❌

Reading view

2026 SFPA Poetry Contest Winners

Science Fiction & Fantasy Poetry Association (SFPA) Logo, blue lettering over star fieldThe Science Fiction & Fantasy Poetry Association has announced the winners of its annual prize for poetry. Poems were judged in three categories, listed below.

Dwarf Form (10 or fewer lines):

  • WINNER: “Unauthorized Territory”, Michael Bailey
  • Second Place: “Communication Is Important”, F. J. Bergmann
  • Third Place: “Untitled”, Anna Cates
  • Honorable Mention: “Disillusioned Tribute”, Joy Donnell

Short Form (10 to 50 lines):

  • WINNER: “The Wind Always Returns”, Hinse Mutter
  • Second Place: “The Museum of Anomalous Objects”, F. J. Bergmann
  • Third Place: “Last Lowcountry Haunt”, Joy Donnell
  • Honorable Mention: “Cataloguing Lost Souls”, Colleen Anderson

Long Form (50 or more lines):

  • WINNER: “The Abyss Between One and Two”, Izzy Toy Retke
  • Second Place: “At the Cosmic Gallery Above Proxima Centauri b: After Dreamworld”, M. Frost
  • Third Place: “A Backdrop of Black Velvet and Rhinestones”, F. J. Bergmann
  • Honorable Mentions: “Ten Ways to End the World”, Kathleen Bryson         

The winning poems were announced on the SFPA website, along with commentary from contest judge Naomi Simone Borwein. The contest chair was Michael Hessel-Mial. 

The SFPA Contest awards unpublished poems from both SFPA members and non-members. Submissions are $3 a poem. Cash prizes are awarded: $150 for first place, $75 for second place and $25 for third place. See the SFPA Contests page for more details and updates. 

via file 770

  •  

2026 Salam Award Winners

Salam Award Logo, a ringed planet with purple backgroundThe winner, finalists, and honorable mentions for the 2026 Salam Award for Imaginative Fiction have been announced.

The winner is “All the Tears from the River Below” by Rida Altaf. Finalists are “Qitmir” by Eman Farhan and “Dreams of Dying and Waking Men” by Shahmeer Mahesar. The honorable mention is “Diesel Raven” by Abdul Kabir Qureshi.

The Salam Award, “a short story award to promote science fiction and related genres of writing in Pakistan,” is an annual prize open to original fiction of 10,000 words or fewer written in English by authors who must be “currently residing in Pakistan, or be of Pakistani birth/descent.” The award is named for Pakistani physicist Abdus Salam.

Judges for this year’s award were Christopher Golden, Robert V.S. Redick, and Karen Joy Fowler. The winner receives Rs 50,000, publication on the Salam Award site, editorial review, and potential publication in a magazine.

For more, see the Salam Award website.

  •  

Jemisin and Block Inducted into New York State Writers Hall of Fame

Empire State Center for the Book logoThe Empire State Center for the Book has announced Lawrence Block and N.K. Jemisin as two of the three writers in 2026 to be inducted into the New York State (NYS) Writers Hall of Fame, along with Kay Thompson (posthumously). The Hall of Fame is presented alongside the NYS Writers Institute, a literary organization that “enhances and celebrates literature, writing, and performance.”

The 2026 Hall of Fame selection committee included Matthew Baker, John Batteiger, Mildred Bernstein, Kevin Fitzpatrick, Paul Grondahl, Ira B. Matetsky Esq., Susan Polos, and Empire State Center for the Book director Rocco Staino.

Block, Jemisin, and Thompson will be celebrated at an induction ceremony on November 17, 2026 in New York NY.

  •  

Unofficial Command-Line Tool Removes Apple Intelligence From MacOS 27

Scharon Harding, Ars Technica:

Unlike with previous versions of macOS, macOS 27 Golden Gate doesn’t have a toggle for turning off Apple Intelligence. That makes disabling AI features that you may not want more difficult. It also means that the AI models necessary for running Apple Intelligence will take up space on your disk, even if you don’t use them or if you go through your settings to individually find and disable AI capabilities.

In response, a developer known as Om Lahore on GitHub last week created RemoveMacAI, a command-line tool that allows macOS 27 users to “turn off Apple Intelligence on macOS 27” in a way that is “fully reversible,” per the GitHub page. They said that Apple’s Intelligence models take up “about 12GB,” but the models can actually take up over 30GB, The Verge noted.

RemoveMacAI “turns off Siri, Writing Tools, Genmoji, Image Playground, the ChatGPT extension, and all the summaries, then it deletes the models and stops macOS from downloading them again. Dictation still works because it’s a separate setting,” the developer said in a Reddit post first spotted by MacRumors.

Sounds crazy but it’s not rming files in the /System/ folder — it uses techniques that work with System Integrity Protection remaining enabled. I mean, I wouldn’t do it on a production machine, but, I don’t want to disable Apple Intelligence.

I can see the reasons why some people are frustrated that MacOS 27 Golden Gate doesn’t have built-in support for disabling this and removing the local models, though. If your Mac only has 256 or even 512 GB of storage, a dozen GB (or more) is meaningful. And there are institutional groups that have rules against AI — these places aren’t allowing Golden Gate at all until and unless Apple Intelligence can be removed. And that means not buying new Mac hardware that only runs Golden Gate.

  •  

Expeditionen ins Reich der Daten

Die Schar der Mailbox-Jünger wird auch bei uns immer größer. Wenn man den Angaben der verschiedenen Anbieter-Firmen glauben darf, stehen in bundesdeutschen Wohnzimmern schon über 60000 Akustikkoppler. Grund genug, einmal nachzuforschen, was per Heim-Computer und Telefon so alles möglich ist.
  •  

Free/Open Source Software is great. Problem is, it’s also increasingly irrelevant

TLDR:Software geeks, parents, educators and lawmakers should get their common priorities straight and start to seriously work together to achieve what matters the most in an all-digital world. Here is what, why, and how.

Public service announcement: if you like my work, thanks in advance for one-time donations via PayPal (mfioretti@nexaima.net) or LiberaPay., which are even better than (still welcome) paid subscriptions. I am also available to work, speak and teach on the same topics: if interested, please email mfioretti@nexaima.net.

One-paragraph introduction to Open Source for readers who may not know it yet: Free/Open Source Software, or FOSS for brevity, is software whose full source code is legally available for everybody to study, modify, reuse and redistribute, even commercially. These possibilities make it much easier to find and fix software bugs, and make locking users into any FOSS software application almost impossible. Some form of FOSS has been around since when computer were invented, but FOSS was formally defined forty years ago, and tirelessly promoted since then, by people who strongly (and 100% correctly) believe that freedom of software is extremely important and the basis of many other freedoms.

Successes and limits of FOSS

These days, one may argue that the FOSS advocacy by the sincere defenders of freedom who have been promoting it for decades has been extremely successful. even for the billions of people who benefit from FOSS daily but couldn’t define or recognize it.

FOSS is, without doubts, what makes the whole Internet possible; Android, the operating system that powers almost every mobile device that’s not Apple, is (almost entirely) Open Source; the most successful FOSS product, the GNU/Linux operating system, reached 10 per cent desktop usage in North America this year (more details here), and some versions of Linux and LibreOffice should soon replace Windows and Microsoft Office on government desktops all over the world, from China to Netherland.

And yet, in spite of all this, and thanks in no negligible part to the very availability of FOSS...

FOSS is used to make the perfect police state, because freedom rightly means one cannot restrict uses. Facial recognition systems or automatic communication scanners used for mass surveillance in China and other countries surely use FOSS components. Even in the allegedly greatest democracy of the “First” world, the Flock cameras that remain a civil liberty threat function thanks to a modified version of Android.

People are dumbed down and alienated by software products, from social media to AI personal “assistants” of all sorts, that could have never been built so quickly and so cheaply without using FOSS.

We are all infested by software incompatibilities that should have never be allowed to exist, because they are the opposite of innovation, and create tons of really ridiculous frustrations and wastes of money. I could make thousands of examples here, but I’ll stop to the two that bug me most this particular week (add yours in the comments please):

  • car repairs that cost much more than they could because cars have become “smart”

  • “smartphone-afflicted parenting”: many posts on online forums for parents trying to protect their kids from online dangers in all ways but the right one specifically ask for solutions suitable for “an Apple family” or “an Android family”, as in “we’d love to give each family member the cheapest smartphone that would best fit their actual needs, but making two brands of software communication platforms communicate is too complicated”.

Free as in “free from censors and easy automatic spying” email is dying, and this is much more serious than you may think, because email is all but “obsolete”.

Systems like WhatsApp, Instagram, Signal, Telegram, Mastodon, X, BlueSky... are all very primitive, because someone with e.g. only an Instagram account cannot communicate directly with someone who only has one of the other accounts. That is, those systems all lock people into using the same maker and model of software device if they want to communicate, which if you think about it is as stupid as if smartphones from different makers couldn’t call each other, or if each radio station could be received only from its own brand of radio. Not to mention the idiocy of using phone numbers as account names, which I won’t rant about just because I already did, eight years ago.

Truth is, the only digital communication system that already exists, is already scalable to the whole planet and was already free from such cretin limits in the past century is email. Everybody can get all the email addresses they want, with any email provider they want, or even self-host their full email system, and still be able to communicate with anybody having any other email address from any other provider.

In spite of this, we’ve all managed, thanks to lack of adequate information campaigns, to let self-hosted, that is FREE email halve in the last decade: today, Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 together receive almost 40 per cent of the Internet’s inbound mail. In plain English, that means that just two for-profit companies, both (theoretically) subject to the same not-entirely-trustable government get to decide which email is delivered and which isn’t, worldwide. It also means that those two companies already have all your email even if you are not using the email accounts they provide, since at least 2014.

Subscribe now

Who is at fault here?

Nothing you just read is the fault of FOSS as such. In and by itself, FOSS is as great as it is necessary, and those problems are FOSS working exactly as intended, because freedom is freedom to do (almost) anything one wants, and for good reasons.

Those bad things have happened, and will continue to happen, because the overwhelming majority of both the general public and of lawmakers still have no clue about which measures would be needed to fix those problems. It is that ignorance that keeps regulators and parents worldwide chasing dead ends like age limits for social media, useless “data portability”, break-ups of companies that wouldn’t accomplish anything, lawsuits that let Big Tech keep doing whatever they want or (in Europe) digital sovereignty plans that look a bit too much like “let’s just ape the Americans, but without their money”.

Those who bears the greatest responsibility for the current state of things are, of course, the people in charge, that is lawmakers and government officials around the world. But they aren’t alone.

As far as FOSS goes, my actual and only issue with almost all traditional FOSS advocates is that, even if they surely have the knowledge to see both the real nature of certain problems, and to propose real solutions, they haven’t done, for decades now, all they could and should have done to lessen the general ignorance around digital issues that were both bigger and (in the last two decades at least) more urgent than how to write and license software. In the long run, exclusive, laser-like focus on the freedom to write, modify, reuse and share software code can only backfire... just as it is already doing.

What should happen instead

Concretely, here are the first things (add yours in the comments, please!) on which I think FOSS advocates, parents, teachers and lawmakers should start to seriously work together in order to make the world an actually better place that still gets all the real benefits of advanced digital technology:

  • immediately end access to general purpose AI chatbots for the general public. The real problem with AI today, after the childish, sociopathic minds of its creators of course, is letting it loose on masses absolutely unprepared to handle it

  • mandatory adversarial interoperability for all digital platforms, from social media to “smart home” systems

  • prohibition of infinite scrolling and other addictive features in social media platforms

  • mandatory use of open document formats by public administrations

  • prohibition for every public official, from the White House and Bruxelles to the most remote villages, of the really dumb and dangerous practice of communicating primarily through social media, instead of official websites and RSS feeds

  • Open Data by default for and by (at least) all Public Administrations

  • Personal Cloud policies that make possible for everybody to have what I first proposed about 14 years ago; really portable, personal clouds with PERMANENT DOMAIN NAMES

Please share this post as much as you can, both in and outside Substack!

Share

What all the proposals above have in common:

That’s easy: technically and legally speaking, none of them, except the last one, requires FOSS. But I’m sure that, had FOSS done more in the last 20 years to help lawmakers and voters to understand and consequently demand policies like those... by now we’d surely have both much more freedom in everything digital than today and, as one side effect, also much wider adoption of FOSS than today. So the sooner FOSS advocates, parents, teachers and regulators start to cooperate for real as I outlined in this post, the better for everybody.

As I said, I am available to work, speak and teach on these topics: if interested, please email mfioretti@nexaima.net.

Leave a comment

(*) For the record, I didn’t just wake up to certain problems this week…

I have been saying for two decades now that FOSS is wonderful but the canonical way to promote it is guilty of leaving the most urgent software problems we all have today grow undisturbed. Here are just some of the proofs:

Just an invitation... is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Just an invitation... is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

  •  

2026 National Book Awards Finalists

National Book Foundation logo

Finalists for the National Book Awards (NBA) have been announced. Categories, authors, and books of genre interest include:

Fiction

  • Paradiso 17, Hannah Lillith Assadi (Knopf)
  • Pretend You’re Dead and I Carry You, Julián Delgado Lopera (Liveright)
  • Mad Eden, Morgan Thomas (MCD)

Young People’s Literature

  • Holloway, Elana K. Arnold (Clarion)
  • When Tomorrow Burns, Tae Keller (Random House Books for Young Readers)
  • That Which Feeds Us: A Hawaiian Gothic, Keala Kendall (Random House Books for Young Readers)
  • The Fight of Our Lives: AIDS in America, Gabriel Duckels & David Levithan (Knopf Books for Young Readers)
  • Shook, Julian Randall (Henry Holt BYR)

Translated Literature

  • The School of Night, Karl Ove Knausgård, tr. Martin Aitken (Penguin)
  • Centroeuropa, Vicente Luis Mora, tr. Rahul Bery (Bellevue Literary)
  • Night of a Thousand Hells, Intan Paramaditha, tr. Stephen Epstein & Tiffany Tsao (Europa)
  • Pure Men, Mohamed Mbougar Sarr, tr. Lara Vergnaud (Other)

The judges for the Fiction award are Matt Bell, Caro De Robertis (chair), Danielle King, Akhil Sharma, and Diane Wilson. Judges for the Young People’s Literature award are Edith Campbell, Brandy Colbert (chair), Tricia Ebarvia, Jarrett J. Krosoczka, and Anne Ursu. Judges for the Translated Fiction award are Shelley Fairweather-Vega, Javier García del Moral, John Keene, Christopher Merrill (chair), and Azareen Van der Vliet Oloomi.

The Poetry and Nonfiction finalists were also announced, and Lifetime Achievement recipients Salman Rushdie and Perri Klass were previously announced. Finalists receive a prize of $1,000, a medal, and a judges’ citation. Winners, who receive $10,000 and a bronze sculpture, will be honored at the 77th National Book Awards Ceremony on November 18, 2026.

For more information, including the complete lists of finalists, see the National Book Foundation website.

  •  

Cover Reveal: The Cookout edited by Erin Brown, Emmalia Harrington, Tonya R. Moore, and P.C. Verrone

Cover of "The Cookout".

COVER REVEAL!

 Check out this delicious cover for The Cookout, edited by Erin Brown, Emmalia Harrington, Tonya R. Moore, and P.C. Verrone, coming out from Android Press!

Cover art illustrated by Ziziian, Cover design by Erin Brown

From the publisher:

“The Cookout” calls to something in our blood that unites us in love and community. Across the African Diaspora, with the fluctuations of ancestral knowledge and cultural roots, in wealth and happiness, in sickness and danger, in celebration and defiance, in every nook and cranny of the world, you’ll find The Cookout. But can it reach the depths of a Level 100 dungeon? Can we put picnic tables in the stars? Gather round the grill in another dimension? Source our seasonings in the furthest realms of our imaginations?

The Cookout: Speculative Fiction from the African Diaspora was edited by Erin Brown, Emmalia Harrington, Tonya R. Moore, and P.C. Verrone, with stories by Shingai Njeri Kagunda, Brent Lambert, Eden Royce, DaVaun Sanders, and many more!

[sponsored content]

  •  

Weekly Bestsellers, 5 October 2026

Tahir

Sabaa Tahir’s Empire (Putnam’s), second in a duology following 2024’s Heir, debuts on three lists, ranking #1 on the NY Times’ Young Adult Hardcover list.

Stephen King and Peter Straub’s Other Worlds Than These, to be published tomorrow, is selling on the Amazon sites today.

Title Debut / #wks on any list NYT
10.11
LAT
10.04
USAT
09.27
PW
10.05
Amz
(10.05)
UK:
Amz UK
(10.05)
Canada:
Amz.ca
(10.05)
Items on list -x- number of lists surveyed 10×3 10×2 150 15×3 100 100 100
Hardcovers
Bardugo, Dead Beat 09.28.26 / 2 x 6 +3 49 -43 22 -20
Bright, Wings of Reverie 08.17.26 / 8 4 +2 xxx.. xx
Brown, Red Rising (Deluxe Slipcase Edition) 10.27.25 / 49 xxx.. 68 +7 xxx..
Burke, Yesteryear 04.20.26 / 25 8 +3 x 43 -14 10 -1 26 -10 32 -3 13 -2
Dinniman, A Parade of Horribles 04.27.26 / 24 xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. x xxx 26 -11
Dinniman, Carl’s Doomsday Scenario 01.12.26 / 39 xxx.. xxx.. 62 -15 xxx 24 -8
Dinniman, The Butcher’s Masquerade 04.21.25 / 35 xxx.. 73 +6 xxx.. xx 87 -54
Dinniman, The Dungeon Anarchist’s Cookbook 02.02.26 / 35 14 = 54 -2 85 -49 25 +2
Dinniman, The Eye of the Bedlam Bride 05.26.25 / 33 xxx.. 124 -23 xxx.. xxx x
Dinniman, The Gate of the Feral Gods 03.24.25 / 37 xx xxx.. 65 -7 xxx.. xx 10 -1
Due, Mazywood 10.05.26 / 1 48 ++
Gillig, The Knave and the Moon 09.14.26 / 4 x xxx 71 -16 16 -3
Grace, The Wretched Divine 10.05.26 / 1 12 ++ 75 ++ 14 ++
Helm, Our Cut of Salt 10.05.26 / 1 141 ++
Hoffman, The Witches of Cambridge 09.21.26 / 3 xx 56 -17 x
King/Straub, Other Worlds Than These 10.05.26 / 1 25 ++ 71 ++ 34 ++
Kuang, Taipei Story 09.21.26 / 3 xx 9 -5 93 -40 24 -10
Maas, A Court of Forgotten Melody 03.09.26 / 16 xxx.. 23 +2 10 -2 35 -9
Maas, A Court of Splintered Harmony 03.09.26 / 21 xxx.. 2 +3 3 +1 2 +8
Mandel, Exit Party 09.28.26 / 2 x 2 -1 8 -6 21 -15
Marie, Ruinous Ends 07.27.26 / 11 8 +2 xxx.. xxx..
Mas, The Emperor’s Enemy 09.28.26 / 2 x 66 -47 x
Roberts, Powerless 11.20.23 / 111 xxx.. xxx.. 23 + xxx.. xxx.. xxx..
Rundell, The Neverfear 09.14.26 / 4 xxx 16 -2
Sanderson/Patterson, Blightfall 09.14.26 / 4 10 -1 xxx
Tahir, Empire 10.05.26 / 1 1 ++ 87 ++ 8 ++
Yarros, Onyx Storm 04.01.24 / 128 xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. 54 +14 xxx..
Yarros, Threshing Day 04.20.26 / 23 15 ++ 9 -8 2 = 1 =
Title Debut / #wks on any list NYT
10.11
LAT
10.04
USAT
09.27
PW
10.05
Amz
(10.05)
UK:
Amz UK
(10.05)
Canada:
Amz.ca
(10.05)
Paperbacks [tpb=trade]
Borison, Grim Tidings [tpb] 09.28.26 / 2 11 -9 45 -40 12 -10
Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451 07.20.03 / 508 xxx.. 114 -36 xxx.. x xxx.. xxx..
Brown, Red Rising [tpb] 05.02.16 / 49 13 -1 xxx.. xxx.. 93 +7 xxx
Buehlman, Between Two Fires [tpb] 09.09.24 / 32 67 -7
Clarke, Piranesi [tpb] 09.13.21 / 16 8 + xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. xxx..
Collins, Sunrise on the Reaping [tpb] 08.17.26 / 8 3 -1 x 47 +4 x
Dinniman, Carl’s Doomsday Scenario [tpb] 08.17.26 / 8 10 -1 xxx 11 = 74 -16 xx
Dinniman, Dungeon Crawler Carl [tpb] 01.12.26 / 39 4 -1 2 +1 11 +7 4 -1 27 -3 32 -3
Haig, The Midnight Library [tpb] 05.22.23 / 91 xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. 60 +
Jones, The Buffalo Hunter Hunter [tpb] 07.27.26 / 9 10 + xxx xxx..
Maas, A Court of Thorns and Roses [tpb] 05.16.16 / 286 15 -1 xxx.. 100 -6 xxx.. xxx.. 57 -7 95 -11
Miller, Circe [tpb] 09.06.21 / 108 xxx.. 5 -1 xx xx xx
Orwell, Nineteen Eighty-Four 07.20.03 / 595 xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. 89 +
Rowling, Harry Potter Box Set [tpb] 10.20.02 / 58 xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. 31 +
Weir, Project Hail Mary [tpb] 10.03.22 / 98 8 -1 6 + 55 -6 xxx.. 89 -32 xxx.. 72 +16
Yarros, Fourth Wing [tpb] 09.16.24 / 106 xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. 31 +44 xxx..
Yarros, Iron Flame [tpb] 06.02.25 / 67 xxx.. xxx.. xxx.. 60 +12 xxx..
Title Debut / #wks on any list NYT
10.11
LAT
10.04
USAT
09.27
PW
10.05
Amz
(10.05)
UK:
Amz UK
(10.05)
Canada:
Amz.ca
(10.05)

The table shows the current rank of each book and the change since last week, where:

= same as last week

+/- change since last week

+ back on list

++ new on list

x no longer on list (number of x’s: weeks off list)

All lists rank hardcovers and paperbacks separately, except for the USA Today list, which is a single list combining fiction and nonfiction in all formats. Dates shown are posted dates, except those in parentheses, which are dates compiled. New York Times posts its list one week in advance of print publication.

Note that some sources do not compile paperback bestsellers, and some exclude YA books (like the Harry Potter series) from their hardcover and paperback fiction lists.

  •  

Pluralistic: Swapping money for expertise (06 Oct 2026)


Today's links



The First Bank of Chicago, a Grecian temple to money. It is surrounded by flames. A skeleton in academic robes and mortarboards has been lynched from its roof. In the foreground are banded packages of US $100 bills.

Swapping money for expertise (permalink)

Since the mid-1950s, we have changed the thing that "AI" refers to every 5-10 years. The current thing we're calling "AI" is about a decade old, and all this label-switching leads to a lack of clarity as to what (this) "AI" is. Unless you know that, you can't understand AI's technical capabilities, limitations, and (most of all) its political economy.

The thing we now call "AI" is a lineal descendant of the thing we were calling "AI" immediately before the current "AI" emerged: that preceding AI is regular-degular "machine learning" (another flexible term, alas!). That slightly older AI was very similar to the current "AI", using comparable statistical techniques to analyze inputs and produce outputs. For example, the previous "AI" created the social media algorithms that have been the subject of so much discussion for 15+ years.

The difference is that this older AI was grounded in explicit, causal software models of the world. In the previous "AI" iteration, applying machine learning to playing chess required that a programmer first create a software model of a chess game, describing (in code) a chessboard, chess pieces, and the rules of chess. Then, the programmer fed a bunch of training data about chess games that had been played before to an "AI" system that analyzed their statistical relations and assayed chess moves.

The need to understand and describe a thing before you could apply "AI" to it is a bottleneck, because it requires programmers to understand how a thing works before they can incorporate it into an "AI" system. Lots of programmers know how to play chess, but far fewer understand the human pancreas, planetary weather systems, or patterns of mineral deposition in the Earth's crust.

For programmers to apply machine learning to these domains, they need to collaborate with experts who do understand them, who furthermore expect to be paid for this work. The need for expert input into this kind of "AI" represents a significant increase in the wage-bill paid by the programmer's employer: it means they have to pay for programmers and experts.

Even worse: this kind of "AI" can't be applied to systems we don't understand. We can observe far more causal relationships – instances in which A reliably causes B – in the universe than we can explain. There are lots of examples of us operationalizing these observations without understanding them. If you get sick today, your doctor might well prescribe one of the many medicines whose method of action is either incompletely understood or not understood at all. We know that molecule A reliably treats pathology B, but not why, and while that why is the subject of ongoing research, it's not necessary that the why be known before the molecule can be given to ailing patients.

But these mysterious phenomena are off-limits to "symbolic AI" (the previously ascendant kind of "AI," that was supplanted by today's "AI"). That kind of AI only really performs when it can operate over a model describing the theory of why A causes B (and not just the fact that A causes B for reasons unknown).

That's where the current kind of "AI" comes in. The major differentiator between the current "AI" and its immediate predecessor is that the current "AI" dispenses with models of reality. It is (in the jargon of the "Big Data" bubble that led to it) "theory-free."

In "theory-free AI," a programmer does not create a software model of reality and then ask a machine-learning system to use statistical insights from its training data to guess at how to operate over that model. Rather, the programmer shovels vastly more training data into the AI's inbox and uses titanic amounts of computing power to analyze that data and find statistical relationships without trying to explain them.

In other words, the current, "theory-free AI" finds all the instances in which A seems to cause B, but has no internal representation of why A causes B. This is true even when we know why A causes B! Purely theory-free chess programs don't operate with any conception of a board or pieces or rules – rather, they make guesses ("inferences" in AI-speak) about which chess move will be optimal based on vast, multi-dimensional arrays constructed by analyzing the statistical relationships between every chess move in their training data.

This yields a surprisingly good game of chess…until it doesn't. Because a theory-free statistical chess program doesn't "know" what a chessboard or a chess piece is and has no programmatic representation of the rules of chess, it will periodically move one of its pieces onto a square that is already occupied by another of its pieces.

When theory-free AI does this with language or image generation, we call it an "hallucination," but this is an extremely misleading metaphor. A biological "hallucination" involves some kind of misfire in your cognitive and/or sensory systems, often arising from chemical imbalances, intoxication, or neurological injury. When a theory-free AI puts a chess piece on a square where it already has a chess piece, that's because it's just extruding statistically founded guesses without any model or conception of what "chess" is. It's a feature, not a bug.

This is a very expensive way to make guesses! As far back as the 1950s, we were able to run conventional chess programs on computers built from vacuum tubes and electromechanical switches and these programs could play a valid game of chess without ever moving a chess piece to a square that one of its pieces already occupied. Modern theory-free AI that cannot manage this feat consumes heptillions of times more computing power.

That said, there's another case for theory-free AI: applying machine learning techniques to causal relationships we can observe but not explain. Remember, there are far more of these (as yet) unexplained causal relationships than there are perfectly understood ones. Theory-free AI can operate on these unexplained, observed phenomena in ways that the preceding (symbolic) AI can't. As anyone who's ever been successfully treated with a molecule whose method of action is partially or fully mysterious can attest, there's plenty of reasons to want to extract and operationalize these statistical relationships, even if we don't understand them.

The fact that theory-free AI can play chess but sometimes makes these weird errors makes it seem like a party-trick, but when you fold in the ability to operate on the (as yet) unexplained, you can see why people got interested in this about a decade ago.

What's more, the first bottleneck – the chess bottleneck – is most easily bypassed by adding the symbolic model back into the theory-free chess system. Today's "coding assistants" are hybridized in this way: they often integrate code interpreters or compilers that actually "know" what a computer program is and can head off many of these failure modes.

The introduction of these symbolic systems to theory-free systems is completely rational, and yet it represents an admission of a key limitation that theory-free AI cannot overcome. That limitation is both a technical fact, but even more importantly, it's a fact about theory-free AI's political economy: about the limitations of trading off expertise for money.

Because whatever else theory-free inference is, it is a way to swap the bottleneck of "before we can use a computer to help us do something, we need to find an expert who can explain how that thing works"; for a different bottleneck: "before we can use a computer to help us do something, we must spend an enormous amount of money on computing power to find statistical relationships between how things work."

Both money and expertise are scarce, but they are unevenly distributed. Expertise is almost entirely in the hands of people who aren't wealthy. However much money a billionaire has, they still have to hire people who have the "how to clean a toilet" or the "how to find seams of gold in quartz deposits" expertise. When that expertise is locally scarce (if there's only one person in town who know how to clean your toilet) or universally scarce (there's only one expert who can tell you which of your landholdings are likely to hold seams of gold) those experts have something that billionaires can't abide: power.

Our entire society is organized around converting money into power. Sometimes, that is overt, as when the wealthy can indenture or enslave a worker. Sometimes it is more indirect, as when the wealthy can enlist the state to limit union rights and enforce noncompete clauses in labor contracts. Sometimes it's so systemic as to be unremarkable and largely invisible, like the fact that the wealthy never have to work if they don't want to, but everyone else – no matter what expertise they hold – must work, usually for a wealthy person, lest they end up starving and homeless, with untreated medical conditions and no way to provide for their families.

Whenever a worker can say "no" to their boss, it's a sign that this system has broken down. This is where expertise comes in: a worker who has very scarce, in-demand expertise can say no to their boss all day long, because there are ten other bosses at the factory gates who'd like to offer them a job. This was the situation for many years among Silicon Valley engineers, who added an average of $1m/year to their bosses' turnover, and whose supply was very short of the demand for their rare expertise.

These engineers enjoyed all kinds of power. Not just power over their working conditions (free massages and kombucha and day care and dry cleaning), but also power over the company's products. This power crested in the late 2010s, when Google employees walked out en masse and forced the company to release them from binding arbitration waivers in their contracts, to crack down on sexual predators in the executive ranks, and to back out of billions of dollars in lethal drone projects for the Pentagon:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_Google_walkouts

The promise of theory-free inference isn't just about reducing the wage-bill associated with programmers: even more, it's about reducing their power. It's about removing their power to hold bosses to account for sexual assault and the power to withhold their labor from lethal military projects. In short, the power to thwart billionaires' desires.

AI is the money-losingest enterprise the human race has ever embarked upon. More than a trillion dollars has been spent this year to make a mere $50b in revenue. The technical excitement over AI's capabilities – from chess to gold-mining to treating pancreatic cancer – cannot be separated from the political excitement that billionaires (short on expertise, flush with cash) experience at the thought of swapping money for expertise and sidelining the only people in the world who can thwart their goals.

The fact that a theory-free AI might demand far more cash to accomplish a task (even a "solved" one like playing chess) than an expert would charge is beside the point. Billionaires have money, they don't have expertise. Theory-free inference is a bid to substitute one for the other: the beauty and terror of being able to manipulate the world without studying or understanding it is that it can be done with money alone. No experts needed.

In a world in thrall to financial power, expertise is the only substantial form of power that can reliably contest the power of wealth. Moreover, expertise is the foundation of other forms of power, such as labor power, which is what we call it when experts band together to combat financial power.

This is why AI bosses are so violently allergic to the idea of hybridizing AI with symbolic systems that operate on models of the world. These models of the world must be constructed by experts, and the power of expertise cannot be reliably commanded by the power of wealth.

This is even true when theory-free methods are applied to causal phenomena that we can observe without explaining. Sure, a pharma exec like Martin Shkreli or Arthur Sackler can command the production and sale of a molecule whose method of action isn't known but whose therapeutic value has been demonstrated. But to improve on that molecule, they must pay research scientists to study and unravel the method of action. Replace those experts with theory-free inference, and finance can emerge triumphant in the only forum in which it is routinely vanquished.

This is the political economy of theory-free AI. Without finance's infinite hostility to expertise, there would have been far less capital for theory-free AI. Experts who wanted to use theory-free AI to help them unravel and operationalize the causal universe could not have laid hands on the bales of $100 bills the industry is now shoveling into its money-furnaces at a rate never seen in human history.

Which is not to say that experts can't make good use of theory-free AI. Indeed, we frequently hear from skilled workers who are using "AI" to improve the quality of their outputs:

https://hrdag.org/tech-notes/large-language-models-IPNO.html

In automation parlance, these workers are "centaurs": workers who enlist technology to serve their needs. The centaur metaphor has the worker taking the role of the top half of the mythical man/horse, the half in which the judgment and decision-making takes place; while the bottom (horsey) half is given to the machine, providing strength, speed and stamina, but only at the direction of the human mind.

The unimaginable sums that oligarchs have committed to AI are mobilized in service to creating reverse centaurs: machines that enlist humans to serve them. If theory-free inference can substitute for expertise, then the humans the machines require to accomplish those tasks that elude computers will not have the power to set the pace of their work, insist upon humane working conditions, or reject work on unethical projects:

https://pluralistic.net/2025/12/05/pop-that-bubble/#u-washington

The joke's on the oligarchy, though. Because theory-free inference doesn't know about chessboards, chess pieces or the rules of chess, it can't be prevented from sometimes putting a chess piece on a square that's already occupied by one of its pieces. The "hallucinations" are intrinsic to and inextricable from theory-free inference, which means that the outputs of an "AI" can only be trusted if they can be evaluated by an expert, whose working tempo must be carefully modulated lest they fall prey to "automation blindness" (rapidly, repeatedly clicking "OK" until you lose the ability to spot mistakes):

https://pluralistic.net/2026/07/28/hitl-ers/#ai-ai-oh

Theory-free inference is technically and philosophically exciting: in their quest for a way to neutralize expertise with money, oligarchs inadvertently built a series of powerful scientific instruments that revealed a heretofore unsuspected degree of statistical regularity in the world:

https://pluralistic.net/2026/09/18/surprise/#wow-signal

But the remaining, stubbornly textured and rough edges of reality are where all the value is. The things we already understand about reality are, by definition, yesterday's news, and that's all a statistical model can do: project the past into the future. But everything exciting in the future is stuff we don't understand yet. The surprising functionality of theory-free AI is itself an example of this. The most interesting and valuable thing about theory-free AI isn't the things it can do, it's the systematic discovery and mapping of the statistically regular parts of reality, whose inverse provides a map of the irregular, surprising, poorly understood (and thus exciting and promising) phenomena in our universe.

Tomorrow's breakthroughs and fortunes lie not in merely operationalizing these causal relationships: they lie in understanding them. The point of theory-free inference is to give us the tools to replace that theory-freeness with testable, validated understanding.


Hey look at this (permalink)



A shelf of leatherbound history books with a gilt-stamped series title, 'The World's Famous Events.'

Object permanence (permalink)

#15yrsago Tempo: transformative, difficult look at advanced decision-making theory https://memex.craphound.com/2011/10/07/tempo-transformative-difficult-look-at-advanced-decision-making-theory/

#10yrsago Internet shutdowns cost the world at least $2.4 billion last year https://www.brookings.edu/articles/internet-shutdowns-cost-countries-2-4-billion-last-year/

#10yrsago Youtube took down MEP’s videos about torture debate https://web.archive.org/web/20160701000000*/https://marietjeschaake.eu/en/when-youtube-took-down-my-video

#10yrsago Yahoo didn’t install an NSA email scanner, it was a “buggy” NSA “rootkit” https://web.archive.org/web/20161007140143/https://motherboard.vice.com/read/yahoo-government-email-scanner-was-actually-a-secret-hacking-tool

#10yrsago The FCC helped create the Stingray problem, now it needs to fix it https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2016/08/fcc-created-stingray-problem-now-it-needs-fix-it

#5yrsago Scottish Limited Partnerships are still laundering criminal millions https://pluralistic.net/2021/10/07/markets-in-everything/#if-its-not-scottish

#5yrsago "Inclusive Access" allows textbook monopolists to permanently consolidate their gains https://pluralistic.net/2021/10/07/markets-in-everything/#textbook-abuses

#5yrsago DoS a federal agency, then charge for access https://pluralistic.net/2021/10/07/markets-in-everything/#no-th-enq

#1yrago They're just trying to earn a buck https://pluralistic.net/2025/10/07/take-it-easy/#but-take-it


Upcoming appearances (permalink)

A photo of me onstage, giving a speech, pounding the podium.



A screenshot of me at my desk, doing a livecast.

Recent appearances (permalink)



A grid of my books with Will Stahle covers..

Latest books (permalink)



A cardboard book box with the Macmillan logo.

Upcoming books (permalink)

  • "The Post-American Internet," a geopolitical sequel of sorts to Enshittification, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2027
  • "Unauthorized Bread": a middle-grades graphic novel adapted from my novella about refugees, toasters and DRM, FirstSecond, April 20, 2027

  • "Enshittification, Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It" (the graphic novel), Firstsecond, 2027

  • "The Memex Method," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 2027



Colophon (permalink)

Today's top sources:

Currently writing:

  • “Once Is Enemy Action,” a science fiction novel about the origins of modern technofascism. Today's words: 513 (22395 total).
  • "The Post-American Internet," a sequel to "Enshittification," about the better world the rest of us get to have now that Trump has torched America. Fourth draft completed. Submitted to editor.

  • A Little Brother short story about DIY insulin PLANNING


This work – excluding any serialized fiction – is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. That means you can use it any way you like, including commercially, provided that you attribute it to me, Cory Doctorow, and include a link to pluralistic.net.

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Quotations and images are not included in this license; they are included either under a limitation or exception to copyright, or on the basis of a separate license. Please exercise caution.


How to get Pluralistic:

Blog (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

Pluralistic.net

Newsletter (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

https://pluralistic.net/plura-list

Mastodon (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

https://mamot.fr/@pluralistic

Bluesky (no ads, possible tracking and data-collection):

https://bsky.app/profile/doctorow.pluralistic.net

Medium (no ads, paywalled):

https://doctorow.medium.com/

Tumblr (mass-scale, unrestricted, third-party surveillance and advertising):

https://mostlysignssomeportents.tumblr.com/tagged/pluralistic

"When life gives you SARS, you make sarsaparilla" -Joey "Accordion Guy" DeVilla

READ CAREFULLY: By reading this, you agree, on behalf of your employer, to release me from all obligations and waivers arising from any and all NON-NEGOTIATED agreements, licenses, terms-of-service, shrinkwrap, clickwrap, browsewrap, confidentiality, non-disclosure, non-compete and acceptable use policies ("BOGUS AGREEMENTS") that I have entered into with your employer, its partners, licensors, agents and assigns, in perpetuity, without prejudice to my ongoing rights and privileges. You further represent that you have the authority to release me from any BOGUS AGREEMENTS on behalf of your employer.

ISSN: 3066-764X

  •  

Dracula: October 6

Jonathan Harker's Journal.

6 October, morning.—Another surprise. Mina woke me early, about the same time as yesterday, and asked me to bring Dr. Van Helsing. I thought that it was another occasion for hypnotism, and without question went for the Professor. He had evidently expected some such call, for I found him dressed in his room. His door was ajar, so that he could hear the opening of the door of our room. He came at once; as he passed into the room, he asked Mina if the others might come, too.

"No," she said quite simply, "it will not be necessary. You can tell them just as well. I must go with you on your journey."

Dr. Van Helsing was as startled as I was. After a moment's pause he asked:—

"But why?"

"You must take me with you. I am safer with you, and you shall be safer, too."

"But why, dear Madam Mina? You know that your safety is our solemnest duty. We go into danger, to which you are, or may be, more liable than any of us from—from circumstances—things that have been." He paused, embarrassed.

As she replied, she raised her finger and pointed to her forehead:—

"I know. That is why I must go. I can tell you now, whilst the sun is coming up; I may not be able again. I know that when the Count wills me I must go. I know that if he tells me to come in secret, I must come by wile; by any device to hoodwink—even Jonathan." God saw the look that she turned on me as she spoke, and if there be indeed a Recording Angel that look is noted to her everlasting honour. I could only clasp her hand. I could not speak; my emotion was too great for even the relief of tears. She went on:—

"You men are brave and strong. You are strong in your numbers, for you can defy that which would break down the human endurance of one who had to guard alone. Besides, I may be of service, since you can hypnotise me and so learn that which even I myself do not know." Dr. Van Helsing said very gravely:—

"Madam Mina, you are, as always, most wise. You shall with us come; and together we shall do that which we go forth to achieve." When he had spoken, Mina's long spell of silence made me look at her. She had fallen back on her pillow asleep; she did not even wake when I had pulled up the blind and let in the sunlight which flooded the room. Van Helsing motioned to me to come with him quietly. We went to his room, and within a minute Lord Godalming, Dr. Seward, and Mr. Morris were with us also. He told them what Mina had said, and went on:—

"In the morning we shall leave for Varna. We have now to deal with a new factor: Madam Mina. Oh, but her soul is true. It is to her an agony to tell us so much as she has done; but it is most right, and we are warned in time. There must be no chance lost, and in Varna we must be ready to act the instant when that ship arrives."

"What shall we do exactly?" asked Mr. Morris laconically. The Professor paused before replying:—

"We shall at the first board that ship; then, when we have identified the box, we shall place a branch of the wild rose on it. This we shall fasten, for when it is there none can emerge; so at least says the superstition. And to superstition must we trust at the first; it was man's faith in the early, and it have its root in faith still. Then, when we get the opportunity that we seek, when none are near to see, we shall open the box, and—and all will be well."

"I shall not wait for any opportunity," said Morris. "When I see the box I shall open it and destroy the monster, though there were a thousand men looking on, and if I am to be wiped out for it the next moment!" I grasped his hand instinctively and found it as firm as a piece of steel. I think he understood my look; I hope he did.

"Good boy," said Dr. Van Helsing. "Brave boy. Quincey is all man. God bless him for it. My child, believe me none of us shall lag behind or pause from any fear. I do but say what we may do—what we must do. But, indeed, indeed we cannot say what we shall do. There are so many things which may happen, and their ways and their ends are so various that until the moment we may not say. We shall all be armed, in all ways; and when the time for the end has come, our effort shall not be lack. Now let us to-day put all our affairs in order. Let all things which touch on others dear to us, and who on us depend, be complete; for none of us can tell what, or when, or how, the end may be. As for me, my own affairs are regulate; and as I have nothing else to do, I shall go make arrangements for the travel. I shall have all tickets and so forth for our journey."

There was nothing further to be said, and we parted. I shall now settle up all my affairs of earth, and be ready for whatever may come....


Later.—It is all done; my will is made, and all complete. Mina if she survive is my sole heir. If it should not be so, then the others who have been so good to us shall have remainder.

It is now drawing towards the sunset; Mina's uneasiness calls my attention to it. I am sure that there is something on her mind which the time of exact sunset will reveal. These occasions are becoming harrowing times for us all, for each sunrise and sunset opens up some new danger—some new pain, which, however, may in God's will be means to a good end. I write all these things in the diary since my darling must not hear them now; but if it may be that she can see them again, they shall be ready.

She is calling to me.

  •  

America’s tallest, most spectacular trees are getting…heat stroke?

A redwood grove in sunlight is seen from below. Many of the trees are tall, with bare trunks that burst into branches filled with vibrant green leaves at their top.
A redwood tree grove at Roberts Regional Recreation area in Oakland, California. | Smith Collection/Gado via Getty Images

A grove of coast redwood trees is a forest of forests. Individual trees can live for thousands of years, and as they grow, their canopies develop mats of soils and ferns, creating something like a second forest floor hundreds of feet above the ground.

These elevated ecosystems are home to creatures like the wandering salamander, which can spend its entire life cycle on top of a single tree, and the marbled murrelet, a seabird whose nesting habits were a mystery until one day in 1974, when a tree-trimmer stumbled upon a nest 150 feet above the ground. Sometimes a stray seed — a sitka spruce or oak or even another redwood — finds its way up a massive redwood and grows into another tree entirely, nestled among the branches of a giant. 

For millennia, redwoods have been the anchors of this incredibly stable ecosystem; they can even survive wildfires that devastate other tree species. They’ve also been the source of plenty of human inspiration and drive millions of dollars to California’s tourist economy. But like other living things, they aren’t immune to warming temperatures, and it turns out these trees have a particular weak spot. 

A new study from researchers at University of California Davis, using measurements taken twice a month for two years, found that coast redwood leaves essentially dial down their photosynthesis during periods of extreme heat. This means trees are slowing their “breathing” and “eating” because they can’t cool down fast enough when temperatures rise. It’s a problem that’s only going to get worse as climate change continues to drive global temperatures up, and it raises urgent questions about the future of these iconic trees and the layers of life that live on and around their shadow-dappled lengths. 

How a redwood fasts

To understand what’s happening to the redwoods — and what that may mean for the species that rely on them — first we need to take a quick foray into tree anatomy. Trees use the pores in their leaves, stomata, to do two things: take carbon dioxide in, and let water out. Open stomata mean the tree is “breathing” in carbon dioxide and photosynthesizing, but probably also letting water out. Closed stomata mean the tree is conserving water but also slowing down its photosynthesis, since it isn’t taking in any carbon dioxide. 

“Because leaves are a physical, light-absorbing object, they heat up just like asphalt would in the sun,” said Lily Klinek, a PhD student at UC Davis who was the lead author on the study. 

“They’re heating up faster than the air around them,” she said. “And one way that they can cope with this is by opening their stomata and allowing water to transpire out of the leaf, which is kind of like the way that humans sweat. When water evaporates off our skin, it cools us down, and it’s the same for leaves. But they can only really do that if they have enough water to lose.”

Klinek and her colleagues studied coast redwoods in Mendocino County, near the southern part of their range, where the researchers used specialized instruments to measure whether or not individual leaves were photosynthesizing. During heat waves, they found, coast redwoods hit a point where they can’t cool down fast enough, and they just keep their stomata closed. While that saves water, it also means the tree isn’t taking in more carbon — which means it’s not “eating” or building up energy stores it can use to keep growing. 

This may sound like a technicality of tree physiology. But it could have a big impact on these forests, creating a vicious cycle where trees don’t have enough carbon stored to replenish their leaves in the future, which means they won’t be able to photosynthesize as efficiently, which will starve them even further, repeating until trees eventually die. And while this sort of behavior has been observed in tropical trees, it’s the first time anyone has studied how coast redwoods respond to the same heat stress. 

“The term people use is carbon starvation,” said Chris Still, a forest ecologist at Oregon State University who didn’t participate in the study. “Leaves can be expensive to build for a plant.” 

Most of the redwoods in California and the Pacific Northwest nowadays are new-growth forests planted in the last couple of centuries. That means the trees are relatively hungry, like growing adolescents, compared to their old-growth cousins, so they need to suck in lots of carbon dioxide to grow taller. 

Redwoods are also incredibly good at storing carbon. Thanks to their bulk and long lives, they store more carbon dioxide per acre than any other forest in the world. “Not only is it negative feedback on the climate system itself, with less carbon sequestration from these trees and forests, but the trees themselves are going to obviously not grow as big,” said Anthony Ambrose, a plant physiological ecologist and co-founder of the Ancient Forest Society. So even if the trees survive, they might not have as much space for fern and soil mats, which means less habitat for the creatures that live in them, and they may not grow as tall as they once used to, which could hurt them in another way. 

The fog of old forests

A central threat to these trees, Klinek explained, is that in addition to the heat stress, they may also lose a crucial source of hydration and protection: Coast redwoods have an intricate relationship with the fogs of their native Northern California and the Pacific Northwest. The trees are so tall that their canopies reach high into fog layers, where they can sip water directly from the sky. The fog also shades the trees from the sun and helps coast redwoods create their own microclimate, which is why these forests are noticeably cooler than the areas adjacent to them. But warmer oceans and drier air are making fog more sporadic, which means the trees are missing a crucial source of relief from heat that is only getting more intense. 

“It’s kind of a double whammy,” said Todd Dawson, a plant ecophysiologist at the University of California Berkeley, who also didn’t participate in the study. “They’re running out of water and also getting this heat stress,” he said. “They’re used to living in a very narrow temperature range of 8 to 27 degrees Celsius (about 46 to 80 degrees Fahrenheit). California, like everywhere, has been getting long periods of much warmer days than we’ve ever experienced, and now the fog, which is normally kind of like an air conditioner, has also declined between 30 and 40 percent.” 

These temperature swings also impact the organisms living high up in the trees. “If they experience really excessive heat throughout the summer,” Ambrose said, “then the soil mats and ferns will probably dry out much faster. And then those salamanders and birds might not be able to live there. So we’ll see cascading effects through the whole ecosystem at that point.”

Klinek said, the trees seem to be doing okay after the heat passes; while the leaves she and her team looked at over their two-year study didn’t acclimate to the heat, they also didn’t lose their capacity to photosynthesize after the heat passed. While that’s a bit of hopeful news, it doesn’t reduce the urgency of the need to better understand the impact of climate change on these trees, and to reduce the warming itself. 

“Right now the temperatures are coming back to normal in the fall and winter and letting the trees recover,” Klinek said. “But in five or 10 years, if temperatures are even hotter and heat waves are even more frequent, we don’t really know if there would be a recovery.”

For now, the salamanders and seabirds still have their homes high atop the coast redwoods. But we’re a part of the redwoods’ larger ecosystem too, even if we don’t live near them — they, like all trees, are key to keeping our planet hospitable. The trees Klinek studied have the potential to live for more than a thousand years. The question is if we’ll let them. 

  •  

Here’s How To Reduce the Existential Risks

Friends,

The most basic function of government is to protect people from harm. Two growing phenomena — climate change and AI — pose escalating risks of extraordinary harm.

Climate change is already causing floods, wildfires, drought, and record heat. AI agents are already escaping super-secure environments to hack into systems they’re supposed to avoid.

Yet Trump and his Republican enablers, backed by big money from Big Oil and Big AI, refuse to do a thing about either risk. In many ways, they’re worsening both.

But there’s another way to reduce these risks. It’s through liability law.

I have no more faith in the Supreme Court than you do, but I was struck yesterday by the responses of at least half the justices who will be considering an important case that opened the Supreme Court’s new term, Suncor v. Boulder.

The case was brought by several Colorado localities against Suncor and ExxonMobil — one of about three dozen filed around the country in which cities and states are demanding that Big Oil reimburse them for the escalating costs of climate disasters brought on by the burning of fossil fuels.

Yesterday, at least four justices (Alito has recused himself) expressed skepticism about Big Oil’s argument that the Clean Air Act explicitly prevents such lawsuits against polluters. “It’s like, wow, like, where is the text for that? Where’s the support for that? Where’s the precedent for that? Where’s the anything for that?” asked Justice Elena Kagan.

Chief Justice John Roberts drew parallels between Boulder’s claim and prior lawsuits against the tobacco and opioid industries in which states and localities won significant damages. “I’m not quite sure what makes this situation different from all those other ones where we’ve allowed them to proceed in state court,” said Roberts.

In 1998, the major U.S. tobacco companies agreed to pay $206 billion to cover public health costs and smoking-related expenses. When translated into current dollars, this is more than $423 billion.

And recall the $20 billion paid by BP in 2010 to cover environmental and economic damage to the Gulf Coast following the Deepwater Horizon oil spill. Or the $7.4 billion paid by the Sackler family and Purdue Pharma to resolve liability for opioids.

Such liability lawsuits — the last resort when the public is harmed by corporate malfeasance or nonfeasance — are also relevant to the risks posed by AI.

If AI agents escape super-secured environments to release dangerous toxins, or destroy critical water, electricity, transportation, or health infrastructure, AI companies and the tech giants behind them could be on the hook for tens if not hundreds of billions of dollars in payments to those who are harmed.

No way major investors in AI — or the insurance companies backstopping AI — are going to ignore this potential liability. The current dollar value of the tobacco settlement — as I said, $423 billion — is comparable to what the tech giants spent on AI chips, servers, and data centers last year.

This gigantic financial risk will weigh on the values of AI companies and the tech giants unless or until they become far more serious about protecting the public against such harms.

I expect political demands from the AI industry to limit such liability through federal laws that set caps on it and that establish industry-funded “trust funds” to pay for big liability judgments. A sane Congress (we may yet have one) wouldn’t agree without specific industry steps to dramatically increase safety.

In all likelihood, the AI industry will also seek government regulations it could use as partial defenses against such massive liability, just as pharmaceutical companies use certification by the Food and Drug Administration that their drugs are safe and effective to defend against lawsuits claiming their drugs cause harm.

The big AI investors and insurers will force this issue. More than 200 cases already in the courts involve cyber liability and AI-related product liability. Follow the money. Insurers are already demanding more effective means of controlling AI risks, and big investors are demanding better means of limiting them.

Both climate change and AI pose existential risks to human life on this planet. Liability law is hardly an easy or perfect fix, but it’s an important start.

The fact that liability for climate change is already in the Supreme Court and that four justices seem sympathetic suggests how significant a role liability can play as an incentive for both fossil-fuel and AI giants — and their insurers and major investors — to clean up their acts.

Share

  •  

Vielstimmig

Das Besondere an diesem Synthesizer ist die Tastaturabfrage: Sie ermöglicht es, bis zu drei verschiedene Töne gleichzeitig zu spielen.
  •  

Computer zu Computer (1)

Immer mehr Leser interessieren sich für Datenfernübertragung, für DFÜ. Diese Übersicht hilft Ihnen, sich fürs »Hacken« richtig auszurüsten.
  •  

Kürbiskern-Grahambrot

Der getrocknete und gemahlene Trester, der bei der Gewinnung von Kürbiskernöl eigentlich als Abfall entsteht, wird in diesem Brot gewinnbringend verbacken – für den Geschmack und die Gesundheit. Zusätzliche Kürbiskerne bringen auch noch das Mundgefühl in Wallung. 

Das Grahammehl (ein Weizenfeinschrot) sorgt für Biss und Ballaststoffe. Wichtig ist, dass der Teig gut ausgeknetet und straff geformt wird. Ist das der Fall, entsteht ein wirklich fluffiges Vollkornbrot für Kürbiskernliebhaber, das nur mit Sauerteig gelockert wird.

  •  
❌