability or sensitivity to human social information and relationships, I think, is bad for kids.
At the federal level, it seems that regulation is not coming, but at the state level, there have been many state regulations intended to protect kids, intended to create safer systems, to put in guardrails, to modulate different aspects of the models, the design, the user interface. These things could potentially make a real difference, I think.
What do you recommend parents do with regard to AI and their kids? Should they let them use chatbots?
In short, no. But I am not a parent, and it’s much easier to dole out advice than it is to enact it. Parenting decisions about technology are not one-size-fits-all. Kids, parents, family dynamics, technology, and the context in which it is used differ, and in so many cases are personal choices (parents must weigh various potential opportunities and risks). Decades of research indicate what conditions a child needs to thrive. Extremely minimal research addresses the effects of AI on youth, and what we have so far suggests that the risks outweigh the benefits.
I would not give a child under my care AI chatbots of any kind to use without me or another trusted adult present. I would talk to them openly about AI and its risks and benefits, but to me AI, like all technology, should be a tool used to promote human thriving, and when the evidence is unclear or suggestive of harms, I think it’s best not to experiment on kids. Currently, the off-the-shelf AI chatbots most kids are using appears more likely to undermine well-being for vulnerable users, especially children.
Well, as a father of two daughters, I’m definitely terrified of what’s to come in the next few years.
There’s a lot to be scared of, but there’s a lot to be hopeful of too. I think that everyone wants kids to thrive. Some of us are under different incentives, and some of those incentives might be perverse. But most of us are working really hard to design a better world for kids.
Last month a young woman filed a lawsuit against Cornell University, alleging that two years ago the university failed to protect her from being raped by seven men at a fraternity house near the university campus. She also sued the fraternity. The lawsuit has plunged the university into a crisis and invited criticism of the district attorney, Matthew Van Houten, who decided there wasn’t enough evidence to bring criminal charges against the seven men.
At this point we can only guess why neither Cornell nor Van Houten did more in response to the young woman’s allegations. But it seems to me that we’re living through a time when men — including privileged young men at a frat house in an Ivy League university — feel some impunity when it comes to attacking women.
I don’t think it unrelated to such feelings of impunity that the man now occupying the highest office in the land was found in civil court to have sexually molested writer E. Jean Carroll (and whose behavior the presiding judge at that trial described as “rape”). Or that this same man has repeatedly insulted the physical appearance of female journalists, politicians, and public figures. Or that he was caught on a hot microphone boasting about using his fame to forcefully kiss and grope women without consent, stating that being a star allows men to "do anything" and “grab ’em by the pussy.”
When women have spoken out against him, Trump has resorted to smear campaigns, as he did with Carroll, Stormy Daniels, and Hillary Clinton. When women have stood up to him, he has exploded in anger against them, as he did with Megyn Kelly, Rosie O’Donnell, Kamala Harris, and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.
As Sophie Gilbert wrote in The Atlantic, “The misogyny that Trump embodies and champions is less about loathing than enforcement: underscoring his requirement that women look and behave a certain way, that we comply with his desires and submit to our required social function.”
His administration is the most belligerently misogynistic of any in memory. It has openly equated testosterone levels to strength and courage, conducted a cage match on the White House lawn as part of its celebration of America’s 250th anniversary, fired every senior female official in sight, and accused the Democratic Party of being run by "a bunch of childless cat ladies.”
Nor do I think it irrelevant that Trump, JD Vance, and Trump’s erstwhile pal Elon Musk inhabit what’s been termed the “manosphere” — a place where the main events are dominance and submission. The whole point is to humiliate weak men and to subjugate women.
An implicit promise of the 2024 Trump campaign was to restore patriarchy to America. Trump voters were overwhelmingly male.
After Trump’s reelection, sexist and abusive attacks on women — such as “your body, my choice” and “get back to the kitchen” — surged across social media, according to an analysis from the Institute for Strategic Dialogue.
A remarkable number of Trump’s cronies are sexual harassers and predators. Trump was introduced at the Republican National Convention by Dana White, chief executive of the Ultimate Fighting Championship, who was once caught on tape slapping his wife in a nightclub.
JD Vance has claimed men in America are “suppressed” in their masculinity.
Before becoming Trump’s defense secretary, Pete Hegseth paid off a woman who accused him of sexual assault. (Hegseth’s own mother accused him of abusing women, though she later disavowed her words.) And as secretary, Hegseth has championed “high-T” men, demanded that women be removed from front-line combat roles, and blocked promotions of female officers.
Trump’s HHS secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., was accused of sexually harassing his family’s nanny and at one point kept a diary of his conquests, which his wife at the time found.
One of Elon Musk’s companies, SpaceX, reportedly paid $250,000 to a flight attendant who said Musk exposed himself to her. In a lawsuit filed last year, former employees accused him of “treating women as sexual objects to be evaluated on their bra size.”
One of the most pathetic members of the manosphere is Mark Zuckerberg. After kissing Trump’s derriere, the third-richest man in America called for more “masculine energy” because the corporate world was becoming “culturally neutered.” He told Joe Rogan that “having a culture that celebrates the aggression a bit more has its own merits that are really positive.”
The Trump regime celebrated toxic masculinity by smoothing the way for Andrew and Tristan Tate to be extradited from Romania to the United States. The Tate bros had been accused of luring women to Romania and then forcing them to work as pornographic webcam performers. Britain is also investigating the Tate brothers for rape and human trafficking in Britain. (U.S. Marshals arrested the Tate brothers in Miami on July 18, following an extradition request from the United Kingdom.)
Andrew Tate is a big fan of Trump, championing him to his millions of mostly young male followers on social media. “I’m a Trump fan because I’m a man,” Tate has said. “You have to support Trump if you’re a man.”
***
Trump’s authoritarian manosphere is organized around a hierarchy topped by heroic male warriors. Winning is all about getting other males to submit to the dominant male. Women are relegated to subservient roles.
Anything that challenges the traditional heroic male roles of protector, provider, and controller of the family is considered a threat to the social order. LGBTQ+ people are believed to weaken the heroic male. Hence, Trump’s executive order declaring that the U.S. government will recognize only a person’s sex assigned at birth, limit the definition of a “male” or “female” to their reproductive cells, and potentially withhold federal funding from programs that acknowledge transgender people or “gender ideology.”
**
I don’t want to oversimplify a complex social phenomenon or engage in the same kind of gender stereotypes that the manosphere promotes. Male domination is hardly the only characteristic that unites Trump, Vance, Hegseth, Kennedy Jr., Musk, and the Tech Bros. Misogyny is not unique to authoritarian men.
Nor do I presume to know what happened at the Cornell fraternity house two years ago. But I don’t think it unreasonable to see it related to America’s slide toward a neofascism rooted in deep distrust, bordering on hate, of people who seem weak or feminine — people who were born as, or have become, women.
In 1995, gender studies researcher Judy Chu found herself chauffeuring around her 13-year-old brother and his friend. The boys’ curiosity got the better of them, and they asked what she was learning: adolescent girls’ development, she told them.
One of the boys looked at her and said, “‘You should study boys. You can start with me,’” Chu recalled. So she did. That fall, she spoke to 13-year-old boys from home for her clinical interviewing class.
In the years since, Chu has researched boys between the ages 12 and 18 — their wishes, their desires, what they wanted from their friendships and romantic relationships — and discovered some felt largely unknown. There was a gap between what the world expected of them — the stoic, strong, independent stereotypes that have persisted for centuries — and how they saw themselves, but had internalized so many messages for so long that they felt like they had no choice but to accept this version of masculinity. Chu theorized that these beliefs must have taken root during their childhood, and she later published a book on the subject.
Key takeaways
By many measures, including academic achievement and labor force participation, men are behind their female peers.
Rather than address these issues in adulthood, many therapists and gender studies researchers agree that pushing back against rigid gender stereotypes in childhood could help foster more resilient men.
Parents, teachers, coaches, and other adults in boys’ lives should empower boys to be in touch with their emotions, to encourage open conversation, and develop deep friendships, according to experts.
When toddlers enter school, she discovered, they begin learning the rules of boyhood. “Regardless of what their parents had encouraged or enabled at home, they were learning that at school, if you wanted to be seen as and treated as one of the boys and you wanted to be with the boys, you wanted to play with the boys, be friends with the boys, there were rules you had to follow,” Chu said. “It was kind of like a microcosm of our society, which is if you want people to see you as and treat you as a quote unquote real boy or real man, you need to prove yourself.”
Across the country, lawmakers have promoted policies and legislation aimed at helping men reach their potential. In California, Gov. Gavin Newsom signed a 2025 executive order outlining education, career, and mental health initiatives targeting men. Maryland Gov. Wes Moore created the state’s Young Men and Boys Initiative, focusing on men’s health, employment, and community connections. But these programs are reactive, attempting to disrupt decades of socialization. At the same time, the rise of the manosphere and misogynist online spaces and increasingly right-leaning voting trends among men signal a cohort of young men at a turning point.
So what will it take to help men get unstuck? If we are truly committed to ending the male loneliness crisis, to tackling suicide and gun violence — society has the power to change things for the next generation, experts said. Rather than aiming to reach men after the constraining masculine worldviews have already taken root, we can prevent them from warping boys’ sense of self in the first place: To help men, we must change how boys are raised.
Reject the myth of the “real boy”
In 2023, psychologist Michael Reichert conducted a nationally representative survey of more than 2,000 American men, asking them questions about their lives, relationships, internet habits, and sources of social support. One finding was particularly staggering: two-thirds of young men between the ages of 18 and 23 felt like no one really knew them well. (In a follow-up report two years later, in which women were also surveyed, equal percentages of men and women — about 50 percent — said they were not truly known.)
The conclusion Reichert came to, he told Vox, was “boyhood is failing at the most important task.” American society is producing young adults who feel like they’re on their own, “a tragic outcome of a boyhood that’s not preparing our males for a resilient life in a world where things are harder, more complicated,” said Reichert, the executive director of the Center for the Study of Boys’ and Girls’ Lives at the University of Pennsylvania.
Because the idea of what a man looks like and how a man behaves is so ingrained, boys are taught to conform from an early age, experts said. From their earliest years, as evidenced in Chu’s work, boys are taught to adhere to stereotypical gender norms reinforced through comments like “boys don’t cry,” “toughen up,” and “don’t be a girl.”
“It starts with mothers having a fear of turning their son into a mama’s boy, so they push them away at young ages — 3 and 4 years old. Go play with your dad, go play with your older male siblings,” Joseph Derrick Nelson, an associate professor in the department of educational studies at Swarthmore College, told Vox. Fathers, for their part, tend to emphasize self-defense, goal pursuit, and overcoming adversity with their sons, Reichert said. Black boys in particular are perceived as older and less innocent than their white counterparts, only pushing them further toward rigid gender roles, Nelson said. If they don’t conform, they may be teased by other boys.
A large part of proving yourself as a “real boy” means rejecting anything deemed feminine, including emotional vulnerability and relationships. As babies and young children, boys and girls are equally emotionally expressive, but by the time they start school, boys show fewer emotions and use less emotional language. When boys are taught that showing their feelings or forging deep friendships is girly, they stop prioritizing those relationships. That shift happens during the teen years, when boys go from reporting having best friends with whom they can share their deepest secrets, to feeling like they’ve drifted apart from these very connections by the end of high school. And it’s not for lack of desire, Chu said, or some inherent biological difference: Boys have simply learned not to show their need for affection, to hide their sadness, to not be tender.
A new paradigm for raising boys, experts said, begins with how masculinity is first presented at home and in school.
To encourage boys to be better in touch with their emotions means adults should not pit masculinity against femininity, Christopher Reigeluth, an associate professor at Oregon Health and Science University, told Vox. This goes beyond simply telling boys not to conceal their feelings, but making clear that confiding these feelings in a friend and fostering platonic connections isn’t girly: it’s a universal human need.
In schools, specialized emotional education in curricula can help boys express their emotions and embrace vulnerability.
Reichert, the psychologist, has led an emotional literacy program in a boys’ school for over 30 years. In that time, he’s seen the sentiment among students shift from skepticism to genuine interest. “It has become, by 2026, the most popular program in the school,” Reichert said, due to an increased cultural awareness of emotional health. In the group, students discuss their daily stressors and hardships, and they learn that letting their peers see them for who they are — connecting with them — benefits their well-being.
Before joining Reichert’s peer counseling group, high school senior Chris Burnetta expressed his emotions on the field. “You’re almost allowed to be emotional when you’re playing sports, and you’re not allowed to be emotional when you’re not,” Burnetta, 18, told Vox. In middle school, he attended a co-ed school and found himself performing aspects of masculinity to impress his female classmates. But once he met older classmates who he respected and wanted to emulate, he discovered many of them attended the counseling group and encouraged him to go, too. “I don’t want to speak for everyone, but I think for guys in general, looking up at people above you gives you a big impression and a big influence on how you want to live your life and what you want to be like,” he said.
Seeing his peers so enthusiastically discuss their struggles and triumphs helps foster maturity and gives him permission to show his emotions, Burnetta said, an outlet he never had before.
Adolescence, a time when many behavioral health patterns are forged or discarded, is the time to engrain healthy social habits in boys — and for parents to be explicit, Matt Englar-Carlson, a professor of counseling and the director of the Center for Boys and Men at California State University Fullerton, told Vox. Now is the time to have dedicated phone-free time as a family, to give them opportunities to share how they’re feeling without fixing their problems, to listen to them even when they’re frustrating you. When his own son was younger, Englar-Carlson thought he knew all the tricks: showing empathy, trying to help. “Me doing that with him actually was making him feel worse, I think,” he said. Instead, Englar-Carlson took a lighter touch. He would acknowledge when his son was upset, but wouldn’t press a conversation. Whenever his son was ready to talk, he was available.
One easy way to do this? Talk to them when you’re driving. As my colleague Rachel Miller previously reported, not having to make direct eye contact can make it a little easier for kids to be vulnerable.
And if you’re a man, make sure you’re leading by example: Be willing to share your own moments of embarrassment, disappointment, and sadness, so they know it’s okay for them to do the same.
Help them foster non-romantic intimacy
While in school, boys have ample avenues for connection through classes and sports, even if they aren’t interacting with others on a deeper level. It’s when they lose access to these organized outlets for socialization in adulthood that they slide into isolation or start looking to their romantic partners to fulfill all of their social needs.
The idea that emotional intimacy is reserved for your significant other is how society gets to a point where 15 percent of men say they don’t have any close friends. Those without a partner are even more adrift: Men are less satisfied being single than their female counterparts. “We teach boys to not ask for help…figure it out on their own,” Nelson said. “I don’t know why we’re surprised when they become adult men and struggle with building relationships and close and connected communities, because all they’ve been taught, even since they were young children, was about figuring it out on their own and denying emotions, suppressing emotions, that then leaves you not in relationship and quite lonely.”
In the absence of in-person friendships, digital spaces provide an attractive alternative. While not altogether negative, some online forums — interactive video games, sports gambling, the manosphere — enable young men to further retreat from society. While pursuing community, boys may find their way to adult-centric spaces, which can be rife with misogynistic and patriarchal messages, feeding the belief that the only way to advance is through hyperconsumption, materialism, looksmaxxing, and dominating women, Nelson said. “They’re quarantining themselves to their rooms and their tech devices and these online communities where they play video games, they gamble on sports, and they have conversations with other boys and young men online about somehow feeling disadvantaged as men in our society,” he said.
Burnetta, the high school senior, said he and many of his classmates’ feeds are populated with “super masculine” content that sometimes pokes fun at men who open up about their feelings, which can further add to the stereotype that men should not be emotional.
Even if boys don’t necessarily agree with these sentiments, they often don’t have other alternatives online. “I don’t think a lot of boys go on to YouTube…and say, ‘I really want to find the most misogynistic content I can find. That’s what I’m looking for,’” said Englar-Carlson, the director of the Center for Boys and Men. They may have simply wanted to watch a video about sports but were fed an ad for betting and then fell down the rabbit hole. Because traditional masculinity content is often fed to boys via their social media feeds, a brief introduction to these themes only leads to more.
By young adulthood, they will have a fairly concrete idea of what’s expected of them as a man. In a 2017 study, young men largely agreed that the cornerstones of masculinity are self-sufficiency, toughness, physical attractiveness, being a financial provider, heterosexuality, hypersexuality, aggression, and control. Notably, they said they feel external pressure from family, friends, and society to meet these ideals.
If adults start with the understanding that boys are emotional and they have the same social needs as girls, they can encourage them to make friends before they learn otherwise.
Teachers can recognize the signs of loneliness in young boys (resisting authority, talking back, and challenging boundaries) and use it as an opportunity to connect with their students instead of reprimanding them — because when they feel heard, their behavior softens. “What are these behaviors communicating to me from this boy about a met or unmet need, and how can I be responsive to it in my classroom? How can I help them facilitate close and connected friendships with not only their peers, but also with me as their teacher, like a primary adult in their lives?” Nelson said. When young boys simply get kicked out of class, they might fall behind and internalize a “bad boy” persona, he said, a cycle that enforces stereotypes and comes at the cost of their education.
The story of masculinity online and from political leaders is that men must be protectors, high earners, and muscular and strong, and when boys fail to meet that standard (which they inevitably do because they are children), they are made to feel inadequate. “They’re struggling in school, they’re having a difficult time finding work, but everything about what they’re learning about to live in America is about the dream, the aspirations, acquiring, hitting these life milestones,” Nelson said.
Demonstrate an alternative masculinity
But for some young men, the most impactful interventions take place while they’re young. Growing up, Michael Dean looked to his father and his friends’ fathers for how to be a man. These men often spoke of the importance of providing for a family, being decisive, and being a stable force. Dean thought everyone was raised with these values and had similar upbringings until he reached high school and joined Reichert’s peer counseling program.
His junior year, one of Dean’s teammates on the football team suggested that some of the young men check out the group to discuss any problems at school, issues with parents, friends, or partners. Dean was frustrated with his performance on the field and decided to attend. Hearing from his classmates — their grief, their struggles — helped give him perspective. He also learned how to be an emotional outlet for the people he loves, including his younger brother.
“I never felt that I had to be some kind of way or be some kind of man based on traditional values of being that strong, tough guy and to keep persevering through. I could definitely see that through my dad, and I did have that belief for a little while as I was in middle school and in the beginning of high school,” Dean, now 21, told Vox. “I learned that that’s not necessarily what it means to be a man, and I can make my own judgment through my own experiences and listening to other people to help me figure out what it means in my own belief to be a man.”
For Dean, learning how to be a man began when he was a child, but his path to adulthood was punctuated by formative adults — his mother, Reichert, and yes, even his dad — who fostered a safe environment to be vulnerable and emotional. Now, when he’s lonely, he knows he can call his family, friends, or his girlfriend for support. These are the outlets experts hope men feel empowered to call upon.
“If we’re really going to make a bigger difference with having healthier men who have connected friendships, who are emotionally expressive and connected in their friendships,” Reigeluth said, “it’s got to start with boys.”
In the moody alcoves of a lobby bar in Chicago in 2021 over French 75s, Dr. Louise King, a gynecologic surgeon, and Katie L. Watson, a bioethics professor, found themselves in conversation about a topic that had long frustrated them both: Female surgeons are consistently underpaid compared to male surgeons, even after accounting for specialty, rank, age, and other factors.
What troubled them even more was how the pay gap compounded in King’s own field. Surgeons who perform procedures that are specifically for women, like gynecological surgeries, are paid less for their services than surgeons who perform comparable surgeries for the male anatomy. Gynecologic surgeons are also predominantly women. Over the course of the conversation, Watson termed this situation “double discrimination,” a phrase that captures the overlapping dilemma of lower pay for surgeries in a specialty that is overwhelmingly female and also serves a primarily female patient population.
Key takeaways
Doctors are paid less for gynecologic surgeries than for similar surgeries on men. That pay gap has barely improved in the last 20 years.
The value of each procedure is largely set by a committee of doctors that relies on self-reported, and sometimes inaccurate, surveys in which doctors report the skill and time their own procedures require.
When doctors are paid less to treat women’s health concerns, hospitals allocate fewer resources to those services, leading to worse outcomes for women
Experts say the gap can be closed by reconsidering how gynecologic surgeries are valued and removing sex-specific billing codes.
That term, which has since entered the medical literature, stuck because the problem it describes has been well documented for decades. In 1997, a group of gynecologic surgeons published a paper in the journal Gynecologic Oncology with a title that gets straight to it — “Is Adam worth more than Eve?” Dr. Barbara A. Goff, now chair of Obstetrics and Gynecology at University of Washington Medicine, and colleagues found that doctors are paid around 44 percent more for performing male-specific procedures than analogous female-specific ones.
In the three decades since, the problem hasn’t been fixed. To the contrary, it has been effectively institutionalized, built into the systems and codes that determine how surgeons bill for procedures of all kinds. Today, gynecologic or female-specific procedures are in large part still reimbursed at lower rates than male-specific procedures even when they take similar time and skill.
Those disparities have consequences that extend beyond the compensation of individual doctors. When gynecological procedures don’t bring in as much money to hospitals, those same hospitals are disincentivised to offer women’s health services. That can lead to worse care for women and, crucially, fewer training opportunities for the surgeons who do that work.
But this historically persistent inequality is not a foregone conclusion.
How healthcare services are billed changes all the time as procedures get reevaluated, new ones get added, and medical societies and experts push for revisions. In fact, one of the biggest changes in how maternity care is billed and reimbursed is set to take effect early next year, splitting up services for prenatal care, delivery, postpartum care, and more. While this is a long-overdue fix for obstetrics, gynecologic surgery — which covers most of a woman’s life outside of childbearing years — continues to be left out of the conversation.
And although real change will require concerted efforts, King and Watson — and other advocates who have spent years documenting this disparity — have a fairly clear sense of how to start fixing it.
How surgical procedures are valued
The work of deciding how much a medical procedure is worth starts well above the head of any given doctor, medical practice, or hospital. In the United States, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, a federal agency that administers healthcare and health insurance policies, sets rates for different procedures based on a metric called relative value units (RVUs). An RVU is supposed to take into account how long a procedure takes, the skill it requires, and the intensity of work it demands. Both Medicare and private insurers consider these figures when they’re settling on reimbursement levels. If a procedure has a higher RVU, it is valued more highly, and makes more money.
In a recent study, cheekily titled “Price and Prejudice,” researchers from the Mount Sinai Health System found that out of 55 pairs of sex-specific procedures that they evaluated in 2023, 75 percent had lower RVUs for procedures on female patients. On average, RVUs for male-specific procedures were 30 percent higher, and when those procedures were performed in a hospital or surgical center, surgeons were paid around 26 percent more.
For example, doctors will often perform biopsies — taking a small sample of tissues, cells, or fluids — on both male and female genitalia to diagnose problems. In 2023, researchers found that Medicare’s standard national rate for reimbursing surgeons was $121.32 for a penile biopsy but only $65.74 for a vaginal biopsy.
Loading interactive graphic…
.ag-root{--ag-m: #3b3fb6;--ag-f: #e2552c;--ag-m-ink: #3b3fb6;--ag-f-ink: #c74d2a;--ag-bg: transparent;--ag-knock: #ffffff;--ag-card: #f5f4f1;--ag-ink: #16161d;--ag-ink-2: #4a4a55;--ag-ink-3: #686872;--ag-rule: #16161d;--ag-grid: #e4e3df;--ag-track: #ebeae6;--ag-focus: #1a73e8;--ag-head: var(--ag-host,Georgia,"Times New Roman",serif);--ag-ui: -apple-system,BlinkMacSystemFont,"Segoe UI","Helvetica Neue",Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif;--ag-head-weight: 700;--ag-head-track: -0.01em;--ag-ease: cubic-bezier(.2,.8,.2,1);container-type: inline-size;container-name: ag;display: block;position: relative;width: 100%;max-width: 760px;margin: 2.25em auto;padding: 14px 0 10px;border-top: 3px solid var(--ag-rule);background: var(--ag-bg);color: var(--ag-ink);font-family: var(--ag-ui);font-size: 16px;line-height: 1.4;text-align: left;-webkit-font-smoothing: antialiased;-webkit-text-size-adjust: 100%;box-sizing: border-box}.ag-root.ag-root{font-family: var(--ag-ui);font-size: 16px;line-height: 1.4;font-style: normal;font-weight: 400;letter-spacing: normal;word-spacing: normal;text-transform: none;text-indent: 0;text-align: left;color: var(--ag-ink)}.ag-root.ag-root i,.ag-root.ag-root em{font-style: normal}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ft em{font-style: italic}.ag-root.ag-root *,.ag-root.ag-root *::before,.ag-root.ag-root *::after{box-sizing: border-box;letter-spacing: inherit;font-family: inherit;text-transform: inherit}.ag-root[data-ag-palette="teal"]{--ag-m: #00829b;--ag-f: #d4661a;--ag-m-ink: #007a91;--ag-f-ink: #b85a1a}.ag-root[data-ag-palette="violet"]{--ag-m: #5b3fb0;--ag-f: #c4661c;--ag-m-ink: #5b3fb0;--ag-f-ink: #b35e1c}.ag-root[data-ag-style="feature"]{--ag-head: "Bricolage Grotesque","Helvetica Neue",Arial,sans-serif;--ag-ui: "Instrument Sans","Helvetica Neue",Arial,sans-serif;--ag-head-weight: 800;--ag-head-track: -0.025em}.ag-root[data-ag-style="minimal"]{--ag-head: var(--ag-ui);--ag-head-weight: 650;--ag-head-track: -0.015em}.ag-root[data-ag-mode="dark"]{--ag-bg: #141417;--ag-knock: #141417;--ag-card: #1f1f24;--ag-ink: #ededf2;--ag-ink-2: #b9b9c4;--ag-ink-3: #8b8b97;--ag-rule: #ededf2;--ag-grid: #2c2c33;--ag-track: #26262c;--ag-focus: #8ab4f8;--ag-m: #6f73e8;--ag-f: #e5603a;--ag-m-ink: var(--ag-m);--ag-f-ink: var(--ag-f);color-scheme: dark}.ag-root[data-ag-mode="dark"][data-ag-palette="teal"]{--ag-m: #1e9db3;--ag-f: #dd7430;--ag-m-ink: #1e9db3;--ag-f-ink: #dd7430}.ag-root[data-ag-mode="dark"][data-ag-palette="violet"]{--ag-m: #8a6ee6;--ag-f: #cf7f22;--ag-m-ink: #8a6ee6;--ag-f-ink: #cf7f22}@media (prefers-color-scheme: dark){.ag-root[data-ag-mode="auto"]{--ag-bg: #141417;--ag-knock: #141417;--ag-card: #1f1f24;--ag-ink: #ededf2;--ag-ink-2: #b9b9c4;--ag-ink-3: #8b8b97;--ag-rule: #ededf2;--ag-grid: #2c2c33;--ag-track: #26262c;--ag-focus: #8ab4f8;--ag-m: #6f73e8;--ag-f: #e5603a;--ag-m-ink: var(--ag-m);--ag-f-ink: var(--ag-f);color-scheme: dark}.ag-root[data-ag-mode="auto"][data-ag-palette="teal"]{--ag-m: #1e9db3;--ag-f: #dd7430;--ag-m-ink: #1e9db3;--ag-f-ink: #dd7430}.ag-root[data-ag-mode="auto"][data-ag-palette="violet"]{--ag-m: #8a6ee6;--ag-f: #cf7f22;--ag-m-ink: #8a6ee6;--ag-f-ink: #cf7f22}}.ag-root[data-ag-mode="dark"]{padding-left: 16px;padding-right: 16px}@media (prefers-color-scheme: dark){.ag-root[data-ag-mode="auto"]{padding-left: 16px;padding-right: 16px}}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-x,.ag-root.ag-root p,.ag-root.ag-root h2,.ag-root.ag-root h3,.ag-root.ag-root button,.ag-root.ag-root select,.ag-root.ag-root input,.ag-root.ag-root ul,.ag-root.ag-root li,.ag-root.ag-root label,.ag-root.ag-root table{margin: 0;padding: 0;border: 0;background: none;box-shadow: none;font: inherit;color: inherit;letter-spacing: normal;text-transform: none;text-decoration: none;line-height: inherit;min-height: 0;width: auto;max-width: none;float: none}.ag-root.ag-root svg,.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-svgwrap svg{display: block;max-width: none;height: auto;overflow: visible}.ag-root.ag-root button{cursor: pointer;-webkit-appearance: none;appearance: none;border-radius: 0}.ag-root.ag-root :focus{outline: none}.ag-root.ag-root :focus-visible{outline: 2px solid var(--ag-focus);outline-offset: 2px;border-radius: 4px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-sr{position: absolute !important;width: 1px !important;height: 1px !important;padding: 0 !important;margin: -1px !important;overflow: hidden !important;clip: rect(0 0 0 0) !important;white-space: nowrap !important;border: 0 !important}.ag-root.ag-root [hidden]{display: none !important}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-hed{font-family: var(--ag-head);font-size: 23px;line-height: 1.12;font-weight: var(--ag-head-weight);letter-spacing: var(--ag-head-track);color: var(--ag-ink);text-wrap: balance}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-dek{font-size: 15px;line-height: 1.4;color: var(--ag-ink-2);margin-top: 6px;text-wrap: pretty}@container ag (max-width: 480px){.ag-root.ag-root .ag-hed{font-size: 22px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-dek{font-size: 14px}}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ft{margin-top: 14px;padding-top: 12px;border-top: 1px solid var(--ag-grid);font-size: 12px;line-height: 1.45;color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-method{margin-bottom: 8px;font-size: 12.5px;line-height: 1.5;color: var(--ag-ink-2);text-wrap: pretty}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-method b{font-weight: 600;color: var(--ag-ink)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ft-row{display: flex;flex-wrap: wrap;align-items: baseline;gap: 2px 14px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ft em{font-style: italic}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-credit{color: var(--ag-ink-3);white-space: nowrap}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-about-btn{margin-left: auto;padding: 4px 0;font-size: 12px;font-weight: 500;color: var(--ag-ink-2);display: inline-flex;align-items: center;gap: 6px;white-space: nowrap}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-about-btn::after{content: "";width: 5px;height: 5px;margin-top: -3px;border-right: 1.5px solid currentColor;border-bottom: 1.5px solid currentColor;transform: rotate(45deg)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-about-btn:hover{color: var(--ag-ink)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ft-end{margin-left: auto;display: flex;align-items: center;gap: 14px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-logo{flex: none;align-self: center;width: 31px;height: 15px;background-color: var(--ag-ink);-webkit-mask: url("") center / contain no-repeat;mask: url("") center / contain no-repeat}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-about{margin-top: 8px;padding-left: 10px;border-left: 2px solid var(--ag-grid);display: grid;gap: 6px;font-size: 12.5px;line-height: 1.5;color: var(--ag-ink-2)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-about a{color: inherit;text-decoration: underline;text-decoration-color: var(--ag-ink-3);text-underline-offset: 2px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-about a:hover{text-decoration-color: currentColor}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-sw{display: inline-block;width: 10px;height: 10px;border-radius: 50%;flex: none;vertical-align: baseline}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-sw-m{background: var(--ag-m)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-sw-f{background: var(--ag-f)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-num{font-variant-numeric: tabular-nums}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn{display: inline-flex;align-items: center;justify-content: center;gap: 8px;min-height: 44px;padding: 10px 18px;border-radius: 999px;background: var(--ag-ink);color: var(--ag-knock);font-size: 15px;font-weight: 650;line-height: 1;transition: transform .15s var(--ag-ease),opacity .15s}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn:hover{opacity: .88}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn:active{transform: scale(.97)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn[disabled]{opacity: .35;cursor: default}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn-ghost{background: transparent;color: var(--ag-ink);box-shadow: inset 0 0 0 1.5px var(--ag-grid)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn-ghost:hover{box-shadow: inset 0 0 0 1.5px var(--ag-ink-3);opacity: 1}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-icon-btn{display: inline-flex;align-items: center;justify-content: center;width: 44px;height: 44px;flex: none;border-radius: 50%;color: var(--ag-ink);box-shadow: inset 0 0 0 1.5px var(--ag-grid);transition: box-shadow .15s}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-icon-btn:hover{box-shadow: inset 0 0 0 1.5px var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-icon-btn svg{width: 18px;height: 18px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-axis-cap{display: flex;justify-content: space-between;gap: 12px;font-size: 12px;color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-bar-track{position: relative;height: 16px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-bar{position: absolute;left: 0;top: 0;bottom: 0;width: 0;border-radius: 0 4px 4px 0;transition: width .9s var(--ag-ease)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-bar-m{background: var(--ag-m)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-bar-f{background: var(--ag-f)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-bar-guess{background: repeating-linear-gradient(135deg,color-mix(in srgb,var(--ag-f) 55%,transparent) 0 2px,transparent 2px 7px);box-shadow: inset 0 0 0 1.5px var(--ag-f);transition: none}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-stage{margin-top: 12px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-prog{display: flex;align-items: center;gap: 6px;margin-bottom: 8px;font-size: 12px;color: var(--ag-ink-3);font-weight: 600}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-prog span{margin-left: 6px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ink-m{color: var(--ag-m-ink)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ink-f{color: var(--ag-f-ink)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-chart{margin-top: 10px;display: grid;gap: 8px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-row{display: grid;grid-template-columns: 1fr;gap: 5px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-row-hd{display: flex;justify-content: space-between;align-items: baseline;gap: 10px;font-size: 13px;color: var(--ag-ink-2)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-row-hd b{font-weight: 650;color: var(--ag-ink);font-size: 15px;font-variant-numeric: tabular-nums}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-lab{display: inline-flex;align-items: center;gap: 6px;font-weight: 600}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-guess-tick{position: absolute;top: -5px;bottom: -5px;width: 2px;margin-left: -1px;background: var(--ag-ink);opacity: 0;transition: opacity .3s .6s}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-guess-tick.is-on{opacity: 1}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-guess-lab{position: absolute;top: 100%;margin-top: 7px;transform: translateX(-50%);white-space: nowrap;font-size: 12px;font-weight: 600;color: var(--ag-ink-2);opacity: 0;transition: opacity .3s .7s}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-guess-lab.is-on{opacity: 1}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-guess-lab.is-end{transform: translateX(-100%)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-guess-lab.is-start{transform: none}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-range{display: block;width: 100%;height: 40px;margin-top: 2px;background: transparent;-webkit-appearance: none;appearance: none;cursor: grab;touch-action: pan-y}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-range:active{cursor: grabbing}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-range::-webkit-slider-runnable-track{height: 4px;border-radius: 2px;background: var(--ag-grid)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-range::-moz-range-track{height: 4px;border-radius: 2px;background: var(--ag-grid)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-range::-webkit-slider-thumb{-webkit-appearance: none;width: 28px;height: 28px;margin-top: -12px;border-radius: 50%;background: var(--ag-knock);border: 2px solid var(--ag-f);box-shadow: 0 1px 4px rgba(0,0,0,.18)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-range::-moz-range-thumb{width: 24px;height: 24px;border-radius: 50%;background: var(--ag-knock);border: 2px solid var(--ag-f);box-shadow: 0 1px 4px rgba(0,0,0,.18)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-range:focus-visible{outline: none}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-range:focus-visible::-webkit-slider-thumb{outline: 2px solid var(--ag-focus);outline-offset: 2px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-hint{font-size: 12px;color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-fade-in{animation: ag-in .5s var(--ag-ease) both}@keyframes ag-in{from{opacity: 0;transform: translateY(8px)}to{opacity: 1;transform: none}}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-end{text-align: left}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-recap{margin: 12px 0 4px;display: grid;gap: 6px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-recap-row{display: grid;grid-template-columns: minmax(0,1fr) auto;gap: 2px 12px;font-size: 13px;color: var(--ag-ink-2);align-items: center}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-recap-row .ag-num{color: var(--ag-ink);font-weight: 600}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-mini{grid-column: 1 / -1;position: relative;height: 8px;border-radius: 4px;background: var(--ag-track)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-mini i{position: absolute;top: -2px;width: 12px;height: 12px;margin-left: -6px;border-radius: 50%;border: 2px solid var(--ag-knock)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-mini i.ag-g{background: var(--ag-knock);border: 2px solid var(--ag-ink-2);width: 12px;height: 12px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-cta{display: flex;flex-wrap: wrap;gap: 10px;margin-top: 12px}.ag-root.ag-root a.ag-btn{text-decoration: none;color: var(--ag-knock)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-svgwrap{position: relative;margin-top: 8px;touch-action: manipulation}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-svgwrap svg:focus-visible{outline: 2px solid var(--ag-focus);outline-offset: 4px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-dot{transition: transform .9s var(--ag-ease),opacity .5s,r .15s;cursor: pointer}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-dot.is-m{fill: var(--ag-m)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-dot.is-f{fill: var(--ag-f)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-dot{stroke: var(--ag-knock);stroke-width: 2px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-dot.is-on{stroke: var(--ag-ink);stroke-width: 2.5px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-dim .ag-pt-dot:not(.is-on):not(.is-hit){opacity: .45}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-grid{stroke: var(--ag-grid);stroke-width: 1px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-zero{stroke: var(--ag-ink);stroke-width: 1.5px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-tick{fill: var(--ag-ink-3);font-size: 11px;font-family: var(--ag-ui);font-variant-numeric: tabular-nums}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-card{margin-top: 14px;min-height: 88px;padding-top: 14px;border-top: 1px solid var(--ag-grid);display: grid;gap: 8px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-empty{font-size: 14px;color: var(--ag-ink-3);align-self: center;justify-self: center;text-align: center}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-ctl{display: grid;gap: 10px;margin-top: 16px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-head{display: grid;grid-template-columns: minmax(0,40%) minmax(0,1fr) 66px;gap: 14px;align-items: end;margin-top: 18px;padding-bottom: 6px;border-bottom: 1px solid var(--ag-grid)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-legend{display: flex;flex-wrap: wrap;gap: 4px 12px;font-size: 12px;color: var(--ag-ink-2)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-legend span{display: inline-flex;align-items: center;gap: 5px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-axis{position: relative;height: 16px;font-size: 11px;color: var(--ag-ink-3);font-variant-numeric: tabular-nums}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-axis span{position: absolute;bottom: 0;transform: translateX(-50%);white-space: nowrap}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-axis span:first-child{transform: none}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-axis span:last-child{transform: translateX(-100%)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-pcth{font-size: 11px;color: var(--ag-ink-3);text-align: right;line-height: 1.2}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-list{list-style: none}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-row{border-bottom: 1px solid var(--ag-grid)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-btn{display: grid;grid-template-columns: minmax(0,40%) minmax(0,1fr) 66px;gap: 14px;align-items: center;width: 100%;padding: 7px 0;text-align: left;transition: background .15s}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-btn:hover{background: color-mix(in srgb,var(--ag-card) 70%,transparent)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-names{display: grid;gap: 1px;font-size: 13px;line-height: 1.3;min-width: 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-names span{display: flex;gap: 6px;align-items: baseline;min-width: 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-names span>i{overflow: hidden;text-overflow: ellipsis;white-space: nowrap;font-style: normal}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-names .ag-sw{width: 8px;height: 8px;transform: translateY(-1px)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-names .is-f{color: var(--ag-ink-2)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-track{position: relative;height: 22px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-track::before{content: "";position: absolute;left: 0;right: 0;top: 50%;height: 1px;background: var(--ag-track)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-gl{position: absolute;top: 0;bottom: 0;width: 1px;background: var(--ag-track)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-bar{position: absolute;top: 50%;height: 3px;margin-top: -1.5px;border-radius: 2px;opacity: .45;transition: left .7s var(--ag-ease),width .7s var(--ag-ease)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-bar.is-m{background: var(--ag-m)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-bar.is-f{background: var(--ag-f)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-dot{position: absolute;top: 50%;width: 13px;height: 13px;margin: -6.5px 0 0 -6.5px;border-radius: 50%;box-shadow: 0 0 0 2px var(--ag-knock);transition: left .7s var(--ag-ease)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-dot.is-m{background: var(--ag-m)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-dot.is-f{background: var(--ag-f)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-pct{text-align: right;font-size: 14px;font-weight: 650;font-variant-numeric: tabular-nums;display: flex;justify-content: flex-end;align-items: center;gap: 5px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-pct .ag-sw{width: 7px;height: 7px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-detail{padding: 4px 0 14px;display: grid;gap: 8px;animation: ag-in .35s var(--ag-ease) both}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-cpt{color: var(--ag-ink-3);font-size: 12px;font-weight: 400;margin-left: 6px;white-space: nowrap;font-variant-numeric: tabular-nums}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-flag{font-size: 12px;color: var(--ag-ink-2);border-left: 2px solid var(--ag-grid);padding: 2px 0 2px 10px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-none{padding: 24px 0;text-align: center;color: var(--ag-ink-3);font-size: 14px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-row.is-enter{animation: ag-in .45s var(--ag-ease) both}@container ag (max-width: 540px){.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-head{grid-template-columns: minmax(0,1fr) 60px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-head .ag-ex-legend{grid-column: 1 / -1}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-btn{grid-template-columns: minmax(0,1fr) 60px;gap: 4px 12px;padding: 10px 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-names{grid-column: 1 / -1}}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-cpt{color: var(--ag-ink-3);font-size: 12px;font-weight: 400;font-style: normal;margin-left: 6px;white-space: nowrap;font-variant-numeric: tabular-nums;letter-spacing: 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-cpt-wrap{position: relative;display: inline-block}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-cpt-btn{padding: 2px 0;margin-left: 6px;line-height: 1.2;cursor: help;text-decoration: underline dotted;text-decoration-color: var(--ag-ink-3);text-underline-offset: 3px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-cpt-btn:hover,.ag-root.ag-root .ag-cpt-wrap.is-open .ag-cpt-btn{color: var(--ag-ink);text-decoration-color: currentColor}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-tip{position: absolute;left: 0;bottom: calc(100% + 6px);z-index: 5;width: max-content;max-width: min(260px,72vw);padding: 8px 10px;border-radius: 6px;background: var(--ag-ink);color: var(--ag-knock);font-size: 13px;font-weight: 500;line-height: 1.35;white-space: normal;text-align: left;box-shadow: 0 4px 14px color-mix(in srgb,var(--ag-ink) 18%,transparent);display: none;pointer-events: none}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-cpt-wrap.is-open .ag-tip{display: block;animation: ag-fade .15s linear both}@keyframes ag-fade{from{opacity: 0}to{opacity: 1}}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-tip-k{display: block;margin-bottom: 2px;font-size: 11px;font-weight: 500;opacity: .7}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pair{display: grid;gap: 4px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pair-row{display: flex;justify-content: space-between;align-items: baseline;gap: 12px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pair-name{font-size: 15px;font-weight: 500;line-height: 1.3;min-width: 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pair-val{font-size: 15px;font-weight: 600;white-space: nowrap}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-find{position: relative}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-find svg{position: absolute;left: 0;top: 50%;width: 15px;height: 15px;margin-top: -7.5px;color: var(--ag-ink-3);pointer-events: none}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-find input{display: block;width: 100%;min-height: 40px;padding: 8px 0 8px 24px;border-radius: 0;background: transparent;border-bottom: 1px solid var(--ag-grid);font-size: 16px;color: var(--ag-ink);-webkit-appearance: none;appearance: none;transition: border-color .2s}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-find input:hover{border-bottom-color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-find input:focus-visible{outline: none;border-bottom-color: var(--ag-ink)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-find input::placeholder{color: var(--ag-ink-3);opacity: 1}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-find input::-webkit-search-cancel-button{-webkit-appearance: none}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-btn{min-height: 42px;padding: 10px 20px;border-radius: var(--ag-r);background: transparent;color: var(--ag-ink);box-shadow: inset 0 0 0 1px var(--ag-ink);font-size: 15px;font-weight: 500;transition: background-color .2s,color .2s,transform .15s}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-btn:hover{background: var(--ag-ink);color: var(--ag-knock)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-find{margin-top: 10px;max-width: 340px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-hits{list-style: none;margin-top: 6px;display: grid;gap: 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-hits:empty{display: none}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-hit{display: block;width: 100%;padding: 6px 0;text-align: left;font-size: 14px;font-weight: 500;line-height: 1.3}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-hit:hover{text-decoration: underline;text-underline-offset: 3px;text-decoration-color: var(--ag-grid)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-none{padding: 6px 0;font-size: 13px;color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-finding .ag-pt-dot:not(.is-hit):not(.is-on){opacity: .15}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-dot.is-hit{stroke: var(--ag-ink);stroke-width: 2px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-cap{margin-top: 6px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-cap>span{display: inline-flex;align-items: baseline;gap: 5px;font-weight: 500;white-space: nowrap}@container ag (max-width: 340px){.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-cap{font-size: 11px;gap: 6px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-cap>span{gap: 3px}}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-arrow{font-weight: 400;color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-card{margin-top: 12px;min-height: 0;padding-top: 12px;border-top: 1px solid var(--ag-grid);display: grid;gap: 8px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pt-empty{font-size: 14px;color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-ctl{display: flex;flex-wrap: wrap;gap: 12px 32px;align-items: end;margin-top: 16px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-ctl .ag-find{flex: 1 1 220px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-sels{display: flex;gap: 20px;flex-wrap: wrap}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mini{display: grid;gap: 2px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mini-k{font-size: 12px;color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mini-v{position: relative;display: block}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mini-v::after{content: "";position: absolute;right: 2px;top: 50%;width: 6px;height: 6px;margin-top: -5px;border-right: 1.5px solid var(--ag-ink-2);border-bottom: 1.5px solid var(--ag-ink-2);transform: rotate(45deg);pointer-events: none}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mini-sel{display: block;min-height: 40px;padding: 8px 20px 8px 0;background: transparent;border-bottom: 1px solid var(--ag-grid);font-size: 15px;font-weight: 500;color: var(--ag-ink);-webkit-appearance: none;appearance: none;cursor: pointer;border-radius: 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mini-sel:hover{border-bottom-color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mini-sel:focus-visible{outline: none;border-bottom-color: var(--ag-ink)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-head{margin-top: 24px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-names .ag-ex-n{overflow: hidden;text-overflow: ellipsis;white-space: nowrap;font-style: normal;min-width: 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-names .ag-cpt{margin-left: 0;flex: none;font-size: 11px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-names .is-f{color: inherit}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-pct{font-weight: 600}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-detail{padding: 4px 0 12px;gap: 8px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-detail .ag-pair-name,.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-detail .ag-pair-val{font-size: 15px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-pager{display: flex;justify-content: space-between;align-items: center;gap: 12px;margin-top: 8px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-count{font-size: 13px;color: var(--ag-ink-3);font-variant-numeric: tabular-nums}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-pbtns{display: flex;gap: 8px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-icon-btn[disabled]{opacity: .3;cursor: default}@container ag (max-width: 480px){.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-sels{width: 100%}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-sels .ag-mini{flex: 1 1 0;min-width: 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mini-sel{width: 100%}}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-stat{display: block;text-wrap: pretty}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-stat-num{font-family: var(--ag-head);font-weight: 600;font-size: 30px;line-height: 1.05;letter-spacing: -0.025em;font-variant-numeric: tabular-nums;color: var(--ag-ink);margin-right: 8px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-stat-cap{font-size: 15px;font-weight: 500;line-height: 1.35;color: var(--ag-ink-2)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-stat-cap span{white-space: nowrap}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-stat-num.ag-ink-m{color: var(--ag-m-ink)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-stat-num.ag-ink-f{color: var(--ag-f-ink)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-stat.is-small .ag-stat-num{font-size: 24px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-stat.is-small .ag-stat-cap{font-size: 14px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-ctl{display: flex;gap: 6px;align-items: stretch;margin-top: 14px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-select-wrap{position: relative;flex: 1 1 auto;min-width: 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-select{display: block;-webkit-appearance: none;appearance: none;cursor: pointer;font-size: 16px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-select-wrap .ag-select{position: absolute;inset: 0;width: 100%;height: 100%;opacity: 0;min-height: 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-select-face{display: flex;align-items: center;min-height: 40px;height: 100%;padding: 6px 34px 6px 12px;border-radius: var(--ag-r);background: transparent;box-shadow: inset 0 0 0 1px var(--ag-grid);transition: box-shadow .2s;font-size: 15px;font-weight: 500;line-height: 1.3}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-select-wrap:hover .ag-select-face{box-shadow: inset 0 0 0 1px var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-select-wrap:has(.ag-select:focus-visible) .ag-select-face{outline: 2px solid var(--ag-focus);outline-offset: 2px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-select-wrap::after{content: "";position: absolute;right: 14px;top: 50%;width: 6px;height: 6px;margin-top: -5px;border-right: 1.5px solid var(--ag-ink-2);border-bottom: 1.5px solid var(--ag-ink-2);transform: rotate(45deg);pointer-events: none}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-ctl .ag-icon-btn{width: 40px;height: auto;min-height: 40px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-ctl .ag-icon-btn svg{width: 14px;height: 14px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-sum{margin-top: 14px}@container ag (max-width: 480px){.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-ctl{gap: 4px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-ctl .ag-icon-btn{width: 32px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-select-face{font-size: 14px;padding-left: 10px;padding-right: 28px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-select-wrap::after{right: 11px}}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-strip-wrap{margin-top: 12px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-strip-lab{font-size: 13px;color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-strip{position: relative;height: 48px;margin-top: 2px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-strip::before{content: "";position: absolute;left: 0;right: 0;top: 31px;height: 1px;background: var(--ag-grid)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-zero{position: absolute;top: 15px;bottom: 0;width: 0;border-left: 1.5px dashed var(--ag-ink-2);margin-left: -0.75px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-zero-lab{position: absolute;top: 0;transform: translateX(-50%);font-size: 11px;font-weight: 500;line-height: 1;color: var(--ag-ink-2);white-space: nowrap}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-tick{position: absolute;top: 23px;width: 2px;height: 16px;margin-left: -1px;padding: 0;border-radius: 1px;opacity: .45;transition: height .25s var(--ag-ease),top .25s var(--ag-ease),width .25s var(--ag-ease),opacity .2s}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-tick.is-m{background: var(--ag-m)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-tick.is-f{background: var(--ag-f)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-tick::after{content: "";position: absolute;inset: -8px -3px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-tick:hover{opacity: .9}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-tick.is-on{opacity: 1;top: 16px;height: 30px;width: 4px;margin-left: -2px;box-shadow: 0 0 0 2px var(--ag-knock);z-index: 2}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-pair{margin-top: 14px;padding-top: 12px;border-top: 1px solid var(--ag-grid);display: grid;gap: 10px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-side{display: grid;gap: 4px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-line{display: flex;justify-content: space-between;align-items: baseline;gap: 12px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-name{font-size: 15px;font-weight: 500;line-height: 1.3;min-width: 0}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-val{font-size: 15px;font-weight: 600;white-space: nowrap}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-pair .ag-bar-track{height: 12px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-prog{display: block;margin: 0 0 8px;font-size: 12px;font-weight: 500;color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-lab{display: inline-flex;align-items: baseline;flex-wrap: wrap;font-size: 15px;font-weight: 500;line-height: 1.3}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-row-hd b{font-weight: 600}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-foot{display: flex;flex-wrap: wrap;align-items: center;justify-content: space-between;gap: 10px 16px;margin-top: 6px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-foot.is-result{margin-top: 26px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-endline{font-size: 17px;font-weight: 500;line-height: 1.35;color: var(--ag-ink);text-wrap: pretty}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-endnum{font-family: var(--ag-head);font-weight: 600;font-size: 30px;letter-spacing: -0.025em}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-hint{display: flex;flex-wrap: wrap;align-items: center;gap: 4px;font-size: 12px;color: var(--ag-ink-3)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-ring{display: inline-block;width: 10px;height: 10px;border-radius: 50%;box-shadow: inset 0 0 0 2px var(--ag-ink-2)}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-cta{display: flex;flex-wrap: wrap;align-items: center;gap: 10px 18px;margin-top: 12px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-link{font-size: 15px;font-weight: 500;color: var(--ag-ink);text-decoration: underline;text-decoration-color: var(--ag-grid);text-underline-offset: 4px}.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-link:hover{text-decoration-color: currentColor}.ag-root.ag-root{--ag-ui: "Geist","Helvetica Neue",Arial,sans-serif;--ag-head-weight: 600;--ag-head-track: -0.02em;--ag-r: 8px}.ag-root.ag-root[data-ag-mode="light"]{--ag-card: #f3f3f6;--ag-grid: #e2e2e8;--ag-track: #ececf1}@media (prefers-color-scheme: light){.ag-root.ag-root[data-ag-mode="auto"]{--ag-card: #f3f3f6;--ag-grid: #e2e2e8;--ag-track: #ececf1}}.ag-root.ag-root[data-ag-style="editorial"]{--ag-head-weight: 700}.ag-root.ag-root[data-ag-style="feature"]{--ag-head-weight: 700}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root{font-family: var(--ag-ui)}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-hed{letter-spacing: var(--ag-head-track)}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-name{font-weight: 500}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-row-hd b,.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-mu-val,.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-pair-val,.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-ex-pct{font-weight: 600}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-dek{text-wrap: pretty}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn,.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-icon-btn,.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-select-face{border-radius: var(--ag-r)}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-bar{border-radius: 0 2px 2px 0}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn{font-weight: 600}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn{transition: transform .15s var(--ag-ease),background-color .2s}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn:hover{opacity: 1;background: color-mix(in srgb,var(--ag-ink) 82%,var(--ag-knock))}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn:active,.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-icon-btn:active{transform: translateY(1px)}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-icon-btn{transition: box-shadow .2s,background-color .2s,transform .15s}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-icon-btn:hover{background: var(--ag-card)}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn-ghost{background: none;box-shadow: none;padding-left: 4px;padding-right: 4px;font-weight: 500;text-decoration: underline;text-decoration-color: var(--ag-grid);text-underline-offset: 4px}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-btn-ghost:hover{background: none;text-decoration-color: currentColor}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-prog span{margin-left: 0;font-weight: 500}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-mini{background: none;height: 12px}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-mini::before{content: "";position: absolute;left: 0;right: 0;top: 50%;height: 1px;background: var(--ag-grid)}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-q-mini i{top: 0}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-range::-webkit-slider-thumb{box-shadow: 0 1px 3px color-mix(in srgb,var(--ag-ink) 22%,transparent)}.ag-root.ag-root.ag-root .ag-range::-moz-range-thumb{box-shadow: 0 1px 3px color-mix(in srgb,var(--ag-ink) 22%,transparent)}@media (prefers-reduced-motion: reduce){.ag-root.ag-root *,.ag-root.ag-root *::before,.ag-root.ag-root *::after{transition: none !important;animation: none !important}}
(window.AG = window.AG || {}).data = [{"id":1,"cat":"Biopsies & lesions","mName":"Biopsy penis","mCpt":"54100","m":121.32,"fName":"Biopsy vagina","fCpt":"57100","f":65.74,"pct":59.42},{"id":2,"cat":"Biopsies & lesions","mName":"Remove penis lesion","mCpt":"54110","m":624.88,"fName":"Remove vaginal lesion","fCpt":"57135","f":191.8,"pct":106.06},{"id":3,"cat":"Biopsies & lesions","mName":"Biopsy scrotum","mCpt":"55120","m":356.83,"fName":"Biopsy vulva","fCpt":"56605","f":59.98,"pct":142.44},{"id":4,"cat":"Biopsies & lesions","mName":"Biopsy prostate","mCpt":"55705","m":265.34,"fName":"Biopsy endometrium","fCpt":"58110","f":40.33,"pct":147.22},{"id":5,"cat":"Biopsies & lesions","mName":"Removal of scrotal lesion","mCpt":"55120","m":356.83,"fName":"Removal of vulvar lesion","fCpt":"56440","f":184.01,"pct":63.91},{"id":6,"cat":"Biopsies & lesions","mName":"Excision penile lesion","mCpt":"54115","m":428.0,"fName":"Excision vaginal lesion","fCpt":"57100","f":65.74,"pct":146.74},{"id":7,"cat":"Biopsies & lesions","mName":"Laser penis","mCpt":"54057","m":98.95,"fName":"Laser vulva","fCpt":"56501","f":136.57,"pct":-31.95},{"id":8,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Distal hypospadias repair","mCpt":"54328","m":934.61,"fName":"Revision of cervix","fCpt":"57700","f":365.3,"pct":87.59},{"id":9,"cat":"Biopsies & lesions","mName":"Destruction penile lesions simple","mCpt":"54050","m":108.1,"fName":"Destruction vulvar lesions simple","fCpt":"56501","f":136.57,"pct":-23.27},{"id":10,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Resection of scrotum","mCpt":"55150","m":496.11,"fName":"Simple complete vulvectomy","fCpt":"56620","f":598.11,"pct":-18.64},{"id":11,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Revision of scrotum","mCpt":"55180","m":690.96,"fName":"Extensive vulva surgery (partial radical)","fCpt":"56630","f":976.63,"pct":-34.26},{"id":12,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Drain prostate abscess","mCpt":"52700","m":443.92,"fName":"Drain ovarian abscess open","fCpt":"58820","f":347.01,"pct":24.51},{"id":13,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Excision hydrocele","mCpt":"55040","m":339.89,"fName":"Excision Bartholins gland","fCpt":"56740","f":321.25,"pct":5.64},{"id":14,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Penis/scrotoplasty","mCpt":"54360","m":721.8,"fName":"Perineoplasty","fCpt":"56810","f":276.86,"pct":89.11},{"id":15,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Excision of sperm cord lesion","mCpt":"55520","m":465.95,"fName":"Excision of Bartholins","fCpt":"56740","f":321.25,"pct":36.76},{"id":16,"cat":"Prostate & uterus","mName":"Interstitial prostate","mCpt":"55875","m":780.08,"fName":"Interstitial cervix","fCpt":"55920","f":463.24,"pct":50.97},{"id":17,"cat":"Urinary tract","mName":"Insert tandem male","mCpt":"53444","m":792.62,"fName":"Insert tandem female","fCpt":"57155","f":286.01,"pct":93.94},{"id":18,"cat":"Urinary tract","mName":"Reconstruction of male urethra","mCpt":"54352","m":1408.35,"fName":"Reconstruction of female urethra","fCpt":"53430","f":975.27,"pct":36.34},{"id":19,"cat":"Urinary tract","mName":"Revise remove sling male","mCpt":"53448","m":1271.79,"fName":"Revise remove sling female","fCpt":"57287","f":754.33,"pct":51.08},{"id":20,"cat":"Urinary tract","mName":"Male sling insert uro/neck sph","mCpt":"53445","m":757.72,"fName":"Female insert mesh pelvic floor add on","fCpt":"57267","f":252.12,"pct":100.13},{"id":21,"cat":"Urinary tract","mName":"Reconstruct urethra male","mCpt":"53415","m":1126.07,"fName":"Revise urethra female","fCpt":"57220","f":353.11,"pct":104.51},{"id":22,"cat":"Urinary tract","mName":"Total urethrectomy male","mCpt":"53215","m":926.14,"fName":"Total urethrectomy female","fCpt":"53210","f":776.7,"pct":17.55},{"id":23,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Partial removal of penis","mCpt":"54120","m":633.01,"fName":"Partial vaginectomy","fCpt":"57106","f":546.94,"pct":14.59},{"id":24,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Removal of penis","mCpt":"54125","m":825.49,"fName":"Complete vaginectomy","fCpt":"57110","f":919.02,"pct":-10.72},{"id":25,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Exploratory laparotomy male","mCpt":"49000","m":778.05,"fName":"Exploratory laparotomy female","fCpt":"58960","f":1009.84,"pct":-25.93},{"id":26,"cat":"Testes & ovaries","mName":"Excise lesion testis","mCpt":"54512","m":538.47,"fName":"Ovarian cystectomy","fCpt":"58925","f":781.44,"pct":-36.82},{"id":27,"cat":"Testes & ovaries","mName":"Removal of testis","mCpt":"54530","m":511.02,"fName":"Oophorectomy","fCpt":"58940","f":567.27,"pct":-10.43},{"id":28,"cat":"Testes & ovaries","mName":"Suspension/relocation of testes","mCpt":"54680","m":787.54,"fName":"Ovarian transposition","fCpt":"58825","f":722.81,"pct":8.57},{"id":29,"cat":"Testes & ovaries","mName":"Laparoscopic orchiectomy","mCpt":"54690","m":655.38,"fName":"Laparoscopic BSO","fCpt":"58661","f":662.83,"pct":-1.13},{"id":30,"cat":"Testes & ovaries","mName":"Laparoscopic orchiopexy","mCpt":"54692","m":755.01,"fName":"Laparoscopic ovarian transposition","fCpt":"58825","f":722.81,"pct":4.36},{"id":31,"cat":"Testes & ovaries","mName":"Removal of epididymis","mCpt":"54861","m":569.64,"fName":"Removal of fallopian tubes","fCpt":"58700","f":814.31,"pct":-35.36},{"id":32,"cat":"Testes & ovaries","mName":"Vas deferens vasectomy","mCpt":"55250","m":230.43,"fName":"Essure hysteroscopy","fCpt":"58565","f":466.97,"pct":-67.83},{"id":33,"cat":"Testes & ovaries","mName":"Orchiectomy with staging","mCpt":"54530 + 38770","m":1320.25,"fName":"Oophorectomy with staging","fCpt":"58950","f":1169.79,"pct":12.08},{"id":34,"cat":"Testes & ovaries","mName":"Extensive testis surgery","mCpt":"54535","m":744.5,"fName":"Removal of ovaries extensive","fCpt":"58943","f":1188.42,"pct":-45.93},{"id":35,"cat":"Testes & ovaries","mName":"Reduce testis torsion","mCpt":"54600","m":454.43,"fName":"Reduce ovarian torsion","fCpt":"58920","f":728.24,"pct":-46.3},{"id":36,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Remove penis and LN","mCpt":"54135","m":1503.24,"fName":"Vaginectomy and LN","fCpt":"57109","f":1751.97,"pct":-15.28},{"id":37,"cat":"Testes & ovaries","mName":"Revise vas deferens/spermatic ducts","mCpt":"54901","m":1056.94,"fName":"Revise fallopian tubes","fCpt":"58740","f":917.67,"pct":14.11},{"id":38,"cat":"Prostate & uterus","mName":"TURP","mCpt":"52601","m":727.22,"fName":"Hysteroscopic myomectomy","fCpt":"58561","f":360.9,"pct":67.33},{"id":39,"cat":"Prostate & uterus","mName":"Remove prostate","mCpt":"55801","m":1093.2,"fName":"Hysterectomy","fCpt":"58150","f":1028.82,"pct":6.07},{"id":40,"cat":"Prostate & uterus","mName":"Extensive prostate surgery","mCpt":"55845","m":1355.49,"fName":"Extensive TAH","fCpt":"58285","f":1440.21,"pct":-6.06},{"id":41,"cat":"Prostate & uterus","mName":"Subtotal prostatectomy","mCpt":"55821","m":837.69,"fName":"Abdominal trachelectomy","fCpt":"57530","f":381.57,"pct":74.82},{"id":42,"cat":"Prostate & uterus","mName":"Prostatectomy","mCpt":"55840","m":1165.38,"fName":"TAH","fCpt":"58150","f":1028.82,"pct":12.45},{"id":43,"cat":"Prostate & uterus","mName":"Prostatectomy LND","mCpt":"55845","m":1355.49,"fName":"TAH BSO LND","fCpt":"58200","f":1362.6,"pct":-0.52},{"id":44,"cat":"Prostate & uterus","mName":"Perineal approach prostatectomy","mCpt":"55815","m":1751.97,"fName":"Radical vaginal hysterectomy","fCpt":"58285","f":1440.21,"pct":19.53},{"id":45,"cat":"Prostate & uterus","mName":"Radical prostatectomy perineal approach","mCpt":"55810","m":1301.27,"fName":"Radical vaginal hysterectomy","fCpt":"58285","f":1440.21,"pct":-10.14},{"id":46,"cat":"Urinary tract","mName":"Removal of bladder and LN","mCpt":"51575","m":1809.92,"fName":"Anterior exenteration (no code for anterior only)","fCpt":"58240","f":2967.84,"pct":-48.47},{"id":47,"cat":"Urinary tract","mName":"Cystectomy complete with conduit","mCpt":"51596","m":2344.32,"fName":"Pelvic exenteration","fCpt":"58240","f":2967.84,"pct":-23.48},{"id":48,"cat":"Biopsies & lesions","mName":"Biopsy penis","mCpt":"54100","m":121.32,"fName":"Biopsy vulva","fCpt":"56605","f":59.98,"pct":67.67},{"id":49,"cat":"Biopsies & lesions","mName":"Biopsy prostate","mCpt":"55700","m":129.11,"fName":"Biopsy endometrium","fCpt":"58100","f":63.71,"pct":67.84},{"id":50,"cat":"Biopsies & lesions","mName":"Destruction penile lesions extensive","mCpt":"54065","m":172.83,"fName":"Destruction vulvar lesions extensive","fCpt":"56515","f":216.88,"pct":-22.61},{"id":51,"cat":"Prostate & uterus","mName":"TURP","mCpt":"52601","m":727.22,"fName":"Hysteroscopy","fCpt":"58558","f":233.48,"pct":102.79},{"id":52,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Drain prostate abscess","mCpt":"55720","m":453.07,"fName":"Drain ovarian abscess","fCpt":"58820","f":347.01,"pct":26.51},{"id":53,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Excision varicocele","mCpt":"55530","m":354.12,"fName":"Excision Bartholins","fCpt":"56740","f":321.25,"pct":9.73},{"id":54,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Excision hydrocele","mCpt":"55500","m":395.8,"fName":"Excision Bartholins","fCpt":"56740","f":321.25,"pct":20.79},{"id":55,"cat":"Genitals & other","mName":"Scrotoplasty","mCpt":"55175","m":367.68,"fName":"Perineoplasty","fCpt":"56810","f":276.86,"pct":28.18}];
window.AG.copy = {"shared":{"method":"Percent difference is the gap between the two payments divided by their average. Because neither the male nor female procedure serves as the baseline to compare against, the average is used, yielding a single figure for each pair. Negative values mean the procedure on women pays more.","source":"Source: Penn et al., Journal of Women\u2019s Health (2025), Table 3.","credit":"Graphic: Anusha Subramanian/Vox","logoLabel":"Vox","aboutButton":"About the data","about1":"Amounts are Medicare\u2019s 2023 national reimbursement rates when the procedure is done in a hospital or surgical center.","about2":"Researchers matched each procedure on male anatomy with a comparable one on female anatomy. Some procedures appear in more than one pair. CPT codes are the billing codes listed in the study. Look any code up in Medicare\u2019s Physician Fee Schedule tool.","difference":"pay difference","srHigherMale":"higher for the male procedure","srHigherFemale":"higher for the female procedure","paysMoreFemale":"Pays more for female","paysMoreMale":"Pays more for male","noMatches":"No matching procedures","cptPrefix":"CPT"},"pattern":{"hed":"Medicare often reimburses more for procedures on men","dek":"Percent difference in 2023 Medicare reimbursement rates among pairs of comparable male and female procedures. Each dot is one pair.","findPlaceholder":"Find a procedure or code","emptyCard":"Tap or hover over a dot to see the pair","moreHits":"and {n} more, highlighted on the chart"},"quiz":{"hed":"Can you guess what Medicare pays?","dek":"Drag the slider to estimate what Medicare pays for the second procedure.","round":"Round {i} of {n}","submit":"Submit","next":"Next pair","seeResult":"See the result","yourGuess":"Your guess {amount}","endLede":"{n} of {total}","endText":"matched pairs pay the surgeon more for the procedure on male anatomy.","legendMale":"Male","legendFemale":"Female","legendGuess":"Your guess","playAgain":"Play again with new pairs","seeAll":"See all 55 pairs"},"matchup":{"hed":"Similar procedures, different pay","dek":"What Medicare paid a surgeon for matched procedures in 2023","stripLabel":"Where this pair falls among all 55","noDifference":"No difference"},"explorer":{"hed":"Every matched pair, side by side","dek":"What Medicare paid a surgeon for each procedure in 2023","searchPlaceholder":"Search a procedure or code","legendMale":"Male procedure","legendFemale":"Female procedure","pctHeader":"% diff.","count":"{from}\u2013{to} of {n} pairs","countFiltered":"{from}\u2013{to} of {n} matching pairs","sortGap":"Sorted by largest difference","sortStudy":"Sorted in the study\u2019s order","sortPay":"Sorted by highest payment","essureFlag":"Essure was taken off the U.S. market in 2018."}};
(function () {
var AG = (window.AG = window.AG || {});
AG.components = AG.components || {};
if (AG.__core) return;
AG.__core = true;
AG.CATEGORIES = ["Biopsies & lesions", "Testes & ovaries", "Prostate & uterus", "Urinary tract", "Genitals & other"];
var P = function (d) { return ''; };
AG.icons = {
prev: P("M168.49,199.51a12,12,0,0,1-17,17l-80-80a12,12,0,0,1,0-17l80-80a12,12,0,0,1,17,17L97,128Z"),
next: P("M184.49,136.49l-80,80a12,12,0,0,1-17-17L159,128,87.51,56.49a12,12,0,1,1,17-17l80,80A12,12,0,0,1,184.49,136.49Z"),
shuffle: P("M240.49,175.51a12,12,0,0,1,0,17l-24,24a12,12,0,0,1-17-17L203,196h-2.09a76.17,76.17,0,0,1-61.85-31.83L97.38,105.78A52.1,52.1,0,0,0,55.06,84H32a12,12,0,0,1,0-24H55.06a76.17,76.17,0,0,1,61.85,31.83l41.71,58.39A52.1,52.1,0,0,0,200.94,172H203l-3.52-3.51a12,12,0,0,1,17-17Zm-95.62-72.62a12,12,0,0,0,16.93-1.13A52,52,0,0,1,200.94,84H203l-3.52,3.51a12,12,0,0,0,17,17l24-24a12,12,0,0,0,0-17l-24-24a12,12,0,0,0-17,17L203,60h-2.09a76,76,0,0,0-57.2,26A12,12,0,0,0,144.87,102.89Zm-33.74,50.22a12,12,0,0,0-16.93,1.13A52,52,0,0,1,55.06,172H32a12,12,0,0,0,0,24H55.06a76,76,0,0,0,57.2-26A12,12,0,0,0,111.13,153.11Z"),
search: P("M232.49,215.51,185,168a92.12,92.12,0,1,0-17,17l47.53,47.54a12,12,0,0,0,17-17ZM44,112a68,68,0,1,1,68,68A68.07,68.07,0,0,1,44,112Z")
};
AG.pairSep = " vs. ";
AG.reduced = function () {
return !!(window.matchMedia && window.matchMedia("(prefers-reduced-motion: reduce)").matches);
};
AG.h = function (tag, attrs, kids) {
var svg = /^(svg|g|circle|line|text|path|rect|tspan)$/.test(tag);
var el = svg ? document.createElementNS("http://www.w3.org/2000/svg", tag) : document.createElement(tag);
attrs = attrs || {};
for (var k in attrs) {
var v = attrs[k];
if (v == null || v === false) continue;
if (k === "text") el.textContent = v;
else if (k === "html") el.innerHTML = v;
else if (k.slice(0, 2) === "on") el.addEventListener(k.slice(2), v);
else if (k === "class" && svg) el.setAttribute("class", v);
else if (k === "class") el.className = v;
else el.setAttribute(k, v === true ? "" : v);
}
(kids || []).forEach(function (c) {
if (c == null || c === false) return;
el.appendChild(typeof c === "string" ? document.createTextNode(c) : c);
});
return el;
};
AG.money = function (v, opts) {
var round = opts && opts.round;
return v.toLocaleString("en-US", {
style: "currency", currency: "USD",
minimumFractionDigits: round ? 0 : 2, maximumFractionDigits: round ? 0 : 2
});
};
AG.pct = function (p) {
var a = Math.abs(p);
return (a >= 10 ? a.toFixed(0) : a.toFixed(1)) + "%";
};
AG.pctExact = function (p) { return (p 0 ? "m" : "f"; };
AG.byId = function (id) {
for (var i = 0; i 0 ? "higher for the male procedure" : "higher for the female procedure";
};
AG.t = function (key, vars) {
var parts = key.split("."), v = AG.copy || {};
for (var i = 0; i < parts.length && v != null; i++) v = v[parts[i]];
if (typeof v !== "string") v = key;
return v.replace(/\{(\w+)\}/g, function (m, k) { return vars && k in vars ? vars[k] : m; });
};
AG.tx = function (tag, key, attrs, vars) {
var el = AG.h(tag, attrs || {});
var s = AG.t(key, vars);
if (/ rr.right) dx = rr.right - tr.right;
if (tr.left + dx < rr.left) dx = rr.left - tr.left;
tip.style.transform = "translateX(" + Math.round(dx) + "px)";
}
var openedAt = 0;
function show(on) {
if (on && !wrap.classList.contains("is-open")) openedAt = Date.now();
wrap.classList.toggle("is-open", on);
btn.setAttribute("aria-expanded", String(on));
if (on) place();
}
btn.addEventListener("mouseenter", function () { show(true); });
wrap.addEventListener("mouseleave", function () { show(false); });
btn.addEventListener("focus", function () { show(true); });
btn.addEventListener("blur", function () { show(false); });
btn.addEventListener("click", function (e) {
e.stopPropagation();
var open = wrap.classList.contains("is-open");
show(!open || Date.now() - openedAt < 400);
});
btn.addEventListener("keydown", function (e) { if (e.key === "Escape") show(false); });
return wrap;
};
AG.pairRows = function (d) {
var h = AG.h;
return h("div", { class: "ag-pair" }, [["m", d.mName, d.mCpt, d.m], ["f", d.fName, d.fCpt, d.f]].map(function (x) {
return h("div", { class: "ag-pair-row" }, [
h("p", { class: "ag-pair-name" }, [h("span", { class: "ag-ink-" + x[0], text: x[1] }), AG.cpt(x[2])]),
h("p", { class: "ag-num ag-pair-val", text: AG.money(x[3]) })
]);
}));
};
document.addEventListener("click", function () {
var open = document.querySelectorAll(".ag-cpt-wrap.is-open");
for (var i = 0; i < open.length; i++) { open[i].classList.remove("is-open"); open[i].firstChild.setAttribute("aria-expanded", "false"); }
});
AG.stat = function (d, opts) {
var h = AG.h, s = AG.side(d);
var num = opts && opts.exact ? AG.pctExact(d.pct).replace("\u2212", "") : AG.pct(d.pct);
return h("p", { class: "ag-stat" + (opts && opts.small ? " is-small" : "") }, [
h("span", { class: "ag-stat-num", text: num }),
AG.tx("span", "shared.difference", { class: "ag-stat-cap" }),
h("span", { class: "ag-sr", text: " (" + AG.t(s === "m" ? "shared.srHigherMale" : "shared.srHigherFemale") + ")" })
]);
};
AG.onVisible = function (el, fn) {
if (!("IntersectionObserver" in window)) return fn();
var io = new IntersectionObserver(function (es) {
if (es.some(function (e) { return e.isIntersecting; })) { io.disconnect(); fn(); }
}, { threshold: 0.2 });
io.observe(el);
};
AG.axisEnds = function (extraClass) {
var h = AG.h;
return h("div", { class: "ag-axis-cap " + (extraClass || "") }, [
h("span", { class: "ag-ink-f" }, [h("span", { class: "ag-arrow", "aria-hidden": "true", text: "\u2190" }), AG.tx("span", "shared.paysMoreFemale")]),
h("span", { class: "ag-ink-m" }, [AG.tx("span", "shared.paysMoreMale"), h("span", { class: "ag-arrow", "aria-hidden": "true", text: "\u2192" })])
]);
};
AG.header = function (o) {
return AG.h("div", { class: "ag-hd" }, [
AG.tx("h2", o.hed, { class: "ag-hed" }),
o.dek ? AG.tx("p", o.dek, { class: "ag-dek" }) : null
]);
};
AG.footer = function () {
var h = AG.h;
var about = h("div", { class: "ag-about", hidden: true, id: "ag-about-" + Math.random().toString(36).slice(2, 8) }, [
AG.tx("p", "shared.about1"), AG.tx("p", "shared.about2")
]);
var btn = AG.tx("button", "shared.aboutButton", { class: "ag-about-btn", type: "button", "aria-expanded": "false", "aria-controls": about.id });
btn.addEventListener("click", function () {
var open = about.hidden;
about.hidden = !open;
btn.setAttribute("aria-expanded", String(open));
});
return h("div", { class: "ag-ft" }, [
AG.tx("p", "shared.method", { class: "ag-method" }),
h("div", { class: "ag-ft-row" }, [
AG.tx("p", "shared.source", { class: "ag-source" }),
AG.tx("p", "shared.credit", { class: "ag-credit" }),
h("div", { class: "ag-ft-end" }, [btn, AG.ta(h("span", { class: "ag-logo", role: "img" }), "aria-label", "shared.logoLabel")])
]),
about
]);
};
AG.mount = function (root) {
var name = root.getAttribute("data-ag");
var fn = AG.components[name];
if (!fn || !AG.data) return;
root.setAttribute("data-ag-mounted", "");
if (root.parentElement) root.style.setProperty("--ag-host", getComputedStyle(root.parentElement).fontFamily);
root.innerHTML = "";
fn(root);
if (typeof CustomEvent === "function") root.dispatchEvent(new CustomEvent("ag:mounted", { bubbles: true }));
};
AG.mountAll = function () {
var run = function () {
var roots = document.querySelectorAll(".ag-root[data-ag]:not([data-ag-mounted])");
for (var i = 0; i 0; }).length;
var sorted = AG.data.slice().sort(function (a, b) { return a.pct - b.pct; });
var sel = null, entered = false, landed = false, pos = {};
root.appendChild(AG.header({ hed: "pattern.hed", dek: "pattern.dek" }));
var findIn = AG.ta(h("input", { type: "search", "aria-label": "Find a procedure on the chart", autocomplete: "off" }), "placeholder", "pattern.findPlaceholder");
var hits = h("ul", { class: "ag-pt-hits", "aria-label": "Matching pairs" });
root.appendChild(h("div", { class: "ag-pt-find" }, [h("div", { class: "ag-find", html: AG.icons.search }, [findIn]), hits]));
var wrap = h("div", { class: "ag-pt-svgwrap" });
var svg = h("svg", { role: "img", tabindex: "0", "aria-label": "Beeswarm chart. " + nM + " of 55 pairs pay more for the male procedure. Use arrow keys to step through pairs." });
wrap.appendChild(svg);
root.appendChild(wrap);
root.appendChild(AG.axisEnds("ag-pt-cap"));
var card = h("div", { class: "ag-pt-card", "aria-live": "polite" });
root.appendChild(card);
root.appendChild(h("div", { class: "ag-sr" }, [h("table", {}, [
h("caption", { text: "Table 3, facility payments, 2023" }),
h("tr", {}, ["Male procedure", "Payment", "Female procedure", "Payment", "Percent difference"].map(function (t) { return h("th", { text: t }); }))
].concat(AG.data.map(function (d) {
return h("tr", {}, [d.mName, AG.money(d.m), d.fName, AG.money(d.f), AG.pctExact(d.pct)].map(function (t) { return h("td", { text: t }); }));
})))]));
root.appendChild(AG.footer());
function drawCard() {
card.innerHTML = "";
if (!sel) { card.appendChild(AG.tx("p", "pattern.emptyCard", { class: "ag-pt-empty" })); return; }
var d = sel;
card.appendChild(AG.pairRows(d));
card.appendChild(AG.stat(d, { small: true }));
}
var circles = {};
function layout() {
var W = wrap.clientWidth;
if (!W) return;
var narrow = W < 520;
var r = narrow ? 5.5 : 7, gap = 1.5, D = 2 * r + gap;
var padL = r + 4, padR = r + 4;
var sx = function (p) { return padL + ((p - LO) / (HI - LO)) * (W - padL - padR); };
var placed = [];
AG.data.slice().sort(function (a, b) { return Math.abs(a.pct) - Math.abs(b.pct) || a.id - b.id; }).forEach(function (d) {
var x = sx(d.pct), cands = [0];
placed.forEach(function (p) {
var dx = Math.abs(x - p.x);
if (dx < D) { var dy = Math.sqrt(D * D - dx * dx); cands.push(p.y + dy, p.y - dy); }
});
cands.sort(function (a, b) { return Math.abs(a) - Math.abs(b); });
for (var i = 0; i = D * D - 0.01; });
if (ok) { placed.push({ x: x, y: y, d: d }); pos[d.id] = { x: x, y: y }; break; }
}
});
var maxY = Math.max.apply(null, placed.map(function (p) { return Math.abs(p.y); }));
var annH = 8, axisH = 22;
var cy = annH + maxY + r + 6;
var H = cy + maxY + r + 6 + axisH;
svg.setAttribute("width", W); svg.setAttribute("height", H); svg.setAttribute("viewBox", "0 0 " + W + " " + H);
svg.style.width = W + "px"; svg.style.height = H + "px";
var old = svg.querySelector(".ag-pt-axes"); if (old) old.remove();
var axes = h("g", { class: "ag-pt-axes" });
TICKS.forEach(function (t) {
var x = sx(t);
axes.appendChild(h("line", { class: t === 0 ? "ag-pt-zero" : "ag-pt-grid", x1: x, x2: x, y1: annH - 4, y2: H - axisH + 2 }));
axes.appendChild(h("text", { class: "ag-pt-tick", x: x, y: H - 6, "text-anchor": "middle", text: t === 0 ? "0" : (t < 0 ? "\u2212" : "") + Math.abs(t) + "%" }));
});
svg.insertBefore(axes, svg.firstChild);
var dots = svg.querySelector(".ag-pt-dots");
if (!dots) { dots = h("g", { class: "ag-pt-dots" }); svg.appendChild(dots); }
AG.data.forEach(function (d, i) {
var c = circles[d.id];
if (!c) {
c = h("circle", { class: "ag-pt-dot is-" + AG.side(d), r: r, cx: 0, cy: 0, "data-id": d.id });
c.style.transform = "translate(" + sx(0) + "px," + cy + "px)";
c.style.opacity = "0";
circles[d.id] = c; dots.appendChild(c);
}
c.setAttribute("r", r);
var place = function () {
c.style.transform = "translate(" + pos[d.id].x + "px," + (cy + pos[d.id].y) + "px)";
c.style.opacity = "";
};
if (entered) { if (landed) c.style.transitionDelay = "0s"; place(); }
c.__place = place;
c.__at = SWEEP * (d.pct - sorted[0].pct) / (sorted[sorted.length - 1].pct - sorted[0].pct);
});
svg.__cy = cy;
}
function enter() {
entered = true;
var reduced = AG.reduced();
AG.data.forEach(function (d) {
var c = circles[d.id];
c.style.transitionDelay = reduced ? "0s" : Math.round(c.__at) + "ms";
c.__place();
});
setTimeout(function () { landed = true; for (var k in circles) circles[k].style.transitionDelay = "0s"; }, reduced ? 0 : SWEEP + 950);
}
function select(d) {
sel = d;
for (var k in circles) circles[k].classList.toggle("is-on", sel && +k === sel.id);
svg.classList.toggle("ag-pt-dim", !!sel);
if (sel) circles[sel.id].parentNode.appendChild(circles[sel.id]);
drawCard();
}
function nearest(evt) {
var b = svg.getBoundingClientRect(), x = evt.clientX - b.left, y = evt.clientY - b.top, best = null, bd = 22 * 22;
AG.data.forEach(function (d) {
var p = pos[d.id]; if (!p) return;
var dd = (p.x - x) * (p.x - x) + (svg.__cy + p.y - y) * (svg.__cy + p.y - y);
if (dd < bd) { bd = dd; best = d; }
});
return best;
}
svg.addEventListener("pointermove", function (e) { if (e.pointerType === "mouse") { var d = nearest(e); if (d && d !== sel) select(d); } });
svg.addEventListener("click", function (e) { var d = nearest(e); select(d || null); });
function outside(e) {
if (!document.contains(root)) return document.removeEventListener("click", outside, true);
if (!sel || (e.target.closest && e.target.closest(".ag-pt-svgwrap, .ag-pt-card, .ag-pt-find"))) return;
select(null);
}
document.addEventListener("click", outside, true);
svg.addEventListener("keydown", function (e) {
var i = sel ? sorted.indexOf(sel) : -1;
if (e.key === "ArrowRight" || e.key === "ArrowUp") { select(sorted[Math.min(sorted.length - 1, i + 1)]); e.preventDefault(); }
else if (e.key === "ArrowLeft" || e.key === "ArrowDown") { select(sorted[Math.max(0, i -1; }) : [];
for (var k in circles) {
var hit = match.some(function (d) { return d.id === +k; });
circles[k].classList.toggle("is-hit", hit);
if (hit) circles[k].parentNode.appendChild(circles[k]);
}
svg.classList.toggle("ag-pt-finding", !!q);
if (match.length === 1) select(match[0]);
hits.innerHTML = "";
if (!q) return;
if (!match.length) { hits.appendChild(AG.tx("li", "shared.noMatches", { class: "ag-pt-none" })); return; }
match.slice(0, 3).forEach(function (d) {
var b = h("button", { type: "button", class: "ag-pt-hit" }, [
h("span", { class: "ag-ink-m", text: d.mName }), " vs. ", h("span", { class: "ag-ink-f", text: d.fName })
]);
b.addEventListener("click", function () { select(d); });
hits.appendChild(h("li", {}, [b]));
});
if (match.length > 3) hits.appendChild(AG.tx("li", "pattern.moreHits", { class: "ag-pt-none" }, { n: match.length - 3 }));
}
findIn.addEventListener("input", find);
drawCard();
layout();
if ("ResizeObserver" in window) {
var lastW = 0;
new ResizeObserver(function () { if (wrap.clientWidth !== lastW) { lastW = wrap.clientWidth; layout(); } }).observe(wrap);
}
AG.onVisible(wrap, function () { setTimeout(enter, 120); });
};
})();
window.AG.mountAll();
While the data quality of the underlying surveys has improved over the years, it is still not very high, said Dr. Miriam Laugesen, a tenured associate professor of health policy and management at Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health. Because the committee’s process isn’t transparent, it is often unclear what evidence its valuations rest on. This leads to distortions of all kinds, she said.
“It’s not a government process; It’s not a federal advisory committee,” Laugesen said. “It’s just a committee that was put together by the [AMA]. It’s pretty unusual in terms of how policy is made.”
In particular, King said that the surveys have a very low response rate from some specialties and are only sent to a small subset of doctors. She has never received a committee survey in the 17 years that she has practiced.
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) has a core seat on the committee that determines RVUs. But most ACOG members are general OB-GYNs, who split their time between obstetrics and gynecology and typically operate relatively rarely. The surgeons who perform the bulk of gynecologic operations are subspecialists – gynecologic oncologists, urogynecologists, and minimally invasive gynecologic surgeons — who complete an additional fellowship after residency. They mainly belong to their own societies and don’t have a seat at the table when RVUs are being determined.
“From a purely cynical or economic standpoint, [ACOG] has no reason to advance billing for gynecology. It doesn’t represent a large portion of the practices of their members,” said King, adding that ACOG has been heroic in its efforts to obtain reimbursement equity for its own members. (One unintended possible result of that advocacy is that pushing for a smaller pay gap for services related to pregnancy has in turn sent the message that women’s bodies are literally worth less, and are less deserving of care when they’re not engaged in the god-given duty of reproduction.)
The result is that doctors in specialties like OB-GYN who operate infrequently are answering the surveys about complicated surgical procedures that gynecologic surgeons perform more frequently. King said that her surgical schedule aligned more closely with those of general surgeons. For example, she operates two to three times a week whereas, according to her, an average OB-GYN will likely operate once a month.
“So they’re not the right people to be answering these surveys. They [the survey committee and ACOG] don’t target the surveys to people who operate a lot,” she said.
Part of the problem with using surveys to determine a key foundation of medical reimbursements is that the data is self-reported by doctors. This is especially relevant when more objective avenues may be available. One of those avenues is the American College of Surgeons’ National Surgical Quality Improvement Program, which is an initiative that collects and manages key surgical data to track quality and improvement in surgical fields, including the actual time spent performing surgical procedures, making it a more definitive measure than self-reported surveys.
Dr. Shitanshu Uppal, a gynecologic oncologist and division chief for gynecology oncology services at the University of Michigan, and his colleagues analyzed 901,917 surgeries using both the National Surgical Quality Improvement Program as well as the self-reported surveys used to determine RVUs. They found that median RVUs per hour vary widely between specialties. Gynecology had the third-lowest median RVUs per hour of all the specialties studied. In effect, that means that gynecological surgeons are paid less for every hour that they work.
The researchers also found that compared to the operating times logged for real surgeries in the Surgical Quality Improvement Program, surgeons in certain specialties tended to report longer procedure times in the self-reported surveys sent out by the RVUs committee. Specialties that reported longer operating times were more likely to be awarded higher RVUs, leading to greater hourly rates of reimbursement.
According to Uppal’s analysis, urologists — a profession most often associated with procedures on men because their work routinely concerns the prostate and the testicles — reported times that exceeded the baseline data by a median of 20 minutes. By contrast, estimates from gynecologists only exceeded the actual time by a median of five minutes, meaning that urologists tended to overestimate their time spent in surgery by four times as many minutes. Generally, urologists earn much more than general OB-GYNs, who in turn earn more than other subspecialties like gynecologic surgery. Despite having access to reliable electronic records of operating time, Uppal and his colleagues note, the AMA committee still continues to use self-reported operating times, which influences their RVU recommendations, ultimately cementing disparities in female-specific procedures.
“The system that they have now developed over time,” King said, “now creates discrimination because of its complexity.” She added that this is how systemic discrimination is perpetuated, even if systems or rules appear seemingly neutral.
How low reimbursement rates make women’s lives worse
The US healthcare system has never been especially good at putting its money where its mouth is when it comes to women’s health. Experts have been sounding the alarm on sex-based disparities in medical billing for a long time — long enough that governing authorities like the committee responsible for RVUs and ACOG have had time to respond to the concerns.
Over the years, the gap between male-specific procedure reimbursements and female-specific reimbursements has decreased slightly. But researchers of the Price and Prejudice study showed that between 2003 and 2023, there were no statistically significant improvements to the pay disparities. Comparing a smaller set of procedures across 1997, 2015, and 2023, they found that the gap had narrowed only minimally.
One common justification that ACOG provides for the pay gap is that obstetrics and gynecologic services see a higher-than-average share of patients on Medicaid, which pays doctors less than other insurers. King agreed this is a real factor, but it doesn’t explain why Medicare itself values procedures on women lower in the first place. And as her account of double discrimination makes clear, undervaluing gynecology ultimately affects women everywhere for the worse.
“I have patients who are waiting for surgery with me for a year at a time. I mean, that’s crazy.”
Dr. Louise King
Lower reimbursements in gynecologic surgery disproportionately affect female surgeons because they represent a majority of this specialty. It’s not just the surgeons’ salaries that are affected. Hospitals and facilities work on a revenue-based model — if gynecologic surgeries are not bringing in enough money, institutions tend to allocate fewer resources to those procedures. That, in turn, can limit access to operating rooms, surgical staff, and operating times.
“I have patients who are waiting for surgery with me for a year at a time. I mean, that’s crazy,” King said. As a minimally invasive gynecologic surgeon, she surgically treats women with endometriosis, fibroids, cysts, or other such conditions.
It also affects the training that gynecologic surgeons receive. When there aren’t enough resources to operate regularly, opportunities to train residents are rarer than they should be. The result is that low reimbursement rates have contributed to a workforce of low-volume gynecologic surgeons who are sometimes not as well-trained as other surgeons who operate frequently.
The relationship between volume of surgeries performed and patient outcomes is well-documented in other fields. Research shows that surgeons who operate infrequently have worse outcomes, including more complications before, after, and during surgeries, compared to surgeons who operate regularly.
Low-volume gynecologic surgeons — who perform a particular procedure less than 12 times a year — have significantly higher rates of causing bowel and urinary tract injuries in their patients. Especially in benign gynecological surgery (procedures not related to cancer), having surgeons who operate frequently also increases the number of minimally invasive procedures performed, which is related to better patient outcomes.
Payment reform is an uphill battle, but not a lost cause
It takes multiple years and pressure from different entities to update or add new RVUs for procedures — but crucially, it is not impossible. The first few steps to creating a sustainable system might look like submitting gynecology-related procedure codes for reevaluation to the AMA committee or prompting a congressional report on the matter.
For example, for years there has only been one billing code for endometriosis, regardless of the complexity of surgery or technique used. This disincentivizes surgeons from taking on complicated surgical cases of endometriosis because of the low reimbursement rate. Reevaluating that rate or diversifying the various surgical approaches that different cases require would help affected women get the care they deserve.
Medicare’s payment system also has what’s called a budget neutrality rule, which dictates that significantly increased payments for any given procedure must be offset by cuts elsewhere. The AMA itself believes that reforming this rule would make it easier to work toward reimbursement equity for female-specific procedures.
Experts have suggested creating gynecology-specific conversion factors to bring parity to a system that naturally undervalues these procedures, while others think that eliminating sex-specific billing codes whenever possible is the right move. For example, the code for genitalia biopsies is different for men and women. This means that those procedures can be reimbursed differently even though they are essentially similar. Adopting one sex-neutral code for any genitalia biopsies would avoid this. While the reform required for this would be substantial, researchers believe that it would narrow the billing gap significantly.
Authorities often justify lower RVUs for female-specific procedures by pointing to training: Gynecologists spend fewer years learning to operate than urologists and other higher-paid surgical specialists, according to King.
Historically, surgeons who operated on the female pelvis trained in ways that were more closely aligned with general surgeons than OB-GYNs. When obstetrics and gynecology merged into one specialty in the 1900s, the training for gynecologic surgery was truncated.
“General OB-GYNs will train for four years and of that four years about 18 months is devoted to surgical training in gynecology,” said King, contrasting the new training period to those of general surgeons, which is in years.
She believes that training periods should be increased for gynecologic surgeons. That change would secure better reimbursement for the speciality, while also producing better trained surgeons who would be more attuned to advances in minimally invasive surgery that will ultimately improve the outcomes for their female patients. In some cases, the experience gained during a two-year fellowship in gynecologic surgery was equivalent to 19 years in practice.
In their initial work on double discrimination, Watson and King argued that failing to implement solutions for parity is tantamount to saying that female patients deserve less well-trained surgeons than male patients.
As with most women’s health issues, it is unclear if this systemic disparity in medical reimbursement is the result of conscious misogyny or a by-product of ignorance. But that question of origins matters little when its consequences have been enshrined in medical policy, with lasting consequences for the practice of medicine more generally. We have allowed this wage gap to persist, even as many have sounded the alarm for decades. It is long past time to heed their warnings.
October 7, 2026, 5:50 pm ET: This story was originally published on October 2 and has been updated to include the sourcing on the RVU gap resulting from training for gynecologic surgery.
Vergessen Sie die ewigen Probleme mit der Druckeranpassung. Super-Install versetzt Sie in die Lage, beliebige ASCII-Werte zu ändern und sorgt dafür, daß die entsprechenden Zeichen auch wie gewünscht auf dem Drucker erscheinen.
In the 6th inning last night the Yankees were only ahead 2-0, and Red Sox first baseman and all-around jackass Willson Contreras hit a home run, closing it to 2-1. Contreras decided to walk around the bases. The baseball gods do not look kindly upon that sort of ostentatiously belligerent showboatery. (Especially when your team is still losing.) Contreras circled the bags after his dinger like a rooster letting you know he just banged a few hens — but at a slower pace.
In the next inning, Contreras wasn’t paying attention and his laziness allowed a Yankee to reach base after striking out on a wild pitch. That started the rally that resulted in the blowout final score.
Donald Trump waves to the media on the South Lawn of the White House on September 26, 2026. | Aaron Schwartz/Getty Images
This story appeared in The Logoff, a daily newsletter that helps you stay informed about the Trump administration without letting political news take over your life. Subscribe here.
Welcome to The Logoff: Donald Trump is once again selling access to the highest bidder(s).
What’s happening? On Thursday, the Washington Sun’s Jeff Stein reported that Trump will reprise his 2025 “crypto dinner” later this year, hosting some of the top investors in the $TRUMP memecoin at his Virginia golf club.
The top 185 holders of $TRUMP will receive an invite to the event, which the website describes as the “Most EXCLUSIVE DINNER IN THE WORLD.” The top 29 $TRUMP holders will also be eligible for a “special VIP reception.”
What is $TRUMP? As my colleague Adam Clark Estes explained last year, memecoins like $TRUMP are “all but make-believe.” The coin is a crypto token, or “a type of digital asset that’s built on a cryptocurrency’s blockchain, but it is not a full featured cryptocurrency, like bitcoin.”
In other words, buying it doesn’t get you very much — the value of the coin has collapsed since early last year when Trump took office — but it will get you a chance to have dinner with the president.
What’s the context? This will be the third major event Trump has hosted for buyers of $TRUMP, following a May 2025 dinner at his Virginia club and a “crypto and business conference” earlier this year at Mar-a-Lago, where Trump gave a keynote speech.
But it’s just one of the many, many ways that Trump and his family have found to enrich themselves through crypto: There’s also another memecoin, $MELANIA, and his lucrative crypto firm, World Liberty Financial, which received a $500 million investment from a member of the United Arab Emirates royal family last year.
Strictly speaking, as Stein points out, Trump himself does not own the company minting $TRUMP, though he still profits handsomely, to the tune of $636 million last year, from transaction fees and other revenue. And he’s made even more off World Liberty Financial, which he and his sons do own, along with others: $799 million in 2025 alone, according to financial disclosure forms filed earlier this year.
And with that, it’s time to log off…
Don’t miss this story about “junk journaling” from my colleague Rachel Miller, a hobby that she describes as “a great way to cope with digital malaise and existential dread.” (Needed!) You can read it with a gift link here.
Plus: It’s a big day for Denali National Park’s sled dog puppies, of whom I’m a big fan.
People cast ballots on the second day of early voting in Wheaton, Illinois, on September 25, 2026. | Kamil Krzaczynski/AFP via Getty Images
This story appeared in Today, Explained, a daily newsletter that helps you understand the most compelling news and stories of the day. Subscribe here.
Depending on your political appetite and your geographic location, you absolutely do not need me to remind you of the upcoming midterm elections. But for those of you unencumbered by an unhealthy attachment to political news, and unassaulted by the onslaught of ever-more-brazen political ads, consider this your official notice that the midterms are approaching. Fast.
In less than six weeks, Americans will head to the polls to decide which party controls Congress, along with a slew of state and local offices. The stakes are arguably unusually high: Voters will choose whether to check the power of a president who has bulldozed over historical norms and limits.
So starting this evening, I’m partnering with my colleague Astead Herndon and Vox’s Midterms, Actually team for five weekly editions on the biggest issues shaping the 2026 midterms. Together with outside experts, we’ll break down one issue each week and suggest further reading and races to watch in November.
Up first, and without further ado: the profound shift that both parties have experienced since the 2024 election. These are not your mother’s Democrats. Or Republicans.
To kick this series off, I asked Astead to imagine a hypothetical world in which he hadn’t followed politics since 2024. (An outlandish counterfactual: Astead is acutely plugged into politics.) But in this alternate universe, I asked, what would surprise him most about 2026?
Easy, he said. The GOP’s disillusionment with President Donald Trump, who remade the party in his image.
Let’s put some numbers on that phenomenon, to start. Trump’s approval rating has dipped to record lows, even among Republicans. According to an NBC poll conducted in mid-September, just four in 10 Republicans strongly approve of Trump’s performance, down 11 percentage points from the spring.
Republicans have soured on Trump over his handling of the economy and attacks on Iran, which violated his promise to keep America out of foreign wars. Trump’s delayed release of the Epstein files also fueled distrust in his base by exposing his own ties to the dreaded “elite insiders.”
In response, some Republican candidates have worked to distance themselves from Trump, even defying him in campaign ads. But it’s unclear whether that tactic will win over disillusioned or disengaged Republicans. If enough stay home, Astead said — especially with Democrats eager to vote — Democrats could flip the House and/or Senate and make Trump’s last years in office far more difficult.
And speaking of Democrats…they’re also undergoing a major transformation after their 2024 presidential defeat. That loss disproved their previous theory of Trump-era politics: namely, that Trump’s rise was an aberration that competence, decency, and normalcy would eventually overcome.
By contrast, today’s Democrats want a party that “fights,” Astead told me. “The open question is who they’re fighting: The oligarchy? Big Tech? The Billionaire/Epstein class? Trump’s Republican Party?”
Democrats face ideological questions, too. Since 2024, voters have lost trust in the establishment and in party leaders’ ability to pick the best candidates; left-wing candidates have thrived in that vacuum. It’s pretty wild, when you think about it, that a Muslim democratic socialist in New York ranks among America’s most popular Democrats.
For both parties, then, November 3 is a test of their respective visions for America. Not just between the parties — as in, Republicans vs. Democrats — but within them, as well. That, in turn, will help determine the rest of Trump’s presidency…and the 2028 presidential election.
But it’s only October 1. Let’s not get ahead of ourselves.
➨ “Decant” your berries and asparagus. They’ll last longer with more space and air. It’s one of several gloriously simple ways you can reduce food waste without resorting to complex cooking projects or pricey “storage systems.”
Before you go…
Did you know…that octopuses’ arms are individually intelligent? When cut off, they can crawl away, grab food, and lift it to where an octopus’s mouth would be if it were still connected.
Today’s trivia: What constellation contains the North Star and Little Dipper? (You can find this and other brain puzzles in Vox’s daily crossword. Look for the answer in tomorrow’s edition.)
Yesterday’s trivia: Yesterday we asked you where Napoleon was exiled after his forced abdication. That was a bit of a trick question, since he was exiled twice: first to Elba, in the Mediterranean Sea, and then to Saint Helena, in the South Atlantic.
Alles über Ihren Computer zum Ausschneiden und Sammeln. Machen Sie mit, basteln Sie sich ein Computer-Lexikon. Im Laufe der Zeit kann so eine Kartei zum »Nachschlagen« entstehen, die Sie in einem Karteikasten sammeln können (Teil 1).